3 ms·
> The law states there must be public access to the beach. Can you not access it by boat? Does that count?
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> The law states there must be public access to the beach.
Can you not access it by boat? Does that count?
- ghaff 7y agoNot sure why the downvotes. It's actually a reasonable question, the answer to which can vary by state. The details vary but, in some cases, having only water access to property--even if not an island--is considered access for purposes of the law. (For example, I believe in Maine it's OK to own a property that doesn't have a legal right of way by land.)
- mrguyorama 7y ago>I believe in Maine it's OK to own a property that doesn't have a legal right of way by land. Maybe that's state law but legal easement is required in many municipalities, for example Kennebunkport will not let you surround a property with other people's property with no access to public property (the road)
- yourapostasy 7y agoIt would be ironic if Khosla woke up one day to find a continuously-growing fleet of recreational and commercial boats including party barges with beach anchors, lights, speakers, generators and tons of booze using the beach, ferrying anyone who desired it to get to the beach from nearby beaches/docks, turning it into the worst destination party-scape he was trying to avoid tepid versions of in the first place. He just made it clear via the case that water access was permitted, he doesn't privately own the beach itself, and there are plenty of waterborne partiers in CA who would take him up on the "offer" of partying on an "exclusive" beach. People pay big bucks on cruises to get to "exclusive" beaches, and there are any number of "entrepreneurs" who will jump at the chance to turn a quick dollar to ferry people to exactly such a beach (albeit created through a legal technicality than natural features), plus throw in the gratuitous "ogle a billionaire's house" in marketing schticks on top to goose the customer buy rate. There might be a corollary of the Streisand Effect at work here...
- cwkoss 7y agoOr someone could anchor a dinghy with a billboard insulting Khosola and a bunch of cameras to livestream Khosolas property 24/7 online
- yourapostasy 7y agoHe probably could take that into court and have that action taken down. However, I'm not so clear that third parties wouldn't capitalize upon the exclusivity he just de jure created by restricting land access. But without actual ownership of the beach itself to turn it into private property, he might have unintentionally triggered a tragedy of the commons scenario, where he's raised the attractiveness of that particular spot of the beach without being able to charge and throttle access for it, and those third parties will be able to deliver that access and charge for it, without having to pay for the beach capex and opex itself. This has the potential to be environmentally terrible, and I'd rather truly not see that happen, even though if it does happen it would make others in this thread happy on how much a Pyrrhic victory it would represent for Khosla.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThat sounds more like harassment rather than legitimate use of the right to access a beach.
- hanniabu 7y agoI'm sure they'll then get you with noise complaints that the motors are too loud, then have boats banned from being within any meaningful distance of the beach.