5 ms·
I like the premise, but I don't think 6,300 representatives makes a lot of sense. I like the proposed "Wyoming" rule. That each representative will represent
by jedberg 7y ago
I like the premise, but I don't think 6,300 representatives makes a lot of sense.
I like the proposed "Wyoming" rule. That each representative will represent no more than the population of the smallest state.
Today that would mean about 562 reps, which is manageable, in line with most of the other major world democracies, and would make the electoral college much more fair and balanced as originally intended.
- elihu 7y agoAnother option is to let each state have as few or as many representatives as they want, but instead of going with one vote per representative, you weight the votes by the number of citizens that representative represents. You could even go one step further and allow the top two or three vote-getters from each district to have a seat in the House, but their voting power is weighted by the number of votes they got.
- gaogao 7y agoHopefully a number within reason. I could see some states protesting congressional salaries by having thousands of representatives.
- vannevar 7y agoI like the idea of weighted representation, though I think you'd have to take at least the top two to avoid disenfranchising a significant fraction of the population under a winner-take-all approach, given our two-party politics. Taking the top 3 might make things interesting. You could imagine the dominant party's candidates finishing 1st and 4th, for instance, resulting in the minority party having more representation than the majority.
- blotter_paper 7y agoIf the party finishing 2nd and 3rd had more votes than the party finishing 1st and 4th, they wouldn't be the minority party. I find it more likely that the 3rd and 4th places would be taken by third parties, and you'd have something like this: 1st: Republican 2nd: Democrat 3rd: Green 4th: Libertarian ...in which case the Dems would be the minority party, but the left in general would still hold a majority of the votes (assuming 2nd + 3rd > 1st + 4th).
- RhysU 7y agoWhy encourage those who cannot prioritize making their minds up against a common enemy? Effectively, this scheme looks to empower any majority no matter how comprised. Clarity of purpose should matter.
- blotter_paper 7y agoThe funny thing about "should" statements is that we get to disagree on them without justification. I see no reason clarity of purpose across multiple humans should matter, nor any reason that people should be corralled into picking between two corrupt options.
- RhysU 7y agoClarity allows governance. Otherwise we're just reacting.
- wickedwiesel 7y ago
- softwaredoug 7y agoThere's the cubed-root rule that is pretty sensible, where representation is related to the cubed root of the population. From 2010 census there would be 676 representatives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cube_root_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cube_root_rule
- vannevar 7y agoI don't think adding 100-odd representatives would do much to fix the problem, which is essentially that the individual vote has been devalued by an order of magnitude. With modern technology, it might not be so difficult to manage thousands of representatives. It would be a huge change, though, and if we're making changes at that scale, a constitutional convention is probably in order.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago"The individual vote has been devalued by an order of magnitude." Well, that's true, if you think about an individual voting for a representative. But what do representatives do? They vote in the House. And no matter how you slice it, you can't make each individual's vote matter more in the House. If it matters more in electing a representative, then there are more representatives, and each representative's vote matters less in the House.
- vannevar 7y agoLook at it from the candidate's perspective: the more voters they represent, the less any individual voter's opinion matters to them. Very similar to the utility of money, the more you have, the less a dollar is worth to you. And the less the individual voter matters, the more monied special interests matter. Money in politics is always a problem, but it's multiplied by the devaluation of the individual voter.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoFair point. And perhaps one additional step: The more voters they have, the more money they need for the campaign.
- peteradio 7y agoWhat exactly is the manageability problems you foresee? 562 seems kind of a pointless change which doesn't address any of the named issues. The first paragraph: > The framers of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights intended that the total population of Congressional districts never exceed 50 to 60 thousand. Currently, the average population size of the districts is nearly 700,000 and, consequently, the principle of proportionally equitable representation has been abandoned.
- blotter_paper 7y ago> and would make the electoral college much more fair and balanced as originally intended. That was not originally intended, in addition to not trusting the people to directly elect leaders the electoral college was intended to give smaller states more power than they would have as a result of their population size alone. This was part of the deal, and it made the union agreeable to smaller states. If you wanna back out of the deal, it seems only fair to give any states that want to a chance to back out of the union.
- belltaco 7y agoWhat were the population differences between the small and large states back then compared to now?
- undersuit 7y ago>the electoral college was intended to give smaller states more power than they would have as a result of their population size alone. Thanks to the 3/5's compromise...
- TMWNN 7y agoThe Three Fifths Compromise had nothing to do with the Electoral College. Slave states gained more power in the Electoral College from the extra 3/5 votes, but a) the compromise itself had nothing to do with the Electoral College's creation or design, and b) 3/5 of a vote gave less power to slave states than their preference, a full vote for each slave.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoWe are in the modern era of electronic communication. 435 or 6,300 makes little difference, but it does make a big difference in term of representation, making it more likely you know the congressman or his family from personal interactions in your community. This lessens the need to rely on campaigns ads and campaign money to run expensive campaigns that sell your soul.
- roenxi 7y agoWhy is 6,300 unamanagable? >500 and 6,300 both cross over the Dunbar number threshold. (interestingly, the per-party size in the US House of Reps is about the upper limit of the Dunbar number, 2 x 250 ~= 500) 6,300 is manageable with modern technology; the capabilities are there to organise and make transparent large public voting system for thousands of politicians that would have been impractical even as recently as the 60s.
- iguy 7y agoIt's not the voting (which has been possible for millions of people, for ages). It's the horse-trading to figure out what to put to a vote, or ideally to find the right compromises. Surely that's the point of having few enough people that many can know each other.
- beatgammit 7y agoJust think of the filibusters with thousands of representatives...
- masonic 7y agoThere is no filibuster rule in the House.