7 ms·
Set and setting. I believe it's important to realize that the "magic" is not in the mushroom. > "Of course, the drug dose does not produce the transcendent ex
by carapace 7y ago
Set and setting.
I believe it's important to realize that the "magic" is not in the mushroom.
> "Of course, the drug dose does not produce the transcendent experience. It merely acts as a chemical key — it opens the mind, frees the nervous system of its ordinary patterns and structures. The nature of the experience depends almost entirely on set and setting. Set denotes the preparation of the individual, including his personality structure and his mood at the time. Setting is physical — the weather, the room's atmosphere; social — feelings of persons present towards one another; and cultural — prevailing views as to what is real. It is for this reason that manuals or guide-books are necessary. Their purpose is to enable a person to understand the new realities of the expanded consciousness, to serve as road maps for new interior territories which modern science has made accessible."
~ Timothy Leary, The Psychedelic Experience: A Manual Based on the Tibetan Book of the Dead
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_and_setting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_and_setting
Drugs like LSD and psilocybin are the chemical equivalent of banging on the side of the box to make the TV work.
With proper set and setting you can get profound effects from e.g. a sweat lodge, or even just hyperventilation (I'm referring to Leonard Orr's Rebirthing breathwork. I would normally link to the wikipedia article on it but that's been defaced by capital-S Skeptics and reduced to a note crapping on the whole thing as "discredited". My dad actually worked for Leonard Orr for a bit and what he was doing was pretty profound whatever it was.)
On the one hand, it's great that the vindictive hysteria around psychedelic drugs is calming down, on the other hand I wish the scientific establishment had a little more epistemological sophistication when it came to investigating the inner world.
To sum up, the cure is not in the pill, it's in the set and setting. The pill just gives you an excuse. You can also use e.g. hypnosis, prayer, drumming, dancing, sweat lodges, or weird breathing, to effect the change you want, just to name a small sampling of the available modalities.
- justanotherjoe 7y agoThe pill is just an excuse? To do what? To chant and dance around? I don't think you know what psilocybin does to people.
- carapace 7y ago> The pill is just an excuse? To do what? To heal. > I don't think you know what psilocybin does to people. I think I do.
- voldacar 7y ago> I would normally link to the wikipedia article on it but that's been defaced by capital-S Skeptics and reduced to a note crapping on the whole thing as "discredited". a lot of Wikipedia is like this
- carapace 7y agoYah... "Planet Without Laughter" https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/smullyan.html https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/smullyan.html
- mistermann 7y agoAre you speaking from hands on experience with psychedelics?
- carapace 7y agoI don't like to give details on a public recorded forum, but yes, you can assume I am experienced in re: psychedelics. I'm also experienced in non-chemical, uh, procedures that have a dramatic and reliable healing effect. In this connexion I should mention, I was cured of depression by a single intervention by a hypnotherapist. I've talked about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20371167 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20371167
- mistermann 7y agoGood to know. What I find interesting in such conversations is the differences of opinions experienced people have about from where "the magic" is coming. > To sum up, the cure is not in the pill, it's in the set and setting. The pill just gives you an excuse. You can also use e.g. hypnosis, prayer, drumming, dancing, sweat lodges, or weird breathing, to effect the change you want, just to name a small sampling of the available modalities. I feel certain that you have far more background (than my zero) in these other fields, but despite fairly extensive reading on the matter, I have encountered very little that leads me to believe (and much that opposes the idea) that the magnitude of what can be practically achieved by the common man with these other techniques comes anywhere near to what can be achieved with an afternoon of reasonably organized psychedelic usage. To be clear, this isn't to say that I oppose such practices, or claim they have no value - I believe the exact opposite of that, they seem to also be tremendously valuable, but my intuition tells me that psychedelics have way better bang per unit of effort.
- carapace 7y agoThe whole problem (I'm pointing out) is that the bang is too potent and can go wrong. The kinds of insights and healing you get from e.g. Core Transformation Process or Feldenkrais Method may take longer but they're much safer and unlikely to have negative side-effects.
- funkjunky 7y agoIt's amazing how strongly people can have an opinion about something they have clue what they're talking about. https://www.pnas.org/content/113/17/4853 https://www.pnas.org/content/113/17/4853 Synopsis: no, actually the drug has a pretty powerful impact on your brain and is the main driver of the effect
- carapace 7y agoFirst, thank you! That paper is awesome, actual Scottish science. Cheers! Second, I would never begin to deny that "the drug has a pretty powerful impact on your brain", because that would be stupid. Third which "effect"? Your linked study "sought to investigate the acute brain effects of LSD in healthy volunteers", we're discussing psilocybin for major depression. So... what's up doc? What I'm saying is that getting high is not the best available therapy for depression.
- funkjunky 7y agoFirst of all, whether "getting high", as you put it, is or is not the best "available" therapy for depression is debatable, and not known at this time. Ketamine has definitely shown to be much more effective against certain kinds of depression than therapy, and much quicker acting, and I wouldn't doubt that psilocybin might also be. But more to the point, you were asserting that the effects of the drugs were secondary to the therapy associated with them, to which I strongly disagree with. The action of the drug itself is main driver of its therapeutic potential, specifically that of "breaking" normal heuristic patterns of activity, suppressing others, and allowing more inter-region connections and plasticity to flourish where non existed before. Most people can't do that very easily, if at all , with just therapy, meditation, diet, and exercise or whatever. However, I -CAN- do that, quite easily and without effort, without the guidance of a therapist or anything else, by simply eating some mushrooms and letting them do their thing.