3 ms·
It's AT&T (UVerse). If they can't get it right, I don't have much hope for anyone else. Also, I don't even use my ISPs name servers, I use Cloudflare or Googl
by jedberg 7y ago
It's AT&T (UVerse). If they can't get it right, I don't have much hope for anyone else.
Also, I don't even use my ISPs name servers, I use Cloudflare or Google, so I don't think it's that unless the ISP is somehow munging the packet in transit, which I suppose is possible.
Honestly I think it is all due to issues with the v6 stack in MacOS.
But my point is, I shouldn't have to be a network engineer to make v6 work. I should be able to turn on my computer and just have it work.
- scurvy 7y agoYou should know from your own background that AT&T doesn't quite have a history of excellence in the Internet realm.
- thedanbob 7y agoI was never able to get ipv6 to work when I was on AT&T, couldn't even get addresses assigned. When I got on Cox at my new house it worked out of the box. So some ISPs get it right.
- jaywalk 7y agoI've never had any issues with IPv6 on Comcast, and I've been using it almost since day one. AT&T is not a company you should ever hold up as some kind of good example of network engineering.
- q3k 7y ago> Also, I don't even use my ISPs name servers, I use Cloudflare or Google, so I don't think it's that unless the ISP is somehow munging the packet in transit, which I suppose is possible. That's exactly the problem. You send out two v4 DNS UDP packets one after another (one for A, another for AAAA), both go via your ISPs CGNAT, the CGNAT gets confused, one of the packets gets dropped. I've seen this exact behavior when talking to 8.8.8.8 on Orange in Poland (and they do DS-Lite). It didn't occur with the ISP's DNS, because a) they were also on v6 b) they weren't getting CGNATed. > But my point is, I shouldn't have to be a network engineer to make v6 work. I should be able to turn on my computer and just have it work. By disabling IPv6 you're letting shit ISPs get away with this. Your ability to debug this and to figure out it's the ISP's issue should be used to voice your concerns, and not just let this slide.