7 ms·
The debate is absolutely about property rights--the fact that the State of California doesn't have any basis to prevent him from putting a gate on his own prope
by rayiner 7y ago
The debate is absolutely about property rights--the fact that the State of California doesn't have any basis to prevent him from putting a gate on his own property: https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2193&context=elq https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art....
California courts have already held in this case that there is no "public trust" access to the beach, due to the peculiarities of land titles that originated in Mexico before Californian statehood.
A California court of appeals has now held that the State's other hook, the idea that the property was "dedicated to public use" is also baseless. That's what this article is about: https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/nonpub/A154022.PDF https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/nonpub/A154022.PDF
> That said, we have been tasked here with reviewing a trial court’s application of the common law of public dedication, which is the sole legal basis for Friends’ remaining claims in this case.
> We have endeavored faithfully to follow the prior holdings of our Supreme Court and fellow appellate courts in applying common law of public dedication principles here. However, we have not attempted to extend the public dedication doctrine beyond the common law parameters previously recognized by court decisions in this state. As strong as the coastal access policies of our state are, we do not understand them to empower us to do so.
There is no "rightful public access" to this property.
- iron0013 7y agoJust so everyone knows, Khosla's legal strategy, which rayiner is parroting with such wide-eyed credulity, is widely considered an absurd grasping-at-straws and has already been shut down by most judges it's been put in front of.
- harryh 7y agoOn the "dedicated to public use" issue Khosla won at trial and (as the bloomberg article says) also won on appeal. So it seems like at least some judges have agreed with him.
- rayiner 7y agoI'm literally just describing rulings of the california appeals courts, as described in the Berkeley legal journal article referenced in my post and TFA. Khosla lost a bunch of intermediate court rulings, and the Supreme Court denied cert with respect to collateral proceedings involving the Coastal Commission. But in two california appellate court wins, he knocked out both bases on which Friends of Martins Beach was claiming the right to public access of his beach. What's left?
- atomi 7y agoDid you not read the relevant portion of California's constitution? If any judicial ruling or people like yourself find any ambiguity to those words, we'll make sure to clear them up for you in future legislative acts.
- rayiner 7y agoPlease read the article I linked, it describes exactly what the California court of appeals has said in this case. In particular, the Supreme Court held that in 1984 that this provision of the California constitution can't override the scope of property right that conveyed from Mexico/Spain after the Meixcan-American war: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=12271413444378083765&q=466+us+198&hl=en&as_sdt=20006 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=122714134443780.... The California court of appeals has already applied that precedent to this case. That was resolved years ago.
- atomi 7y agoSo what? That's not to say Congress isn't able to resolve this through their own legislation. The judicial branch only interprets the law; they don't make it.
- beerandt 7y agoEven Congress can't override a ratified treaty with a law. Treaties are the law of the land. Edit: The president can unilaterally withdraw from a treaty, and Congress can certainly repeal a treaty (or even edit it) using the typical lawmaking process. But passing a simple law isn't going to override a treaty on it's own. And it would almost certainly have international repercussions. That said, in this case, the rights have already been granted to the property owners by the US in the form of a converted land patent, and changing that retroactively would almost certainly count as an expropriation / taking anyway. So you might as well expropriate from the get go, without going to the trouble of dealing with Congress.
- dang 7y agoPlease make your substantive points without crossing into name-calling. This is not a comment on the underlying issue, just the need to follow the site guidelines in conversation here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Incidentally, since https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=rayiner https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=rayiner is an appellate lawyer, his credulity seems unlikely to be wide-eyed.
- iron0013 7y agono name-calling here, boss. I very much agree with you that his credulity seems unlikely to be wide-eyed. I wonder how I could have better described his credulity.
- dang 7y ago"parroting" and "wide-eyed credulity" and "absurd grasping-at-straws" count as calling names in the sense that the site guidelines use that term: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html I don't think your comment needed to "describe his credulity" at all, because that's not the topic here, and it's a step into making the discussion personal, which is always best avoided in a disagreement. A better comment would have added more substantiating information about how judges have already refuted what rayiner was saying.
- refurb 7y agoThat was my understanding as well - this goes back (or at least that's Khosla's argument) to before California became a part of the US. Interestingly, property right dating back to Mexican land grants are respected in the US as a part of the agreement that settled the Mexican American War. I don't know enough to say whether that's a valid argument in this particular case.
- rayiner 7y agoIt's not only a valid argument, it's exactly what the California court of appeals held in this case. From the law review article I linked: > While the public trust doctrine can protect access rights over private land, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to extend that protection to private land certified under the 1851 federal law implementing the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, where the federal or state government had not asserted an interest in title proceeding. Therefore, the court of appeal in Friends I found that, because the Martin’s Beach property had been certified under the 1851 law without any mention of a public interest and never passed into state ownership, there could be no common law public trust easement over the land to the water. > And while California courts hold that Article X, section 4 of the California Constitution affirms and codifies “at least in part” the public trust doctrine of coastal access, “absent clear legislative intent to the contrary,” the access requirements do not apply retroactively.26 Applying this constitutional principle, the court held that section 4 could not protect public access to Martin’s Beach since it was passed decades after the property became privately owned.
- amznthrowaway4 7y agoWhy are you spending so much of your life parroting the bullshit arguments of an absolute fucking asshole? Do you derive any financial benefit from Khosla, or do you hope to in the future?
- refurb 7y agoAre you telling me we can't eat the rich in this case?!?
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- choppaface 7y agoThis is exactly how Vinod’s lawyers want you to see this: some complicated and interesting legal case. While you might be accurate about the details, it’s not within the public interest to see those details as relevant. The truth is that Vinod bought a property overestimating it’s value and this legal nonsense is how he tries to recoup from his mistake. It is not within the taxpayers interests to entertain him.
- beamatronic 7y agoSo you are saying he failed to do his due diligence?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maire 7y agoI don't see how Vinod is any different than the Sea Ranch authority in the mid 1970s. Precedent is not in Vinod's favor. The California Coastal Access law was based on Sea Ranch blocking access to the ocean in the mid 1970s. All building at Sea Ranch was blocked until Sea Ranch put in access trails to the beach. The temporary Coastal Access law was then made permanent. I don't feel sorry for someone of means buying property without any understanding of California state law. Vinod is claiming property rights he never had.
- rayiner 7y agoKhosla won on the key point of California state law: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/ca-court-of-appeal/1733249.html https://caselaw.findlaw.com/ca-court-of-appeal/1733249.html The appellate court held that his beach was not subject to California’s “public trust” doctrine due to title tracing back to a Mexican land grant before California statehood. That was in 2016. All the litigation since then had been only a different, much weaker theory that the Martin’s beach owners dedicated the property to public use. Khosla just won that battle too.
- bananabreakfast 7y agoWhy are you so ardently defending a man who is so clearly in the wrong here? He is so much of an asshole about this that he's proud of it and boasts about it to look tough in VC meetings. The spirit of the law in California is very obviously to provide public access to all beaches without exception. Good job on his lawyers on finding a weird ancient technicality to lean millions of dollars on but it's bullshit and he and everyone else knows it. Vinod is literally the evil heartless corporate billionaire in 80's movies who wants to bulldoze the small town rec center. He arrests surfers trying to go to their own public beach and brags that he's never even set foot on the property and couldn't care less about it besides the "principal" of property rights.
- m0llusk 7y agoWhy are you making this about character and personality. Vinod bought a property advertised as having particular rights associated. Does it have these or not? Clearly the courts should decide. Want to visit this beach urgently? Get a kayak.
- stjohnswarts 7y agoRightful public access is what the government of California is unless the federal government steps in and says otherwise. Vinod doesn't have a case really, he just has a stable of lawyers. It's probably just something to keep him from getting bored in his old age.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]