4 ms·
Since drivers can't set their own rates, I've always felt the government should regulate the split. Uber's portion should be capped at something like 5%. The ma
by criddell 7y ago
Since drivers can't set their own rates, I've always felt the government should regulate the split. Uber's portion should be capped at something like 5%. The marginal cost for them to connect a driver to a rider is close to 0 so even 5% feels very generous.
- ekianjo 7y agoThat's not the job of the government to regulate margins of businesses. If you go by that way, then you might as well regulate every margin of every app store?
- Endy 7y agoA great idea.
- criddell 7y agoAt least in the US, they do it all the time. The job of the government is mostly to do what we tell it to do because the government is just people from the community.
- cartoonworld 7y agoThat is the governments job. They aren't regulating an app on the store, they would be in this hypothetical scenario regulating the labor practices of a multinational corporation, which is for sure the job of any government.
- buboard 7y agoThats what taxation does anyway
- lmm 7y agoThe government should (and does) regulate the margins of natural monopolies like utilities where a free market can't operate effectively.
- ma2rten 7y agoI doubt that their margin is much higher than that after factoring in discounts.
- criddell 7y agoI may be wrong, but I don't think the driver keeps 95% of the fare.
- ma2rten 7y agoKeep in mind that Uber's revenue was $3.6 billion in the last quarter, but they lost $1.2 billion. I wouldn't be surprised if their margin was negative. Really the problem is not that Uber gets paid too much, but that drivers are underpaid. I think a minimum wage for drivers is a better solution. In California such a law is currently underway.
- criddell 7y agoI mentioned minimum wage in another comment. If a driver has the app open for four hours, they need to be paid a minimum of four hours of minimum wage.
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoDrivers can set their own rates, or at least to the success a bidding process would work. If the rate is to low, don't work. If there was a bidding process I wouldn't be surprised if you saw rates actually drop.
- jamiequint 7y agoSay we implemented this scenario, can we walk though what would happen next: - What do you expect would happen to Uber prices? - How do you expect that change would affect overall demand for the service? - From there, how do you expect this change of demand (if any) would affect the take-home pay of the drivers?
- criddell 7y ago> What do you expect would happen to Uber prices? That would depend on how much money Softbank has left to invest. Prices might go up. > How do you expect that change would affect overall demand for the service? Uber's great advantage is that the quality of service is better than the alternatives. If drivers can make more money, more drivers might sign up and wait times would drop. A better experience means the service will be used even more. > From there, how do you expect this change of demand (if any) would affect the take-home pay of the drivers? There are two parts to this. First Uber should have to make sure no driver ever makes less than minimum wage. If a driver starts the app to announce their availability and has the app running for four hours, they are entitled to a minimum of four hours of pay. The second part is that I think getting 95% of the fare would mean drivers take-home pay is generally higher than it is today. If Uber wants to make more money by raising the rate, then drivers automatically get a pay increase as well and that seems fair.