4 ms·
> I don’t want to rate my driver. I want to be able to rely on a third party... You sure can’t rely on the Uber, Lyft, Juno ratings. It’s 5 stars or bust. T
by Terretta 7y ago
> I don’t want to rate my driver. I want to be able to rely on a third party...
You sure can’t rely on the Uber, Lyft, Juno ratings. It’s 5 stars or bust. The social pressure on 5 stars is enormous.
Netflix moved to thumbs up, thumbs down. YouTube did the same, after showing a graph of the 5s and 1s:
https://techcrunch.com/2009/09/22/youtube-comes-to-a-5-star-realization-its-ratings-are-useless/ https://techcrunch.com/2009/09/22/youtube-comes-to-a-5-star-...
I relentlessly give an average delivery or ride 3 stars, but feel bad every time. When the ride is quite good, 4 stars, and exceptional, 5 stars. Exceptional is the exception.
Three stars doesn’t make you a bad rider or a bad driver, just average. If it’s not the bulk of the ratings you give, you’re an unreliable rater and not helping the ratings anyway.
- ward 7y agoI used to think like this (and still do for movies and such), but recall reading that a driver under 4.6 or 4.7 rating will barely get any clients matched any more.
- ceejayoz 7y agoI desperately wish they’d just adopt an “it was fine” and a “something wrong or exceptional” button.
- newswasboring 7y agoMaybe they should scale your ratings based on your rating pattern. I don't know how to do it mathematically but there must be some way to normalize scores if you have enough data. Anybody knows how to do this?
- jankassens 7y agoI’d start with assuming everyone’s experience is normal distributed. Someone who always voted 3 stars probably had the same experience as someone who always voted 5 stars. I’d try out computing the normal distribution of the rater and see where on the distribution this particular vote fell.
- dangus 7y agoYour inability to follow the cultural norm is actually at fault here, not the rating system. What you’re doing is akin to tipping 5% in restaurants in the US and only tipping 15% when you have an outstanding experience. In reality, restaurants workers in the USA would expect 15% to 20% unless they dramatically fucked up. I don’t like the tipping system either, but I’m also not going to be that asshole who tries to change the system all on my own without anyone else agreeing to it. Just use the rating system like everyone else and get over it: If the driver was great it’s 5 stars with all the “what did I do great” options checked and a note for the driver. If the driver didn’t fuck up it’s five stars. If you don’t want to be matched with the same driver again but they didn’t do anything egregious it’s three stars. If you were outright disgusted at your ride it’s 1 Star. That’s it. It’s simple. Your own personal usage of the ratings system is not helpful. Actually, for another example of why your ratings method is bad, let’s compare three stars to grades in school. Three out of five stars would be 60%, which is a D- in most schools. That’s not an average grade. Someone who completes all the homework and does an average job would expect a B, which would be 4 stars. Someone who didn’t get any questions wrong would get an A, 5 stars. If your Uber driver took you to your destination with a reasonably clean car that’s an A. There’s no such thing as exceptional. It’s a car ride not a physics exam, what do you want exactly? Uber wants a driver to maintain over a 4 rating, something like 4.5 or 4.2. When you give that driver a 3 rating you’re not saying “thanks, you were acceptable and average.” You are saying “you kind of suck” and Uber won’t actually even match the driver with you again. So if you continue to give all your drivers 3 stars just because you wish the rating system worked a different way than it does, you’re even screwing yourself by reducing the number of drivers that can match with you.
- user5994461 7y agoWhile that's on point, the US school grades are even more obscure and meaningless than the taxi rating to the rest of the world. Many countries are using numbers like out of 10 or 100 and doing an average job on the homework will land you the average like 5 or 50. It's kinda funny how everything is connected: school grades, restaurant tips, taxi ratings.
- deleted 7y ago
- CaptainZapp 7y agoThat's exactly what bugs me so much about Trip Advisor ratings. Even then, when they still had some utility. When you have a 5* scale for rating a restaurant my description would be: * A disaster level lousy place ** Sub par. Probably wouldn't visit again *** Quite OK. Probably not my fave anytime soon, but fine **** Above average. Excellent food, service and atmosphere ***** An out of this world dining experience. Perfect in every aspect I realise that there is a certain amount of relativity and subjectivity and that a 5* Trip Advisor review is not necessarily equal to three stars by Guide Michelin. But it should mean something and when most restaurants have something between 4 and 5 stars (Let alone that the #1 rated restaurant in London was one, which didn't exist[1]) the value of such ratings become very questionable. You can see the exact same with Airbnb ratings where 4 -, or 5 star does not mean that you will have a great experience. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shed_at_Dulwich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shed_at_Dulwich