3 ms·
That was my understanding as well - this goes back (or at least that's Khosla's argument) to before California became a part of the US. Interestingly, property
by refurb 7y ago
That was my understanding as well - this goes back (or at least that's Khosla's argument) to before California became a part of the US.
Interestingly, property right dating back to Mexican land grants are respected in the US as a part of the agreement that settled the Mexican American War.
I don't know enough to say whether that's a valid argument in this particular case.
- rayiner 7y agoIt's not only a valid argument, it's exactly what the California court of appeals held in this case. From the law review article I linked: > While the public trust doctrine can protect access rights over private land, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to extend that protection to private land certified under the 1851 federal law implementing the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, where the federal or state government had not asserted an interest in title proceeding. Therefore, the court of appeal in Friends I found that, because the Martin’s Beach property had been certified under the 1851 law without any mention of a public interest and never passed into state ownership, there could be no common law public trust easement over the land to the water. > And while California courts hold that Article X, section 4 of the California Constitution affirms and codifies “at least in part” the public trust doctrine of coastal access, “absent clear legislative intent to the contrary,” the access requirements do not apply retroactively.26 Applying this constitutional principle, the court held that section 4 could not protect public access to Martin’s Beach since it was passed decades after the property became privately owned.
- amznthrowaway4 7y agoWhy are you spending so much of your life parroting the bullshit arguments of an absolute fucking asshole? Do you derive any financial benefit from Khosla, or do you hope to in the future?
- refurb 7y agoAre you telling me we can't eat the rich in this case?!?
- stjohnswarts 7y agoThat's seems dumb since they taste so good in a proper bbq sauce and a good Chianti on the side.