6 ms·
>Is it ethical to make a little person taller? No [there is no ethical problem], why would something which has no negative effect on anyone else present an eth
by mc32 7y ago
>Is it ethical to make a little person taller?
No [there is no ethical problem], why would something which has no negative effect on anyone else present an ethical challenge? It doesn’t say make everyone into a 6’7” basketball athlete, it says make small people taller which translates into a more normal height range.
If everyone potentially affected by dwarfism in the future were diverted into normal growth via treatment, in a few generations there would be no one left who is affected by it physically.
- driverdan 7y ago> No, why would something which has no negative effect on anyone Did you bother reading the article? As it said there are a lot of medical complications related to it. Being abnormally short also makes life significantly harder without even factoring in the societal / social consequences. > If everyone affected by dwarfism in the future were diverted into normal growth via treatment, in a few generations there would be no one left who is affected by it physically. Why is that a bad thing?
- tzs 7y agoMaybe its similar to what happens sometimes with young deaf children whose parents are deaf? The parents sometimes refuse to get cochlear implants for the child that would give the child normal or near normal hearing, on the grounds that they want the child to grow up fully in "deaf culture". Many who have been deaf all their lives, as opposed to those who lost their hearing as adults, view deafness as just a difference, not as a disability to be cured or fixed, apparently similar to the way most see race and ethnicity. Telling them they need to "fix" their child's hearing apparently to them is like, say, telling a Jewish family they need to raise their kids Christian. Achondroplasia has a hereditary component, so there will be families where both parents have it and their child has it, and they have many relatives with it. I would not be surprised if some of them feel that there is an achondroplasia culture, and it is wrong to "fix" a child to make them fit non-achondroplasia culture.
- big_chungus 7y agoThere are tons of nasty side effects that go with dwarfism; it's not as though it's _just_ being short. It can cause bowleggedness, hunchback, limited mobility of elbows, and all sorts of other issues [0] (yes, those refer to the specific kind of dwarfism this medicine treats). A parent can't subject his kid to those just so he can feel like his kid fits a "culture". It's wrong for the same reason mutilating girls' genitals to fit a "culture" is wrong. It is unethical to cause a child a lifetime of problems for personal gratification or because of a parent's insecurities. At least cochlear implants can be given at a later age; this is a developmental thing which a child cannot choose for himself at a later age. [0] https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/dwarfism/symptoms-causes/syc-20371969 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/dwarfism/symp...
- total_lurker667 7y agoAlright let's talk about a part of your post where you claimed it's bad to submit a female to genital mutilation to fit a cultural ideal. I agree it's barbaric. By the same token why is it acceptable to submit male infants to the same treatment ( circumcision) Both are barbaric genital mutliations. It's the same thing. Cutting off a very sensitive part of any infants genitalia is barbaric
- ackshually 7y agoWhen referencing baby genital mutilation, it might be worth dropping the "female". It's just as horrible to slice up a male baby's genitalia, and it's done much more often.
- shotashotashota 7y ago> If everyone affected by dwarfism in the future were diverted into normal growth via treatment, in a few generations there would be no one left who is affected by it physically. Why would it? Unless the changes are made at the genetic level nothing change. Well, some things will change.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoI believe the opposite is true. It would promote more of the genes in society, because dwarfism is sexually selected against. Thus more children would be born with dwarfism.
- mc32 7y agoThere are many afflictions which are hereditary. We typically don’t go about saying how finding treatments that allow these people to live at all or live improved lives inflicts the possibility of further establishing the affliction in a population into the future. I mean this comes off as kind of close to a eugenic attitude, although not quite there. I’d be okay with some sort of disclosure for future partners as we’d be for many things of this nature.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoI think enforcing any sort of eugenic policies would also be unethical including the forced disclosure of the medical procedures we are discussing. It's hard for me to believe something is wrong and shouldn't be done while simultaneously believing it should not be prevented with policy. We need to evolve the ability to uncover deception with our minds and prevent betrayal innately. Those who can do that possess gifts that will reward the successful species in the very long term. As it is, we are unable to detect and prevent it as a society and we need that skill. I admire it in those I know who have it. I wish I was better at it.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoYou do get people complaining, with no apparent irony, about how modern medicine weakens the human race by allowing unfit people to reproduce, often with an extremely broad definition of "unfit". Idiocracy will be invariably be mentioned. And then they get offended when you say that's eugenics.
- jariel 7y ago"No, why would something which has no negative effect on anyone else present an ethical challenge? " It's interesting to see how self-oriented the moral view is in here on HN, but more interesting, is the lack of understanding that not everyone shares these individualist views. Everything affects everything - and all of this stuff present moral challenges. I don't think this therapy in particular is a big deal ... but we are on the cusp of some 'big deal' type questions. A very easy but contentious example: 'the gay cure pill'. Imagine if someone created such a thing, it would immediately cause a huge debacle. More relevant because it actually exists are 'skin lightning' products. Mostly creams, but imagine a simple, cheap pill that just suck the melatonin out and 'made you white'. It's easy to think of problems that might arise. But what about genetics mutations skin that glows in the dark? Or permanent hair or eye colour transforms? Procedures that are given 'before birth'? Artificial limbs grafted onto the torso made possible with amazing drugs (so the body doesn't reject the limb), amazing surgery, and therapy that enables people to make use of such limbs? Or a genetic tinkering that re-release the 'tail' gene so kids can have tails like animals? Will we need to update the constitution to reflect this new class of people as 'protected'? What about issues of identity? Personal pronouns? What limits will parents have in deciding the genetic makeup of their kids? All social behaviour is contagious to some extent, especially when accepting it becomes legally enforced. Do companies have to make special accommodations for people with modifications? Most nations have socialised medicine: how much of this should be paid for by the community? Do people have a 'right to a tail' because that's how they want to identify (i.e. pre-paleo human?). And if it's not covered by public insurance, what happens when these things are botched? Or when there is long term fallout? The community has to pay for the 'blue skin disease' that appears 30 years after people get the gene treatment that colours their skin blue? It's a brave new world - moral questions abound. It's not just as easy as 'let them do whatever'.
- roywiggins 7y agoIt's being tested on children who can't really consent- for obvious, practical reasons. The people who are really deciding this are the children's parents.
- mc32 7y agoAs long as it’s an approved procedure with minimal side effects where the benefits far outweigh the downsides, I don’t see that as a problem any more than parents who get other non life saving treatments for their kids which will be beneficial in the future.
- roywiggins 7y agoI think you're probably right, and that it doesn't make much sense to not give your child a drug that would fix their bone growth even if it isn't literally life-saving. As long as the side effects are well studied and strictly less bad than the alternative. If the side effects were awful then it would be much trickier, but it seems like that's not the case.
- aaron695 7y agoSkin color effects your future. Should parents change their child's skin colour. If you think that has ethical issues, then so does height. Cosmetics can change your life path Crooked teeth we accept as ethical to change in children. Breast size we don't. I think ethics is involved, even if it's wrong.
- bsder 7y agoAs I recall, being significantly out of range in terms of height also has fairly broad health implications due to maldevelopment of internal structure. So, it's not just height that gets fixed.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoHeight is a predictor of evolutionary viability in humans. Altering the physical manifestation of any genotype, does affect both one's mate and potential offspring. Therefore it is deception and thus, imo, unethical. I believe this is true of all medical procedures that counteract genetically maladaptive traits.
- mc32 7y agoFine, require disclosure of some sort in the event of possible procreation.
- michalf6 7y agoThat's only a partial solution, rational thought has little to do with sexual selection. I don't think we can come up with anything better though.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoMy partner and I got dna tests before beginning on the path of procreation. We were making a decision that affected a human being that would have no input on its coming into existence. We owe it to a child we would come to respect and love to be very conscious in every aspect of its life including its genetic viability. Less than rational thought in such a matter, I believe is very selfish and unkind to a life that I may create. I understand this isn't the normal way of thinking on the issue, but I wish it was more common.
- bennyelv 7y agoThe premise that backs this approach seems to be that there is a black and white “genetic standard” but the reality is surely very subtle shades of grey. What are the parameters for deciding between genetically viable and genetically unviable?
- StacyRoberts 7y ago
- colechristensen 7y agoThe ethical issue lies in classifying different kinds of people as undesirable and then fixing them with drugs. Sometimes "fixing" a specific condition sounds obviously ethical to some and to others it is offensive.