4 ms·
The problem with using height is that there is already evidence that taller people are more successful due to hidden biases. So perhaps the teacher measures we
by jedberg 7y ago
The problem with using height is that there is already evidence that taller people are more successful due to hidden biases.
So perhaps the teacher measures were still valid because all the tall people were more successful because of other biases in the system?
I'm mostly just being cheeky here. To be clear, I still think it's nearly impossible to measure how good a teacher is based on student performance, since the teacher is only one part of the equation, the parents (and the student's home life) being a much bigger part of the equation. The teacher can only do so much if the child comes home to parents that don't feed them and tell them they are worthless.
- telotortium 7y agoPerhaps, but the point is that the value-added statistics that have been used (in trials, I don't know if this was ever into a formal metric with consequence) to measure how much students' grades or test scores are improved by a particular teacher's performance show almost as large of a supposed effect of the teacher on height, not height on grades.
- jedberg 7y agoThe study says that the measure of teacher performance is correlated to student height. The measure of teacher performance is supposed to be correlated to student success. What I'm saying is that if student success is already correlated to student height, then anything that measures student success will also measure student height.
- JamesBarney 7y agoWhile what you say so true if they're ere just measuring student height/success. But they're not measuring student height/success they're measuring the effect of teachers on student success/height over time. And what you said isn't true of that measure.
- jedberg 7y agoStudent success over time is correlated to student height. It would be impossible to measure one without measuring the other.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scarejunba 7y agoHaha, just to play along, that means that the value added measures are just value captured measures, i.e. It's worse than before. Since a teacher has no effect on height, but height has an effect on ability, and height varies just as hard as ability then the variation is attributable to the height and not skill in any sort. I am, as always, quite convinced that teachers aren't that valuable. At least not the kind in public school. What I'd expect from a situation where there is wide variation in teacher ability is for them to form private schools where they extract massive value from the relationship because everyone will want the best tutor for their kids. This can probably happen. But normal teachers aren't it. It's the specialized tutors who get this value. Which means that perhaps all really good teachers become private tutors so you'd expect everyone else to be essentially unexceptional.
- beagle3 7y ago> The problem with using height is that there is already evidence that taller people are more successful due to hidden biases. IIRC, while it has been shown that taller people are more successful, and everyone says it is due to "hidden biases", those hidden biases were not in fact shown. A competing theory that I am familiar with, which provides just as good (if not better) explanation is this: Height is a (bad) proxy for healthy upbringing. Your maximum height is essentially genetically predetermined. But to actually attain that height, you have to have good everything growing up -- good food, good health. If you do not have access to nutritious food, or you are plagued with diseases that impact your growth (.. or treatment for them [0]), you will be shorter. So: Tall = Tall Genes + Good Environment Short = Short Genes + Good Environment ; or Tall Genes + Bad Environment Thus, tall people are correlated with good environment growing up, and shorter people less so -- and the theory is that it is the environment you grow up in that explains your success, rather than some hidden biases.
- iguy 7y agoAdult height is, as you say, a proxy for good genes & healthy environment. A noisy one, but not all noise. It's my understanding that this trumps the "hidden biases" idea (that height impresses people in job interviews etc. and this causes the correlations). But children's height might just be a proxy for age, or stage of development. 8th-graders are taller than 6th-graders, and do much better on 7th-grade tests.
- jedberg 7y agoThat's certainly plausible. But it doesn't change the fact that student success and student height are correlated. :)
- beagle3 7y agomost definitely true; I was only commenting about the "hidden biases" part.
- bsanr2 7y agoIANAS, but from what I understand, it's more complicated than that. A parent's or grandparent's childhood health has been shown to affect the growth and health of their descendents. These effects only go away after several generations of adequate nutrition and health. Tall women tend to give birth to larger babies not (directly) because of a "tall gene", but because of the physiological realities of their bodies (i.e., more space). We've recently identified several traits that are hereditary and that can stunt growth, but that had previously not been linked directly to a given family's shortness (e.g., sleep apnea and gluten sensitivity), and which have interventions much less radical than genetic modification. It seems clear-cut, and there are studies that link certain genes to height on a statistical level. But I suspect we're going to find that height has little to do with genetics in the traditional sense, and outside a few notable outliers, that there are no "short genes", just environments that fit specific genetic profiles that are or are not available to the people with those genes. Europeans are tallest in a generalized global monoculture where Western diets and lifestyles are the norm, and where European-descended populations have enjoyed a generally higher quality of life for several generations. Color me surprised.
- jcranberry 7y agoI vaguely remember a developmental psychology paper (I think) which attributed this effect to taller children being more likely to enter into leadership roles at a very young age.