3 ms·
Intel set their embargo date to a day before AMD's embargo date, so early Intel reviews can't include numbers against AMD's next generation CPUs. (That would v
by jrockway 7y ago
Intel set their embargo date to a day before AMD's embargo date, so early Intel reviews can't include numbers against AMD's next generation CPUs. (That would violate AMD's embargo.)
My thought here was that AMD should have just moved their embargo back... but some reviewers would not have been prepared for that and we'd instead be watching a video about how AMD screwed them and they'll never review an AMD product again.
Intel was smart here. 99% of reviewers will not complain about this. LTT could have waited a day to release their review, but chose not to; exactly what Intel desired. Sure, he called them "chickenshit" but if you want to buy a new CPU today, you have no data about AMD's offering but you do see that Intel's 9th gen products are half the price now.
- alkonaut 7y ago> Intel set their embargo date to a day before AMD's embargo date, so early Intel reviews can't include numbers against AMD's next generation CPUs. (That would violate AMD's embargo.) Yeah I got that, but does "early intel reviews" really mean "reviews done in the first day"? Does anyone even care about waiting a day? Is it such a mad rush to push reviews online? I guess intel could also use it themselves in their marketing "look, 10980XE is faster as AMD" (even though that's only true for 1 day) and that I agree would be a little shady. But for reviewers and tech sites? Just wait a week if you want to compare? If your clicks go down because you wait 48h with a review to make it properly, that sounds like a serious problem... > LTT could have waited a day to release their review, but chose not to; To make a review is cool. You can just finish it with "Spec and perf comparison will follow in 3 days". You don't necessarily need to include bar charts comparing Intel to anything AMD just because you make a review.
- jrockway 7y ago> Is it such a mad rush to push reviews online? Yeah, it's a huge deal. You want to be selected by The Algorithm to be the authoritative review, and being early appears to help. Is that good? Nope. Can the reviewers change this system? Not easily. So here we are.
- teddyh 7y ago> Is it such a mad rush to push reviews online? From what I hear, yes. The first video with a review get all the initial clicks, and is therefore recommended over all later reviews, since they have a higher click count. This compounds, and any later review is essentially doomed to obscurity. > If your clicks go down because you wait 48h with a review to make it properly, that sounds like a serious problem... Yes, many people have complained about this phenomenon on YouTube, but YouTube does not seem to want to change it.