10 ms·
> political system to organise itself to reward work done How do you decide which work is valuable and which work isn’t?
by kortilla 7y ago
> political system to organise itself to reward work done
How do you decide which work is valuable and which work isn’t?
- BuckRogers 7y ago> How do you decide which work is valuable and which work isn’t? By viewing the profits generated. As profits are nothing more than unpaid wages.
- _carl_jung 7y agoI invent (at the cost of $500) a programming tool that improves your output by 50%. This enables you to earn $5000 more per year than previously. You purchase that software for $1000, providing me a profit of $500. Who's wages are unpaid?
- theohofpleasure 7y agoIt's a company which makes the profit. If you started a company and sold the tool for $500 and the company paid you $500 then there is no more profit for the company. If the company paid you $250, only then can they claim to have made $250 profit. Hence, profits are nothing more than unpaid wages.
- _carl_jung 7y agoYou make a philosophical leap about rightful ownership when you say "unpaid wages". I don't agree with that leap. Further, your definition doesn't include situations in which there is no employee (such as the one I gave). It is more correct to say that the profit is the gains made to some agent in a market transaction.
- theohofpleasure 7y agoI don't entirely agree either. I was just expanding on the idea. However, when there is no employee, such as in the example you gave, there is also no profit. What you have called profit is actually your wage. Do I make a profit when I go to work for a company? No, I earn a wage.
- tathougies 7y agoYou can easily think of your wage minus your yearly expenditures as your profit, which, if you're doing things right, should be positive.
- BuckRogers 7y agoIt's never positive as your life is worth far more than those wages in all cases. That's why no one can be considered overpaid, or we would limit payment to CEOs. Thus wages can only be considered at best, a trade. That's why I asserted that profits are nothing more than unpaid wages. Since it's objectively a trade of your life for wages, paying others less than the value you produced is simply not valuing human life. The worst sort of theft. For your example, it doesn't hold up because most people only make enough to live, there's nothing to optimize other than going "full ramen". While others have far more than necessary for basic food, shelter and medical care. Those who are just-surviving aren't doing anything wrong, when an economic ponzi scheme simply doesn't value their life by paying them less than the value they produce.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>paying others less than the value you produced is simply not valuing human life. The worst sort of theft. And yet, both the planet and individual people are far wealthier today than when they were producing and receiving "full value" for their labour.
- BuckRogers 7y agoThat’s extremely loaded, and not true. I’ll unpack it all if someone is curious but in short your statement is only true if you define wealth in terms of faith-based fiat currency or define wealth as central bank issued scrip. There’s a reason credit is readily available. It’s a scheme that only works until it doesn’t, which is objective evidence that it makes for a very hollow definition of wealth.
- username90 7y agoA goes and buys flour for 100$ from farmer B. Then A goes and pay independent baker C 100$ to make bread from the flour. Then A goes and pay independent retailer D 100$ to sell the bread for $500. Each cycle A makes $200 in profit, nobody loses out as everyone agreed to the terms. This is enough margin for A to pay an independent manager $100 each time he repeats the process, ultimately netting A $100 without A doing anything. Is A taking advantage of everyone here? No, of course not, everyone still agreed to all the terms, A was just aware of a business opportunity the others were not, risked his own money paying for goods and labor he wasn't sure he could sell and now everyone is richer as a result. This is how businesses works. Of course in practice sometimes businesses does scummy things, but that is why we have laws which are meant to ensure that all businesses are net positive for society. If a business is not net positive then we send the police to them and shut them down. That doesn't work when businesses have politicians in their pockets, but it works in parts of the world where workers have more political influence.
- johncalvinyoung 7y agoThere's a word for this in economics. The 'normal profit' is the 'wages' of the entrepreneur and risk-taker -> the return on the money invested or put at risk, and the time and effort of the entrepreneur to build the business. Nothing immoral about that.
- anigbrowl 7y agoIn reality most people are not sole traders and the market does not operate under conditions of perfect competition. Over-simplification is not helpful; I could describe a similar virtuous circle based on entirely different economic arrangements, and it would be just as facile.
- claudiawerner 7y agoIt should be worth noting that this is a pretty strong (and I don't think defensible in the case given) claim to make - you're echoing the Marxist/socialist objection to profits (one which I may agree with) but Marx (nor anyone else) ever claimed that this happens without employing wage labour. For profits to be nothing more than unpaid wages, we need to be talking about at least one waged worker who applies labour, and his product is appropriated by his employer.
- _carl_jung 7y agoFor what it's worth, the principle objection I have to the Marxist position on wage and profit is the redefinition of the term "exploitation". It muddies the argument because it enables a circular argument whereby the transaction of employment can be labelled as exploitative, where it's easy to defend against the claim of exploitation if the original definition of the word is preserved. In other words, profit generation as it comes from an employer/employee relationship is Exploitative but not exploitative.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThe definition of "exploitation" is a technical one; even those who argue against the Marxist claim actually take this in stride, for instance, there is an objection to the Marxist idea of exploitation that Marx's selection of labour-power as the exploited commodity is arbitrary, thus we can say that any commodity (such as steel, peanuts or shoes) is "exploited" - the Marxist reply to this isn't to say "well, exploitation doesn't mean that, exploitation is evil and you can't be evil toward inanimate objects". In other words, I think the definiton used by Marxists is somewhere between the two. It not only means to use something up (to exploit resources) but also the Marxist idea that exploitation relates to workers being forced (by man-made historically arisen structures, that is) to sell their labour-power. Nevertheless, newer schools of Marxism (such as the ones from the 80s which attempted to use neoclassical economic models) have axiomatic definitions of exploitation. For some simplified models of a commodity economy, researchers such as Veneziani and Yoshihara (and Roemer on different grounds) prove that the axiomatic definition of exploitation is satisfied. Defined axiomatically, we can escape the talk about morality. But you can easily rephrase Marx without the word "exploitation" - the claim is, rather simply, that there is some amount of labour that is unpaid, this labour forms the substance of surplus value, which is appropriated. No judgement, no morality, no right or wrong - that's just the fact, and of course it may well be a good thing(!) that workers are "exploited" - Marx certainly said as much, when writing that the capitalist's point of view, his idea of "fairness" is just as worhless as anyone else's.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoProfits are the "wages of capital". No one pays companies wages. The owner or owners of a restaurant doesn't have anyone to pay them -- they have to arrange for their to be more in gross receipts than there are expenses or taxes; otherwise, they go under.
- staplers 7y agoBy giving out massively bloated defense contracts and subsidies to agri-corps.
- fladrif 7y agoNot OP, but my personal belief is that all work is valuable, otherwise it wouldn't be desired. I don't think it's a good exercise to decide how much it is worth, except to say that work that requires X unit of time should provide at a minimum an amount of compensation that allows a person to obtain a standard of living above the poverty line.
- s3cur3 7y ago> all work is valuable, otherwise it wouldn’t be desired. Have you had such a good experience with managers that you a) have never been assigned bullshit work that should have never been done, or b) have never seen a manager invent work to make themselves seem important?
- nine_k 7y agoIn my book, work has negative utility. It is something you tolerate to get the fruits of it, which may have positive utility. Being paid in exchange for work is the sign that otherwise the work won't be worth doing for you. The less work you do to achieve a desired result, the better. This is why technical improvements are valuable: they allow you do less work. There are activities that are rewarding by themselves, like playing games, watching the sunset, or otherwise having leisure. You are not paid for that, you sometimes pay for it yourself, and still it remains worth doing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoYou're describing the utility of work for the worker, and I agree with your description. But work also has utility for the person who pays the worker, and this is extremely different from what you've described. This difference in the utility functions for each party (one wants to maximise the return on work and minimize the work; the other wants to minimize the work and the cost on it) is what sets up most of the "classical" marxist class tension. This is despite their agreement that the less paid work that needs to be done, the better.
- cousin_it 7y agoGeneral rule: work spent on getting better at a zero-sum game is valuable to the player doing it, but if all players do it, the result is waste. Example 1: companies spending on advertising to increase their share of a fixed market. Example 2: managers hiring more people for their team to look more important within the larger company. Example 3: if social status is determined by looking tougher than others, everyone will spend resources to look tough. I think such waste is the main reason for failure of groups, and coordinating to prevent it is the main reason for success of groups.
- pas 7y agoAdvertising encourages people to spend, even in some times to do it by going into debt. This in turn leads to more economic activity, more widgets ordered, which in theory should mean we can reap benefits of economies of scale, we can better amortize costs, etc. Which leads to R&D and innovation, which helps technological change, which leads to a more efficient economy, which leads to more surplus, which means more wealth created, etc. Now, of course we could do this probably without spending so much on ads, but just saying ads are zero-sum is incorrect, because there's a bigger picture. Social status is again not so simple. Because after a certain group size there will be value in being different. See also the classic equilibrium between strategies in any game (as in game theory). That said, yes the race to the bottom is a real problem, see the oft cited Meditations on Moloch: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
- bad-joke 7y ago> which helps technological change, which leads to a more efficient economy You made a leap of logic here. The technological innovations in finance directly contributed to a more volatile economy that crashed and inflicted massive losses on huge swaths of the global population, many of whom never recovered.
- throwawaytoday5 7y agoNot too mention, at least in America, the vast majority of American lives are far worst off than they were in the 70s, 80s, or 90s. Making smart phones and personal computers just made rich people richer.
- jtolmar 7y agoI'd like to see what the market decides is worthwhile without capital ownership.
- vinceguidry 7y agoThe harsh truth is that your largest effects will always be local. What you do for your immediate family and friends will always dwarf anything you can do for society. To expect your day to day to serve a larger social purpose is to subordinate either your lifestyle or your cognitive integrity to something you’ll never be able to completely convince yourself isn’t a lie you’re telling yourself. If you can put your kids through college well-adjusted, you’re already doing better than most on that front. Beyond that, maybe maintain a few open source libraries for awhile?
- pas 7y agoThe big ideological divide in families (usually between generations) is a serious symptom of our inability to really communicate and compromise. In large part these ideological groupings are meaningless and inconsequential. Mostly because it doesn't really matter, for most of the people the feedback is very much lost in the noise. (There's institutional inertia, states are big, changes are slow, Congress doesn't change that fast anyway, the Senate is entrenched; and similar situations exist in other countries too.) And thus it's hard to reconcile how trivial it is that people don't see what's going on, yet they are the problem themselves. This drives people mad on both/all levels.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago"The big ideological divide in families (usually between generations) is a serious symptom of our inability to really communicate and compromise. In large part these ideological groupings are meaningless and inconsequential." I think this is only true in very specific circumstances. Ideological divide can also mean disowning your child for being gay, which is why among homeless youth there's a disproportionate amount of LGBTQ children and why the concept of "found families" is very relevant to the LGBTQ community. Certain families also will disown or withdraw from any member who doesn't follow religious teachings. Often times ideological differences is quite meaningful when it results in the abuse/neglect of vulnerable family members.
- pas 7y ago
- rout39574 7y agoReading a book on that question right now; 'The Value of Everything'. Might be worth a look.
- te_chris 7y agoExcellent book, recommend it as well!
- davinic 7y agoIt's not about which specific categories of work are valuable, it's about treating labor in general as more valuable than capital. Currently in the US, income from capital is taxed at far lower rates than income from labor. Why?