8 ms·
None of those things are the reason. The reason is simple. The Price is Right use MSRP. Back in the day, with only a few outlets, it was hard to get somethin
by jedberg 7y ago
None of those things are the reason. The reason is simple. The Price is Right use MSRP. Back in the day, with only a few outlets, it was hard to get something less than MSRP.
Today, it's almost impossible to find something at MSRP. There are so many outlets and our information on pricing is so good, stores have to compete by offering discounts.
- baby 7y agoManufacturer Suggested Retail Price
- Merrill 7y agoFair trade laws were repealed by '75, and it took a while for pricing to diverge and become as highly variable as today. Not sure whether anyone is doing it, but an early presumed advantage of internet commerce was that the seller could set a different price for each customer depending on the seller's knowledge of the customer's preferences, socioeconomic status, and other parameters. The global electronic village as the global electronic bazaar!
- kortilla 7y agoThere was someone who got caught increasing prices for iOS users.
- taxidump 7y agoTravel sites are the worst for this.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhich sites exactly? I’ve never seen it actually happen and I’d like to experiment.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoTravel sites are worst about it but I've seen it on Amazon which claimed it was a mistake. Smaller stores don't typically do it, but with an iPhone and an Android, one on VPN sometimes you can catch the site being funny about pricing.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAre any of the websites actually the official website of the hotel/airline/car rental? I’ve never even seen a lower price advertised on a third party website compared to the official website of the vendor.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoI've only seen this on third party sites. Never in direct sites. I've definitely seen cheaper prices on third party rather than direct sites on more than one occasion.
- wolco 7y agoNetflix charges differently based on location which is a proxy for those. Amazon offers multiple shipping option for various prices.
- baroffoos 7y agoLocation pricing was done before the internet and ad tracking. Some countries have richer people who can afford to pay more for luxuries.
- manderley 7y agoTons of sites do variable pricing, especially in the travel sector. Typically discriminating by device, OS etc. And you'll often get a discount coupon after staying on a shopping site for a few minutes without interacting.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI’ve read rumors about this, but I’ve never experienced it on any hotel/airline/car rental’s website. I know people that work at chain hotels and they set the price, or the computer does based on shopping the other hotels around it, but never based on who is searching. I’ve tried searching flight prices by remoting into someone else’s computer far away and comparing to mine, and I’ve always gotten the same priced even though I’m not logged in or anything. Ditto for car rentals. I don’t use travel agents so I can’t say for any other kind of sites.
- soared 7y agoYou can search for Wordpress plugins that do the above and then look at their documentation to learn the rules. Shopify has a setting you can enable to email a 15% off code to anyone who adds and item to their cart but doesn’t check out.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI meant in the travel sector, as the previous poster pointed it out specifically. For retail yes, all you usually need to do is add something to cart and then leave and in the next few days they email you a discount code.
- com2kid 7y agoI'll frequently get quoted different prices on travel sites when using different computers or after turning incognito mode on.
- 7y ago
- RandomBacon 7y agoI have a funny (IMO) anecdote: I used to be a cashier at a major regional chain. I once had a customer complain that an item rang up higher than the MSRP printed on it. I told the customer, 'MSRP stands for the average suggested retail price and that because it's an average, sometimes the actual price will be higher.' The customer didn't say anything else and bought the item (didn't ask for a manager or anything!).
- mtmail 7y agoIn Germany the equivalent is called translated 'non-binding price suggestion'.
- peter_tonoli 7y agoIn Australia, it's called 'recommended retail price'.
- eru 7y agoAnd the exact wording might have been chosen to work around anti price fixing laws?
- smnrchrds 7y agoAnd I assume it is all one long word? Edit: Apparently it is two long words instead: Unverbindliche Preisempfehlung
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- graedus 7y ago> 'MSRP stands for the average suggested retail price and that because it's an average, sometimes the actual price will be higher.' It stands for manufacturer's suggested retail price, but I guess your point stands because it is only a _suggested_ price. Still, I can't remember ever being charged more than MSRP, although perhaps it's happened without me noticing.
- 7y ago
- dap 7y agoIs there data about that? Growing up in the 90s I thought we could usually by something for less than the MSRP. When I watched the show in the 90s I always felt the actual prices were high.
- computator 7y agoYour observation is consistent with the parent comment. The article says, "accuracy of people’s guesses sharply decreased from the 1970s to the 2000s". Presumably by the 1990s, stores had already begun to sell well below the MSRP.
- filmgirlcw 7y agoPrecisely. We are much more conditioned to shop and compare with places that undercut MSRP, that many people would never run across anything selling at the actual MSRP. Even if you’re trying to do “research” to see how much something costs in advance, the MSRP is often obfuscated, even ok the manufacturers site. MSRP has always been a bit of a scam b/c it’s just showing what the suggested price is and the amount of markup between wholesale and selling to end users is variable — some manufacturers have historically been protective about what the price could be, but others have cared less. And now that many manufacturers sell direct to consumers themselves, even their own MSRP is often “slashed” as they sell at a lower price to compete with other retailers.
- reaperducer 7y agoBack in the day, with only a few outlets, it was hard to get something less than MSRP. Ummm... no. Not even remotely close. I find it strange and mildly amusing how so many people in this thread have positioned themselves as experts on this, and have subscribed to some kind of fantasy that before the 1990's that everyone paid MSRP and that we now live in an enlightened internet-powered wonderland of rampant competition and low low prices. These must be people who weren't alive much in the last century.
- jedberg 7y agoI spent many years shopping in the last century. The best you could do for price comparison was to scour local paper for deals at nearby stores, or if you were lucky, the sears catalog. You didn’t have instant access to the best worldwide price.
- u801e 7y agoInternational shipping took a lot longer and was more expensive back then. I remember going through computer parts catalogs in the mid '90s to find the best prices for the parts I needed to assemble a new desktop.
- jedberg 7y agoExactly. So no one did it and your local store didn’t have to compete with those international prices.
- Gibbon1 7y agoYou didn't spend as many years as my mother did. Also best world wide price is a fiction.
- dang 7y agoThis comment breaks the guidelines by being snarky and shallow. It would be much better to instead provide some information about what the world is/was actually like (in your experience). How did pricing vis-a-vis MSRP actually work? What do you actually remember about it? This would be much more interesting than just directing belittling rhetoric at someone else for getting it wrong (in your experience). https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mxfh 7y agoMSRP seems only used for bonus/loyality programs these days. where the price after adding your overpaid vouchers still has a hard time competing with market prices.
- ken 7y agoBetween ebay, craigslist, goodwill, etc., I rarely pay anywhere near full price for most manufactured goods. As a society, we've built more than enough stuff. We just have to redistribute it properly to the people who want it. And the cost of that is way less than the cost of producing it in the first place.