3 ms·
If it's possible to mathematically characterize the relationship, and the relationship is non-linear, then there exists an optimal hierarchical grouping algorit
by dTal 7y ago
If it's possible to mathematically characterize the relationship, and the relationship is non-linear, then there exists an optimal hierarchical grouping algorithm for maximizing empathy in nested groups (that balances the loss due to group numbers vs the "generation loss" from traversing hierarchical levels.
I think the difference in sizes between the organizational groups of different countries goes a long way towards explaining the vast differences in political flavor. How many people are in the smallest political constituency you identify with? Dozens? Hundreds? Millions? This is the range of scales we're dealing with.
What would it look like if we layered government so that at no level was any group larger than tribal size (~150)? In the US you'd only need 4 levels to cover the entire population, roughly corresponding to: neighborhood (150 people), town (~20,000 people), city/state (3-4 million people), country (327 million people). At that scale, each representative can be on friendly personal terms with a) everyone in the constituency they represent and b) every other representative at their level. So the access to government ought to be much better with this system. In the US, local and federal governments are divided - there's not a lot of continuity between the town government and your friendly local congressperson.
- crawfordcomeaux 7y agoMy friends/partner and I are designing neighborhood models to go along with these ideas with the goal of experimenting with them on land we give back to native tribes. I'd love to talk to you more about this if you're interested. My contact info is in my profile, if so.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI suspect that it would lead to massive corruption if actually tried both in personal enrichment and NIMBYism for everything related to "being the one to bell the cat". Localism is fashionable but I can't help but suspect it will only make things worse judging by every dysfunctional small town and city council working on ineffectual grand proclimations and unconstitutional ordinances instead of actual responsibilities like potholes. Related the disturbing root of the problem has been historically been not just the leadership that is objectively terrible and accepts bad outcomes for the sake of hurting the other but that frankly the people and the values they hold dear. Storm Thurgood even admitted that he tried running on things which would actually help them and got no real interest but running on racism propelled him forward.