8 ms·
Massachusetts state police have been testing out Boston Dynamics' robot dog
- ovi256 7y agoIs there an ongoing development program for the procaine injector ?
- Animats 7y agoThey found an application! After 25 years! Probably not cost-effective, but at least it's getting used.
- lnsru 7y agoIf it can stop swatting, why not? A robot is better than scared and well armed officer.
- pluma 7y agoYou'd think the solution to "scared" and well armed officers wouldn't be more weapons. Tasers were heralded as a way to reduce casualties because they were a less-than-lethal replacement for guns, but now cops are still shooting unarmed people dead and using tasers as legal torture devices. US police doesn't exactly have a stellar track record when it comes to the equation "problems + more equipment = less problems".
- lnsru 7y agoI don’t think, that anybody uses a Taser in swatting situation. These are marketed in Germany as better replacement for tear gas instead of replacement for a gun.
- kuu 7y agoI'm not from US and I've never been there, but I think the problem is not only about police abuse. When you're in a country where almost anyone can have a weapon (and kind of the military range), the police also is having more risk than in any other country...
- pluma 7y agoI used to think that too, but the problem with gun ownership in the US tends to be more about gun culture than ownership. Other countries with high gun ownership rates don't have nearly the same problems, especially when it comes to accidental shootings. The problem of law enforcement killing people also has little to do with gun ownership. The frequent (or at least frequent enough to be concerning) shootings of unarmed black men for example are generally excused with police officers saying they were "afraid for their lives". This can only either be explained with terrible training or plain old racism (i.e. black men seem more threatening by default to the extent that an unarmed black man is considered more threatening than an armed white man), or most likely a mixture of both. There's a lot wrong with how police in the US is trained and held accountable. Gun ownership is the smallest contributor to that problem.
- krapp 7y ago>The frequent (or at least frequent enough to be concerning) shootings of unarmed black men for example are generally excused with police officers saying they were "afraid for their lives." Police officers only ever say that to lay the groundwork for a legal self-defense argument. >Gun ownership is the smallest contributor to that problem On the one hand, maybe, but on the other hand, it's difficult to stab someone from a distance, so the effect of guns as a force multiplier is relevant.
- CompanionCuuube 7y ago> Police officers only ever say that to lay the groundwork for a legal self-defense argument. Or on the other hand, being afraid for your life is one of the motivators for resorting to deadly force. > On the one hand, maybe, but on the other hand, it's difficult to stab someone from a distance, so the effect of guns as a force multiplier is relevant. It's a good thing that human beings are not equipped with appendages on their lower body that enable locomotion.
- maxerickson 7y agoMost working police officers in the US probably haven't fired their weapon in the line of duty: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/02/08/a-closer-look-at-police-officers-who-have-fired-their-weapon-on-duty/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/02/08/a-closer-lo... The idea that they are at particular risk from random people with weapons is not supported by statistics. The current level of violence pretty clearly (to me) justifies police having access to weapons. It doesn't justify using them quickly.
- ejsjxuxuduhgwv 7y agoCalling a robot dog a weapon is a stretch without more context. Why can't this be used as a communication platform to replace no-knock raids? You'd just need to equip it with a loud speaker and a short range radio for the most part.
- krapp 7y ago>Why can't this be used as a communication platform to replace no-knock raids? Because telephones and loudspeakers already exist, and law enforcement clearly doesn't want to replace no-knock raids, because they could already do so if they chose. This is just a land-based drone, expect law enforcement to put it to the same use as military drones - surveillance and violence. Maybe bomb disposal/retrieval.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> Maybe bomb disposal/retrieval. Don't forget bomb placement. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-texas-crime/no-charges-for-dallas-officers-who-killed-sniper-with-robot-bomb-idUSKBN1FK35W https://www.reuters.com/article/us-texas-crime/no-charges-fo... https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/8/8/20747198/philadelphia-bombing-1985-move https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/8/8/20747198/philadel...
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>You'd think the solution to "scared" and well armed officers wouldn't be more weapons. >Tasers were heralded as a way to reduce casualties because they were a less-than-lethal replacement for guns, but now cops are still shooting unarmed people dead and using tasers as legal torture devices. >US police doesn't exactly have a stellar track record when it comes to the equation "problems + more equipment = less problems". As much as I hate the entrenched corruption the MA state police stands for they seem to be content to waste taxpayer money on useless toys and enriching themselves (recurring falsified time-card scandal anyone?). It is thankfully very rare for them to kill people under questionable circumstances so I can't complain too much about them wasting a little more on a cool toy. This is kind of how the deal works, the state is basically buying their good behavior and letting them have toys a reasonable parent would say no to is part of that. I generally agree with you about giving additional hardware to police not turning out well for the people being policed though.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>Tasers were heralded as a way to reduce casualties because they were a less-than-lethal replacement for guns, but now cops are still shooting Tasers are routinely used to attempt to deescalate situations. The problem is though they just aren't terrible effective and often fail. Simply wearing thick clothing can't prevent penetration, distance and wind can prevent them from even making contact, batteries age, etc. An enraged suspect, such as one on drugs or drunk, can also rip them out of their skin or outright not be deterred. Here's one study that backs up what I've said above > A total of 2,395 use-of-force reports indicated conflict ended at the first “iteration” (the officers’ first application of force). In the first iteration, TASER’s were deployed 2,113 times. Out of these deployments, 1,459 ended the conflict at the first TASER application (69-percent success rate); chemical agents had a 65-percent success rate; impact weapons had a 45-percent success rate at the first iteration; takedown had a 42-percent success rate; and compliance holds had a 16-percent success rate. https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=246034 https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=2460... 69% on the first attempt, when the officer's life is potentially in risk (and anyone else at the scene), is a pretty lousy success rate. You can find more data (just be vigilant as the manufacturers like to muddy the waters with their own claims) if you'd wish to continue looking.
- pluma 7y agoIf you think using a taser is a way to "deescalate situations", you have a very different interpretation of what a "deescalation strategy" is meant to accomplish than most. TBH the problem seems to be that US police is often trained to "deescalate situations" by shutting them down quickly and forcefully rather than actually deescalating, i.e. carefully defusing the situation. Tasers are violent, less-than-lethal (i.e. potentially fatal) weapons. If they're ineffective at reducing casualties and decreasing the overall use of violent force, they need to be removed.
- ryanmercer 7y agoWhen you're confronted by someone larger than you, more muscular than you, that's enranged at their partner/coworker/family member and have been violent already and want to make you their next target, let me know how well trying to talk them down works 99 times out of 100. Less than lethal options exist because in some scenarios the fact of the matter is you have to deploy a less than lethal option, shoot them or get hurt/dead. While you might be able to talk your best friend down when he's mad that they put lettuce on his sandwich, that doesn't work when you're talking to someone that doesn't have respect for authority and is drunk/high/mad/mentally unwell and wants their way. - Pepper spray/mace, despite spraying in a stream, are NOT targeted devices. They will immediately spread to the surrounding the environment and while the intended target may take the brunt of it, everyone in the immediate area will feel it to some degree - Less than lethal rounds, like a rubber bullet, can be considerably more lethal than a taser - Tasers can miss, fail to seat, and yes can cause death in some circumstances - Bullets, at best, are going to cause permanent damage and at worst are instantly fatal. I urge you to see if your local law enforcement has a community outreach program and if they do to actually attempt to talk to some officers about the sort of things they deal with daily and how they personally feel about their various offensive tools. I come from a law enforcement family, I have many friends in local, state and federal law enforcement roles. The extreme majority of law enforcement officers hope they NEVER have to draw their firearm or even need to deploy a taser or spray someone but the fact of the matter is when police are called to deal with someone that is being disruptive, or actively attempting to harm others, they've already thrown reason out the window and there is a realistic chance they're going to attempt to harm the officer(s). A taser is a deescalation tool. Simply drawing it can be enough to back some people down although as the study I linked shows You've got roughly a 1 in 3 chance that even sending electricity into someone isn't enough to get them to comply after the first round. That alone should tell you something "shocking 1 out of 3 people causes them to continue to resist" is exactly why law enforcement carry firearms (again, that they hope they never have to draw and certainly never use).
- kace91 7y ago> A robot is better than scared and well armed officer You know how a lot of people is upset with companies like google for the lack of humanity of their moderation policies? like when a youtube channel is unfairly demonetised because an algorithm incorrectly flagged it? Imagine that, but with the choice to maim or kill.
- reustle 7y agoIt will be a long time until AI is making those decisions. In this case they'll just be a remote camera and maybe a taser?
- OJFord 7y agoThe article says that Boston Dynamics agrees with you, and has a clause in the lease agreement requiring that it not be equipped with weapons or anything to 'physically harm' a person.
- rburhum 7y agothis is definitely one of the few cases where I immediately stop trusting a private company and ask for heavy regulation...
- retSava 7y agoWell the lease agreement for our office has changed a couple of times just the last two years, also without actually needing a re-sign of the agreement. So I think that's a pretty weak protection.
- kypro 7y agoAnd Google said it wouldn't be evil, so you're either wrong or naive.
- OJFord 7y agoWell, I'm only as wrong as the article. I don't think I'm being naïve - at the very least it means that BD doesn't want the bad PR from being a robotic armaments company at the moment, which affords time for various groups to raise concerns, awareness, and petition for legislation guarding against it - also as mentioned in the article - on the other side of the agreement, i.e. disallow police forces from buying or using weapons that are not in the direct control of a human, or whatever the wording might be.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoLot cheaper than getting a cop/bomb squad person killed, preliminary investigation with risking a human is where these would work well I think and better than the tracked robots in use
- TYPE_FASTER 7y agoAnd technology has improved to the point where they can use a battery instead of a really loud internal combustion power source.
- ANY_TRUERS_LULW 7y agoThis thing is going nowhere. Should have been obvious when it was bought by S OMEGALUL FTBANK. But hey, le funny reddit gifs xDEDDDD
- fit2rule 7y agoSoon as these things get rat-thing sized, I'm going to be investing heavily in Reason. ;)
- serf 7y ago"As we learned in Vietnam, high-powered weapons are so sensorily overwhelming that they are similar to psychoactive drugs. Like LSD, which can convince people they can fly--causing them to jump out of windows--weapons can make people overconfident. Skewing their tactical judgement." Just don't go taking over any aircraft carriers.
- fit2rule 7y agoI guess its just a matter of time until someone builds man-portable particle accelerators that can, indeed, take on an aircraft carrier. Its going to be a very, very wild world to live in when that happens .. Sci-Fi seems to be a key factor in the inspiration of engineers. I'm left astounded at how quickly things proceed from "mm... feasible" to "on the market".
- ceejayoz 7y agoI'm more worried by the basement biology labs than the basement physics ones.
- ryanmercer 7y agoIndeed, and it doesn't even have to be someone trying to do something malicious like create a virus that targets a certain ethnic group. It's completely possible that someone trying to create something as a novelty causes some mutation that results in massive damage. Say someone is trying to create a glowing plant (there are numerous companies and individuals attempting to make these that glow bright enough to be commercially viable) and they accidentally encourage some mutation that can spread in the wild that ultimately results in creating a dead end in the species with a bunch of plants that can only be cloned and you end up with a precarious situation cough like we have with Cavendish bananas cough. Or what if someone is trying to cure their own disease and uses some bacteria or virus to deliver the gene edit to themselves and it also happened to pick up a mutation that makes it highly contagious to certain individuals and causes some unintended issue. Or someone wants to help sequester carbon so they try and engineer some incredibly fast growing tree (I know of people actively looking into this) and go plant some in the wild and create the next terrible invasive species like kudzu. Or someone actually sits there trying to intentionally create some super-bacteria or super-virus because they are mentally unwell and hate the world and creates something that makes the Spanish Flu's death count look like amateur hour.
- afroboy 7y agoThe real moment that i'm waiting for is when the USA army will start putting weapons over them and let them in the wild.
- lostlogin 7y agoIf anyone hasn’t seen the Black Mirror episode on this, S04E05, Metalhead, please do. It’s apparently based on this robot too, and it’s terrifying. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metalhead_(Black_Mirror) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metalhead_(Black_Mirror)
- thundergolfer 7y agoThat episode doesn't really explore the wider issue of autonomous weapons though. It's just a straight-faced action episode. I wouldn't recommend people watch it to "learn more" about things related to this article.
- ricc 7y agoI wonder how much gunfire it can withstand.
- swebs 7y agoThey'd have to test it out in Chicago, not Massachusetts.
- homonculus1 7y agoMassachusetts criminals have plenty of guns, if that's who these are actually intended for.
- Merrill 7y ago>Other than Spot, state police has a permanent fleet of robots. As of 2017, the bomb squad had 18 robotic platforms worth $1.8 million that are used on a weekly basis, according to police records. Most of those are tracked robots, not a legged robot like Spot. >But there’s something different about Spot. Calo, the professor, acknowledged there’s not a big operational difference between the robot dog and something like a more typically robot-looking PackBot. But, he said, Spot feels different. He pointed to a statement animal-rights group PETA put out, saying that it’s not cruel to kick Spot, because it’s not a real dog. The main difference seems to be that it looks like a dog instead of a miniature tank. This may give it some advantages in rough terrain, navigating stairs, etc. Otherwise, it is just another remotely controlled vehicle.
- icebraining 7y agoSpot is semi-autonomous, you can run a path once (including opening/closing doors) and then have it repeat it alone, handling (simple) obstacles that might appear.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoIf your instincts are telling you to be creeped out, there's a reason for that. Our brains are pretty good at recognizing threats.
- simion314 7y agoIs someone doubting that the boston dynamics also has robots with guns/weapons mounted that are tested in secret by military? The humanoid one what runs and jumps with guns in hands is a nightmarish image.
- MisterTea 7y agoA protest starts, people take to the streets, hong kong style. The police force, greatly outnumbered by the protestors, call in the "dogs". Armored trucks pull up, the sides slide open revealing a large hydraulic rack with dozens of "dogs" racked up and fully charged. Armed with tasers, pepper spray and tear gas, these little robot dogs are a cops best friend. The machine whirs to life, extends and unloads the "dogs" battle droid style, while a controlling human uses a RTS like interface to move the dogs into a formation and gives orders to begin herding the human protestors. In seconds, dozens, maybe even hundreds of these mechanical beasts gallop towards the protestors and begin a herding process not unlike a sheep dog. The attack is swift and chaotic to the humans but highly organized and planned by an AI system controlling them as a flock. Pepper spray and tear gas fills the air as people are chased and intimidated by the mechanical creatures. Protesters who dare attack the "dogs" are recorded by the dogs as they are all equipped with real time video and charged with destruction of police property after arrest. Facial recognition is used to locate high value targets such as political figures or organizers. The terrorfied humans are quickly disoriented, broken up and herded into groups. Surrounded on all sides by robot dogs, their arms raised with their tear gas/pepper spray nozzles at the ready. Finally the human police force rolls up in full riot gear and enough plasticuffs to wrap around the earth. The protestors are quietly arrested, no one was badly hurt, and not a single officer was scratched in the roundup. Suddenly, a scared protestor bolts past the line, prompting two dogs to instantly give chase and taser the offender. Easy peasy. It's not even noon yet and the protest is fully quelled. The same scene repeats itself all over the world. A man looks down from his ivory tower on the scene below, smiles, and sips coffee from his alphabet security branded mug. I weep for the future.
- germinalphrase 7y ago> Protesters show up with Tupperware bins and promptly begin capturing and subduing the dogs. I’m sympathetic - I guess - to your general point, but conflicts are dynamic.
- kitd 7y agoThen the dogs turn on their handlers ... and you have the makings of a Black Mirror episode.
- 7y ago
- pmoriarty 7y agoThis immediately made me think of the robot dog in F451.
- dTal 7y agoMy thought as well. But then, I finished it last night, so this is weirdly timely.