2 ms·
The problem is that everyone claims to want open silicon but nobody wants to put together the tools for custom VLSI which is where an individual can do interest
by bsder 7y ago
The problem is that everyone claims to want open silicon but nobody wants to put together the tools for custom VLSI which is where an individual can do interesting things.
Getting custom silicon in older processes (>150nm, but even 90nm has come down dramatically and that's a pretty modern process) just isn't that expensive anymore. It's under $50K, and can be under $5K if you catch a "shuttle" that one of the fabs runs.
The VLSI CAD tools, however, are ferociously expensive. Even the old Tanner tools are now being flogged by Mentor for north of $100K. And they're probably the cheapest around.
We're not even talking heavy digital--old 2um or 5um (especially metal gate since they have 18V voltage tolerance) processes are interesting for analog audio. Guitar pedals still use analog bucket brigade delay chips that haven't been manufactured for decades. At $5K, you could make your money back on a boutique pedal if you sell 100 of them. At $50K that gets dicey and at $250K that will probably never happen.
The ability to slap a couple hundred transistors down on a chip, simulate it and get it manufactured for less than $5K would enable a lot of interesting, low-volume stuff--look at what happened when PCBs got so cheap.
Right now, the entire electronics industry is constrained by the fact that volumes are "millions or bust".
- Ericson2314 7y agoYeah DARPA or somebody should just dump money into making that cheap low volume happen.
- bsder 7y agoDARPA (via VHSIC) is the reason why most of the commercial VLSI tools even exist today. That's why it was particularly frustrating to see DARPA missing the boat to try to make more digital stuff happen. We have an excess of digital. We have vast quantities of digital. We have so much digital people don't know what to do with it all. What we don't have vast quantities of are interesting sensors, oddball RF designs, or extremely low power things. Note that these are all analog. Throwing money into an open-source VLSI toolchain would do more to relieve DARPA's VLSI bottlenecks than anything else they could do.
- adapteva 7y agoNot sure what you are referring to, but the majority of DARPA’s recent $110M investment in silicon design tools and opens source IP is dedicated to analog design.