6 ms·
This sort of thing happened long before technology provided mapping programs. I wonder if anyone is familiar with how these things played out in the days of pub
by dangus 7y ago
This sort of thing happened long before technology provided mapping programs. I wonder if anyone is familiar with how these things played out in the days of published maps? I’m no historian myself. But I’m sure some map publisher had to begrudgingly admit that “their side lost” at some point.
Here’s the thing, once enough time passes, you have to start to consider that Crimea may never return to Ukrainian control.
Just because Russia’s actions have been condemned by the international community doesn’t mean those actions weren’t taken and weren’t successful.
We have to admit at some point that Russia controls this territory now because, sadly, nobody did anything significant to stop it. Russia essentially fought a brief war and won, and took territory as a result.
It’s getting to the point where a map saying that this land is inside the Ukraine is an inaccurate statement.
- pjc50 7y agoMaps used to be, like telegraph systems, under far more aggressive state control in various places. I seem to remember that Turkey had a law against possessing maps at greater than specified resolution without a license. Even in present-day India I believe maps are required to show Kashmir with the Indian view, and customs may theoretically confiscate differing printed maps.
- reaperducer 7y agoI wonder if anyone is familiar with how these things played out in the days of published maps? Pretty much the same. Map is tailored to its audience. Visit a mid-tier antiques shop in a large global city (New York, London, Vienna) and you may see some old maps with some interesting borders. One of the walls in my home office has one of those big pull-down school maps of the Middle East. There isn't a date on it, but based on the borders it's probably about 80 years old. A number of... unconventional... names and borders on it.
- varjag 7y agoThe USA used to depict Baltic states as Soviet-occupied independent states on the maps, and didn't budge until USSR fell apart and the countries regained independence. Growing a spine to stand up for what is right helps. Appeasing a bully is certainly going to cement status quo.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoWhat do you mean by “re-gained” independence? They were part of Russia for centuries prior to that. That was them gaining independence for the first time since like the 1500s or so?
- MLR 7y agoThey were independent in the interwar period, technically lots of the Western USSR/former Russian Empire formed independent states after the First World War but only the Baltic states are usually considered to have been occupied by the USSR AFAIK.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoI believe they were all independent for at least a short time between WW1 and WW2.
- varjag 7y agoThey became independent around 1918 and occupied in 1940. Plenty of the modern European nation-states emerged in 20th century, including Poland, Norway, Hungary.. would you dispute statehood of those?
- pishpash 7y agoThe Confederacy also became independent for a few years, before being reabsorbed under the gun. How long do you keep depicting a fiction?
- brutt 7y agoWhen Russian Empire, AKA Jail of Nations, fall apart, all nations were officially granted power to make their own national countries. Then Russian Federation started war against these independent nations and captured most of them back, killing dozens of millions in the process, but existence of these new countries was not disputed (except for few ones, like Kuban People's Republic, etc). It's not same as separatism. It was similar to fall of other empires.
- kelnos 7y ago> sadly, nobody did anything significant to stop it. Why "sadly"? By all reliable accounts, the Crimean people would rather be a part of Russia. Obviously we'd prefer that land and people be transferred between countries via diplomacy rather than military action, but I don't feel like expecting that to happen in this case is realistic. (Obviously Russia didn't annex Crimea out of the goodness of its heart, of course. I imagine it was primarily for some form of strategic advantage, and Crimea being largely populated by ethnic Russians just made it both easier to accomplish and justify.)