4 ms·
Well, this is Hacker News, so it's probably unlikely that anyone here is particularly a fan of the Kardashians or Justin Bieber. Having said that, I think this
by keiferski 7y ago
Well, this is Hacker News, so it's probably unlikely that anyone here is particularly a fan of the Kardashians or Justin Bieber. Having said that, I think this is a good example of the fact that "there are opportunities in markets I'm not personally familiar with" - a problem quite common among programmers and technical people.
Kim Kardashian has 150 million Instagram followers. Justin Bieber has 122 million. Both monetize their followings for ungodly sums of money. You don't need to like them (and I certainly don't), but there are definitely startup lessons here worth learning.
- swiley 7y agoI think there’s a moral concern about this particular market. That’s reasonable, some markets may very well have moral issues because of hidden costs or externalities or because of the unreasonable power it gives certain groups of people (CFCs, fentanyl, targeted advertising, killing for hire etc.) These people would probably do better to spend that time improving themselves or looking at the amazing things and people near them that they could actually interact with, or if they have to idolize someone at least doing it to someone worth idolizing like an accomplished artist or philosopher. There’s a concern that I think I share with GP: these things are designed to put the viewer into a kind of consuming unsatisfied state that makes it easier to sell them things, and that’s probably a bad thing. I’m not sure celebrities are so bad, often good ones have good things to say. It’s not like we don’t have our own either: every time FB or RMS sneezes it gets posted on hackernews a dozen times.
- BoorishBears 7y ago>These people would probably do better to spend that time improving themselves or looking at the amazing things and people near them that they could actually interact with, or if they have to idolize someone at least doing it to someone worth idolizing like an accomplished artist or philosopher. How can you get this message to the unwashed masses with a horse that tall? I mean, where do you get off telling people who is worth idolizing? People have idolized less accomplished, less personable, less accessible people than those two since before media was a thing. To me Stallman is a toe-jam eating crackpot with no social skills and an embarrassment to all those who support him and does little to nothing worth idolizing, yet I'm in a forum where I'd probably find no shortage of people who idolize him. I'm not a fan of Justin Beiber... but are you really going to tell me he's not an accomplished artist? Man does the tone of this comment just rub me the wrong way. If following your advice means getting into a headspace where you don't cringe at the thought of telling people who's "worth idolizing"... maybe those fans are on to something...
- swiley 7y agoYeah you’re right about the Bieber thing. I realized that after posting. I don’t know, it’s definitely wrong to decide who people should idolize but part of me feels like that’s what’s going on with the most popular idols, that’s why I feel the need to warn them. There’s a good chance I’m just full of myself though.
- vorpalhex 7y ago> These people would probably do better to spend that time... We need to have a robust theory of human agency. That I play videogames with no moral worth or depth does not mean I don't also go to the gym, mealprep my lunches, or read philosophy in my free time. Likewise, just because someone enjoys zoning out and scrolling on instagram or watching celebrities doesn't invalidate their other time that they may spend in beneficial activities. Everyone has leisure activities that have no value - that's the point of leisure. When we start preaching to others, we've lost sight of what it means to be human.
- lghh 7y agoI'm a fan of Kim Kardashian. She somehow managed to build a an empire based just on her name. Then, she used that empire to fight to release people from prison and spread awareness for the Armenian genocide. I'm normally not one for "spreading awareness", but there are a lot of people who don't know about the Armenian genocide, and the US government won't acknowledge it happened in a unified and official fashion. She doesn't do anything particularly scandalous other than maybe being too materialistic. Her show mostly revolves around being there for your family. Overall, she's a net positive.
- throw_m239339 7y ago> I'm a fan of Kim Kardashian. She somehow managed to build a an empire based just on her name. It's not like she did not come from a very wealthy family… That porn footage wouldn't have been news worthy if she was a rando… One can still acknowledge her financial accomplishments yet, I wonder about her negative influence on young girls who will believe that a sextape or nudes are going to get them rich quickly like the Kardashian…
- BoorishBears 7y agoSometimes I read people's comments on her sex-tape and almost start to wonder if it's a form of subtle sexism. I mean, she had already been on reality TV before, her family already had the idea for a reality TV show, Ryan Seacrest had already expressed interest in producing the show (there was even a precedence for the show, "The Osbornes"), she already had a fairly successful career with extremely marketable skills. The 2nd movie Sylvester Stallone ever did, which he credits for saving him in the pits of desperation, was softcore porn, but I've never heard anyone say "I wonder if he's a negative influence on poor people who believe that softcore porn is going to get them rich quickly like Sylvester" It turns out having useful skills and a vision is what made them successful in both cases. There are plenty of people with famous, rich parents who never end up building billion dollar brands, do you really think a sex tape built a billion dollar brand? Isn't it a bit much to reduce all her accomplishments to that and think that will be the takeaway of her success?