5 ms·
What's the value of HFT? If exchanges were required to add a random delay to very trade to work against high frequency traders, would anything of value be lost?
by criddell 7y ago
What's the value of HFT? If exchanges were required to add a random delay to very trade to work against high frequency traders, would anything of value be lost?
- jstanley 7y agoIf exchanges added a random delay, that would mean traders have to plan for a longer time horizon, which means they need to offer more conservative prices. That means when you're selling, you get less money, and when you're buying, you get less stuff. Some people have this notion that if their trade got matched against a HFT that they have somehow lost out. The exact opposite is true. If the party on the other side of your trade was a HFT, then that implies that all other parties were offering worse prices than the HFT was. If the HFT had not been there, you would have got a worse price (whether on the buy side or the sell side). The presence of high-frequency traders (or any traders, for that matter) reduces spreads and increases liquidity. The only people who get worse deals as a result of high-frequency trading are people who would sell you the same stuff for more money.
- roenxi 7y agoHang on, that is conflating separate ideas. The substance of your post is describing price discovery - price discovery isn't the issue here. The issue is that the price discovery is being done in milliseconds. The substance of the complaint is the speed of the auction that discovers the price. The faster price discovery is being done, the fewer traders can participate. If a few milliseconds can change the value of a financial instrument then we have to accept that waiting a second or two will allow a lot more traders to reevaluate and offer a fair price. The HF in HFT looks like a play to reduce the number of traders who can act on information, which means the buyer/seller is probably getting scalped. HFT traders are making money arbitraging the speed of information dissemination, which indicates that other traders would offer different (/better) prices if the market waited a half-second or so to let everyone gather all the relevant data.
- growse 7y ago> The substance of the complaint is the speed of the auction that discovers the price. The faster price discovery is being done, the fewer traders can participate. The faster the price discovery, the shorter the validity time. This means a more accurate price. > If a few milliseconds can change the value of a financial instrument then we have to accept that waiting a second or two will allow a lot more traders to reevaluate and offer a fair price. You're making the mistake of assuming the price is static. If I have to quote you a price on an instrument that's valid for the next 5s, I have to be more conservative than if I'm quoting for the next 5ms. Which means you get a worse price. > The HF in HFT looks like a play to reduce the number of traders who can act on information, which means the buyer/seller is probably getting scalped. HFT traders are making money arbitraging the speed of information dissemination, which indicates that other traders would offer different (/better) prices if the market waited a half-second or so to let everyone gather all the relevant data. There's literally nothing stopping or limiting the numbers of players operating at this speed. What the race actually results in is all market participants getting smaller spreads and better prices.
- perl4ever 7y ago"The faster the price discovery, the shorter the validity time. This means a more accurate price." A continuous market price is an illusion; let's not forget that. Every market is made up of trades, which are discrete, and every price has an unstated amount of uncertainty, which may be large by any standards. You can't know from first principles whether a change in quoted price is even a change in the market, because it could be within the +/- range that's implicit. Apple is quoted to the nearest penny, at least, but the idea that the current price is accurate to within 0.004% is ridiculous. Edit: "Fischer Black famously defined an efficient market as “one in which price is within a factor of 2 of value, i.e., the price is more than half of value and less than twice value,” ...I hadn't heard this before Matt Levine mentioned it, but I was like "yeah, obviously, why haven't most people gotten the message?" But: "BNP Paribas...said [Saudi] Aramco was worth exactly $1.424394 trillion." I wonder which particular millisecond that held for. Edit Edit: The market has a whole (mostly) unseen dimension other than uncertainty, which is depth. You can only buy or sell so many shares at the instantaneous market price. Further away, there may be orders, but the price of the whole company is going to be way outside of that. The shorter the timescale, the shallower the "market" so you can't just say we're making progress by doing things faster. It's like when research lasers are said to make unbelievable power, but it's like for a femtosecond or something. Liquidity, in my mind, requires depth, just as with water.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- traK6Dcm 7y agoMany HFT systems provide liquidity. If there is no liquidity, retail investors like you or me cannot buy or sell. Just imagine you want to exchange a currency because you go traveling and the exchange tells you "Sorry, nothing available right now, gotta come back in a few weeks". That's what would happen if there is no liquidity.
- roenxi 7y agoIt isn't obvious that the retail investors are that excited by sub-second liquidity. Speaking personally, I'd even be happy to wait several seconds to see if someone else is willing to pay a better price.
- vecter 7y agoThat's not how things work. You would see much less demand/supply for a particular stock at every price level, which means you'd pay much more to buy less and would have to pay much more to sell less also. There are no upsides to having fewer market makers.
- roenxi 7y ago> you would see much less demand/supply Why? If the HFT firm was willing to offer me $X 2 milliseconds ago they are probably still willing to offer $X now. It isn't like there has been time for anything to change; there are going to be short periods of time where there is literally no new information. And they are just as likely to be offering me more now than less as conditions change.
- downerending 7y agoAs sibling said, it's liquidity. Worked at an HFT for a while, and they once got in a snit with an exchange over some policy change. They turned off their trading there one morning, and within 20 minutes, the exchange was on the phone begging them to come back.
- 1e-9 7y agoYes, adding delay generally lowers the economic value of markets. In addition to improving liquidity, as mentioned by others here, HFT also improves the relative pricing of related instruments. There is an enormous number of financial instruments traded for the purpose of prioritizing resources, transforming assets, and offsetting risk. Equities and cryptocurrencies are a small part of this connected financial universe. There are many trading entities with unique information and/or understanding about different parts of this constantly changing universe of prices. None of them has a complete view, but by communicating with each other through trading, their expertise is pooled. HFT speeds this communication network, which improves the dynamic consensus.
- munk-a 7y agoLiquidity, which honestly has very little value to a traditional stock market. HFT and day trading both just exist as rent seeking behaviors on company valuation growth.
- musicale 7y agoNot really. The real-world value of Google (or any other company) doesn't change meaningfully on a millisecond basis.
- rb808 7y agoThe liquidity from bots has replaced the human brokers. Sell side stock trader is a job that mostly no longer exists Eg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-30/goldman-trading-desk-that-once-had-500-people-is-down-to-three https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-30/goldman-t...