6 ms·
A new treatment promises to make little people taller
- oh_sigh 7y agoI wonder how long until rich parents are giving this to their kids who will "only" be 5'10" so they can be 6'2"?
- diminoten 7y agoI hope soon, that's so cool!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pacaro 7y agoIs there any implication in TFA that this would work? It appears to work on a pathway which converts collagen to bone, if that is already happening, would adding this drug make it happen more? is there any "more" to happen?
- big_chungus 7y agoI am possibly wrong, but from what I've read, this medicine allows the body to produce its own natural supply of the protein in question (which would otherwise be defective). It shouldn't increase the quantity produced, just allow what is produced to work.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 7y agoIt's much harder to verify that a drug doesn't have side effects than that it has less side effects than an illness. The problem with giving it to healthy children is that it could make their lives worse even though they get taller (otherwise I see no problem with taking it).
- foogazi 7y agoThey could go for the bone-stretching alternative discussed in TFA
- teej 7y agoYou shouldn't be downvoted - there was a recent episode of This American Life talking about this trend. Pediatric Endocrinologists are prescribing growth hormone to otherwise healthy kids who are on the short side of the height spectrum. This is typically at the rich parents demand. The treatment is often not covered under insurance and can cost hundreds of thousands over a few years. So yes, rich parents are already juicing their kids up on HGH to give them an extra inch or two of height. It's not the same exact treatment as the OP but it is happening today. https://www.thisamericanlife.org/687/small-things-considered https://www.thisamericanlife.org/687/small-things-considered
- jmpman 7y agoI read that it results in an extra inch or two in other places as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- buboard 7y agopretty soon apparently. but why rich only?
- kelnos 7y agoThe assumption is that it'd be an expensive treatment, and insurance would be unlikely to cover it if there isn't a medical need.
- djohnston 7y agoI'm not sure this particular treatment would actually do anything, since it acts against a genetic mutation causing dwarfism, but I'm not a doctor. Anyways rich parents are already doing things like this, and we haven't even hit the inflection point with CRISPR on the horizon. Assuming my hypothetical son wanted it, I would try to provide it. Humans are biased and tall men command unearned respect simply because of stature. It's not fair but it's also irrefutable.
- mc32 7y ago>Is it ethical to make a little person taller? No [there is no ethical problem], why would something which has no negative effect on anyone else present an ethical challenge? It doesn’t say make everyone into a 6’7” basketball athlete, it says make small people taller which translates into a more normal height range. If everyone potentially affected by dwarfism in the future were diverted into normal growth via treatment, in a few generations there would be no one left who is affected by it physically.
- driverdan 7y ago> No, why would something which has no negative effect on anyone Did you bother reading the article? As it said there are a lot of medical complications related to it. Being abnormally short also makes life significantly harder without even factoring in the societal / social consequences. > If everyone affected by dwarfism in the future were diverted into normal growth via treatment, in a few generations there would be no one left who is affected by it physically. Why is that a bad thing?
- tzs 7y agoMaybe its similar to what happens sometimes with young deaf children whose parents are deaf? The parents sometimes refuse to get cochlear implants for the child that would give the child normal or near normal hearing, on the grounds that they want the child to grow up fully in "deaf culture". Many who have been deaf all their lives, as opposed to those who lost their hearing as adults, view deafness as just a difference, not as a disability to be cured or fixed, apparently similar to the way most see race and ethnicity. Telling them they need to "fix" their child's hearing apparently to them is like, say, telling a Jewish family they need to raise their kids Christian. Achondroplasia has a hereditary component, so there will be families where both parents have it and their child has it, and they have many relatives with it. I would not be surprised if some of them feel that there is an achondroplasia culture, and it is wrong to "fix" a child to make them fit non-achondroplasia culture.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoWhy are people taking offence to this? If you find the treatment distasteful then don't use it. If no one uses it then it will disappear on its own. Problem fixed.
- NegativeLatency 7y agoIt’s also not just about height. Sounds like there are other heath factors to be considered. > The goal, according to the company, is to prevent the medical complications associated with achondroplasia, which include sleep apnea, hearing loss, and spinal problems.
- okonomiyaki3000 7y agoBecause, before you can cure something, you have to admit that the condition was a kind of flaw in the first place. Maybe it's easy for most of us to say that dwarfism clearly is a flaw but, if you were a dwarf, you may see it differently. There was a similar outcry some years ago when there was talk of a cure for some kind of deafness. And, it's a little different, but kind of similar to Iceland's near elimination of Down Syndrome.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI feel sorry for the children of such people. I grew up in an environment of alcoholics. Many of my family were alcoholics. My sister and I are most definitively not alcoholics. We purposefully avoided such a path. My cousins also. We are seen by some of the older family as 'prissy/non-enjoyers of life/less willing to be 'alive/etc'. Though overall my parents I'm sure are happy we don't drink like they do/did. Whenever you break from the group, it causes tension. One would hope most adults weren't so small minded that they would prefer their children suffer like them, so long as to not highlight their own ghosts. One generation should want the best for the next, and that means leaving behind things that have overwhelming negatives (such as genital mutilation) - I'm sure one day we will look back at purposefully keeping a child def or 'little' as a form of extreme cruelty.
- NeoBasilisk 7y agoCalling it a "flaw" is probably going too far. It is a simple acknowledgement that if your physical traits or abilities diverge significantly from what is average, then your quality of life will suffer in some way. Depending on your condition, maybe you won't suffer much of a loss, or maybe you will suffer significantly. The simple reality is that society is not ever going to fully accommodate someone that is 4'6" (137cm). As a somewhat irrelevant example, I'm colorblind, and I don't see any redeeming value in that trait. It's a mild inconvenience, and it there were a treatment to make it go away without significant side effects, that would be nice. There is no reason to be "proud" of your physical attributes that you had no part in creating. If you are part of a historically marginalized group, then pride in your group can emerge as a method of coping with that oppression, but otherwise there is no point.
- michalf6 7y agoMy view on this, if I knew my kids were going to be little: 1) I would absolutely get my children on that. 2) I don't want others to take it - I don't want to give my kid to have a chance to mate with someone else after the treatment. Chances of producing affected offspring are too high. I'm a bit too tired right now to see a solution which isn't straight up eugenics, but it's an interesting problem to ponder about. Public record? Forced sterilization? Abortion? Of whom, carriers and affected or affected only?
- ladberg 7y agoIf the medicine is easily available, then you shouldn't have any issues with your kids mating with people afflicted. Your grandkids can just take the medicine and it will become a non-issue in the same way that a cleft lip is today.
- michalf6 7y agoThat's the issue I'm worried about - after a doomsday scenario like war / cataclysm / plague my descendants would most likely be deprived of that medicine, likely resulting in my direct ancestral line dying off. In a more general sense, I'm very concerned about the point in human evolution when we can't live our lives and reproduce anymore without the aid of technology. Then it takes one cataclysm to wipe us out. I see your point though, this kind of event seems unlikely.
- klipt 7y agoAfter a cataclysm, wouldn't your short sighted descendents have trouble without glasses too? Does that mean you wouldn't date anyone who's shortsighted? Also you're assuming we develop technology to cure all these genetic problems in the phenotype, without being able to CRISPR them away in the genotype too, which may happen in the nearish future.
- chipperyman573 7y agoThis is a really interesting point I haven't thought of, but haven't we really already reached that point? Terrible diseases that used to wipe out entire civilizations are stopped dead (heh) in their tracks by taking a pill for a few weeks, stopping us from developing an immune system that can respond well.
- zaroth 7y agoAs far as ethically questionable drugs go, particularly around genetic abnormalities, this one seems like it is about as uncontroversial as it can get. It doesn’t confer benefits to someone who doesn’t have the specific genetic issue. It works around the missing protein rather than trying to alter the broken gene. And there are significant co-morbidities that come along with dwarfism that make it more obviously a medical issue rather than just being about physical stature. It doesn’t change the underlying gene, so the issue can still be passed on to offspring. So nothing is being eradicated or erased. If it works as described it should be a highly effective treatment with minimal side effects which avoid a host of medical issues for the children that get it, besides giving them a good shot at > 1st percentile height. I can imagine much more ethically dubious treatments that will certainly be coming down the line as we continue to identify, target, and find ways to enhance these genetic pathways.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Invictus0 7y agoIf someone is born with dwarfism and wants to be a dwarf (sorry if this is not the PC term), they can be a dwarf. If someone is born a dwarf and wants to be a normal height, they can be a normal height. Are there really dwarf organizations arguing that no dwarf people should even be allowed to be a normal height? Or is this just manufactured outrage for a news article?
- kelnos 7y agoI'm not really surprised. There are deaf parents who have deaf children and then refuse to allow their children to be fitted with cochlear implants, all in the name of something akin to "deaf pride", and a delusional denial that being deaf is any kind of disadvantage. It's understandable to build that sort of thing into one's identity to the point where it's a blind spot, but it's unfortunate that the kids end up suffering for it. Part of the issue here is that -- presumably -- the drug must be administered during childhood, as it's too late to make a difference during adulthood. So the child isn't the one making the choice, legally: it's the parents. Personally, I find the question asked of the article to be upside down; I think it's unethical for a parent to deny a child a treatment that would improve their quality of life, simply because they are "proud" of their in-group. It's almost as bad as the anti-vaxxers.
- mrtweetyhack 7y agoso tall people can be even taller?
- marcoseliziario 7y ago3, 2, 1 for celebrities accessing this treatments through Hollywood doctors, and then the spawning of a thriving cottage industry of shady tree doctors to satisfy the demand from their social media followers.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoThe idea that dwarfism isn't a disadvantage is the kind absurdity now promoted by mainstream culture in the name of sensitivity.
- kelnos 7y agoThat was my take on it as well. My view is the opposite: if you have a child with dwarfism, it's unethical to refuse to treat them, if there's a safe treatment where the long term effects are understood (I get that this drug is not yet that, but hopefully someday could be). Being short is a disadvantage in our society, no matter how you try to slice it. Even people without dwarfism tend to be looked on less favorably if they're shorter than average. It sucks, but pretending that being short isn't a disadvantage is just willful disillusionment. And that's before we get into any of the health problems that dwarfism can cause. I look at this similarly to how I see vaccinations: I'd consider a parent unfit to raise a child if they'd refuse to treat their kid's dwarfism, if a treatment is possible and reasonably safe. Pride in a disadvantage is helpful for people psychologically, in order to cope with the oppression or cruelty of others, but allowing it to turn into a desire to keep that disadvantage -- and deny others the ability to choose for themselves whether or not they want treatment -- is truly a bad thing.
- CryptoPunk 7y ago>>Pride in a disadvantage is helpful for people psychologically, in order to cope with the oppression or cruelty of others, but allowing it to turn into a desire to keep that disadvantage -- and deny others the ability to choose for themselves whether or not they want treatment -- is truly a bad thing. Exactly, the desire to boost the self-esteem and social acceptance of those with disorders is now having pathological consequences.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vonseel 7y agoThis (article) is ridiculous. That was not the first “R” adjective I wanted to use to describe it. People will find anything to get all PC and fussy about. You can’t make a blanket statement like “little people don’t want to be taller, they celebrate their dwarfism” or whatever argument he’s making. Certainly there are plenty of people affected by it who wish they could have had a treatment like this. Hell, I’m 5’10” and I’d have gladly taken HGH or something when I was younger if I knew it was a chance to grow a few extra inches. Like the song goes... I wish I was little bit taller, I wish I was a baller, I wish I had a girl who looked good I would call her, I wish I had a rabbit in a hat with a bat... lol
- bilekas 7y agoThis is a stupid argument. If it was a mandatory treatment that would be a problem. If people want to be taller, go for it. Like saying : "Oh we cant research cures/preventative procedures for downsyndrome because that might offend some people". Nonsense
- Proven 7y ago"Treatment" for what?