5 ms·
The real question is, why is the Saudi Arabia sovereign wealth fund such a huge source of dumb money? They propped up WeWork. They propped up Uber. To some end,
by Animats 7y ago
The real question is, why is the Saudi Arabia sovereign wealth fund such a huge source of dumb money? They propped up WeWork. They propped up Uber. To some end, or just through sheer dumbness?
None of this could happen without a huge source of dumb money.
- seibelj 7y agoInvesting $10 billion responsibly across a lot of private companies is hard work. Gotta find the companies, negotiate, join the board, monitor them, be apprised of the goings-ons. Then you find a company that can plausibly take $10billion in one go and return the same as any other tech company, plus by giving them so much capital they can destroy the competition. It really comes down to easy-money policies of central bankers combined with the laziness of investors. So much money to invest and doing hard work is for suckers who don’t have the connections to get the capital to invest.
- skybrian 7y agoOkay, but why not do something simple like buying the S&P 500? Is that unavailable at scale?
- tracer4201 7y agoDiversification. I don’t mean to generalize, but there’s a aspect to Saudi culture where they look at down upon people who work - regardless of whether you’re a doctor or a rocket scientist - they look down upon folks who work for a living as if they’re lesser people. In that micro culture, you cannot rely on your own population for economic output. You rely on foreigners or you directly invest in foreign companies and hope to find the next Amazon, Microsoft, or something like that. Source - I married right after high school and my first husband (15 years older) worked in Saudi Arabia. I went there to live with him. We lived together there for 3 years. I eventually left him because I didn’t want to be in a cage (at least that’s what it was like to live there as a female) and wanted to go to school and have my own career and freedom.
- closeparen 7y agoWhy are all the best performing funds closed to new investment? Good strategies have limited capacity. The more capital you have, the dumber you have to be with it. Otherwise we'd invest the whole economy in the Medallion Fund and go home.
- rapsey 7y agoBecause when you are too big, you start changing the market conditions with your investments. This makes investing harder since the ground starts moving under you that much more.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 7y agoBecause it's purpose isn't to return a profit. It's bribery pool used to corrupt the West's business and political institutions.
- josefrichter 7y agoCoz it's good intelligence to have insights into Americans' everyday life and habits? Moreover legally, without any espionage effort? Just speculating, but I don't think MBS is investing in Uber or WeWork to "get rich" really...
- goatinaboat 7y agowhy is the Saudi Arabia sovereign wealth fund such a huge source of dumb money? Because they never earned that money via ingenuity, it is rent paid by foreigners for access to natural resources. It makes sense that they never learnt to invest wisely. Contrast with the Norwegians who extract their own oil with their own skill and technology.
- nojvek 7y agoThe Norweigeian is truly a testament to their government. No shortcuts. Invest the oil money in a broad portfolio ~10k companies for the benefit of all future and current citizens. https://www.nbim.no/ https://www.nbim.no/ Truly amazing.
- rchaud 7y agoThey are strategic investments. They'd probably get better returns if they invested in a balanced portfolio like most SWFs, but making money is probably lower down in terms of priorities than having economic leverage. Let's say if a dissident with US residency were to disappear on foreign soil. Diplomats have started asking some awkward questions. The way to make them go away is to point to major investments you've made in high-profile US companies, that could be impacted should such questions persist.
- charwalker 7y agoThere is a lot, $15+ trillion USD, of cash sitting in bonds/treasuries/etc around the world. Interest rates around the world are low if not negative plus many treasuries are hitting low if not negative rates meaning the groups or people sitting on these piles of cash look to invest in riskier VC/stocks/etc for a positive return. This money is ripe for investing in active funds or financial management groups. The leader of SoftBank approached the Saudis years back and, allegedly, got a $45 billion buy in from a 45 minute meeting. That's a lot of cash on hand. The amount of cash sitting around has stuffed typical investment opportunities and led to (relatively) incredibly risky investing or active management like SoftBank/WeWork. It's mostly worked out for VC funds as if group A doesn't buy in for billions, group B and C are available for a meeting next week losing Group A the opportunity. And Group A has enough cash that they could lose the investment and recover via less risky investment opportunities give say 1 in 10 investments pays out 20-50x. It's great if you are, say, an ex WeWork CEO who can take advantage of the free money. You might even be paid in negative interest to take it on. It's a bit scary from an economics point of view but also highlights inequality given so many Americans are paycheck to paycheck or hold so much debt while there are trillions to push around in money markets and billions to fund losses at Uber and others. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/banks-are-paying-people-to-borrow-money-thats-alarming-news-for-the-global-economy/2019/08/13/8eb7b9ca-bada-11e9-a091-6a96e67d9cce_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/banks-are-pa...