4 ms·
> This is also about not changing the rules after the fact. There's lots of fair ways to structure a society. But it undermines notions of rule of law for the g
by michaelt 7y ago
> This is also about not changing the rules after the fact. There's lots of fair ways to structure a society. But it undermines notions of rule of law for the government to change the terms of the bargain after-the-fact.
Surely that happens all the time, though?
I mean, if I brought a car factory in 1950 is it unjust that the government changed the deal by forcing me to start supplying seatbelts in the 1960s?
- rayiner 7y agoOftentimes it's unavoidable. You operate businesses subject to the (legitimate) right of the government to create laws of general applicability. But there is a spectrum. In this case, a California court of appeals found that there was no "public trust" right to access the beach years ago. So what did the state do? It pursued a frivolous theory based on the idea that just because someone has been operating a public beach, they and all their successors must keep operating a public beach. That's not a law of general application "requiring everyone to put seatbelts in cars." That's abuse targeting a single individual and his property.
- WWLink 7y agoEminent domain on the land, buy it off the jackass, it'd probably save legal fees lol.
- schoen 7y agoThis reminds me of an old article by David D. Friedman, "Choosing Metarules for Legal Change". http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Metarules/Metarules.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Metarules/Metarules.h... It discusses some of the problems with both horns of the dilemma about changing rules.
- beerandt 7y agoAlso, treaties trump any state or other federal law.
- WWLink 7y agoKnowing HN, yeah, they probably consider seatbelts extreme big government overreach lol. "Let the market decide what safety devices people want! You're just raising costs for everyone with these unnecessary nannies!"