3 ms·
How do you know what really influenced your life outcomes? We all have stories about a great teacher or a terrible parent. But these are anecdotes. You don't a
by jlawson 7y ago
How do you know what really influenced your life outcomes?
We all have stories about a great teacher or a terrible parent. But these are anecdotes. You don't actually know what would have happened if you had different parents, or different friends, or went to a different school.
It's perfectly possible that if circumstances were different, you would have gotten to the same place, by a superficially different path.
The specific stories would vary, of course. But when we talk about society-level policy, it's not specific personal stories that we focus on. It's things like income, marital status, job field, health, criminality. A lot of evidence suggests that even if your specifics were very different you would have actually ended up largely in the same place on these metrics.
- Ididntdothis 7y ago“It's things like income, marital status, job field, health, criminality.” Yes, it’s all of them. And they all need to be addressed instead of trying to pick the one all-dominant factor.
- godelski 7y ago> How do you know what really influenced your life outcomes? > ... these are anecdotes. Combine a lot of anecdotes and add in more scrutiny and we can call that data.