4 ms·
It’s not forced equivalency. Any modern society should be able to say that concentration camps are bad, or that rounding up or punishing children, families peo
by Spooky23 7y ago
It’s not forced equivalency.
Any modern society should be able to say that concentration camps are bad, or that rounding up or punishing children, families people in the basis of race, familial connections, etc is an affront to human dignity that should be condemned.
I’m not sure why this would make me cool at parties, but I would like for my government to be able to take a stand against this type of conduct.
- rayiner 7y agoYou’re drawing a false equivalence both between the people detained and the condition of their detention. > Any modern society should be able to say that concentration camps are bad, or that rounding up or punishing children, families people in the basis of race, familial connections, etc is an affront to human dignity that should be condemned. Of course. And modern nations should condemn China on that basis. But what does that have to do with detaining people apprehended while illegally crossing a sovereign nation’s border? Self determination is also a fundamental right. People have a right to have a country, and govern themselves according to their laws. Concomitant with that right is the right to enforce borders, because those dictate where one polity begins and another ends. People have a right to decide who comes into their country and in what terms. There is a reason the UN Declaration of Human Rights reads: > Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each State. Of course it should be done as humanely as possible, but detention in enforcement of a border is fundamentally moral and legitimate, in the same way as detention pursuant to trial and investigation of a crime. It’s a necessary corollary of protecting other peoples’ rights. Saying that people can’t detain other people who trespass on their border strips people of their rights.
- jacquesm 7y ago> But what does that have to do with detaining people apprehended while illegally crossing a sovereign nation’s border? That this needs spelling out is pretty sad: that separating infants from their parents and sticking them in what to my eyes looks suspiciously like a concentration camp (a thing a Jewish observer btw agreed with) is the rough equivalent of what China is accused of here. And that's besides losing track of whose kids are which and the odd corpse as well as kids living in cages. Are we even on the same planet here? > Of course it should be done as humanely as possible, but detention in enforcement of a border is fundamentally moral and legitimate, in the same way as detention pursuant to trial and investigation of a crime. There is nothing humane about what is happening on the Southern United States border just like there is nothing humane about what the Chinese are doing. > Saying that people can’t detain other people who trespass on their border strips people of their rights. They can, it's the conditions under which it happens that we're debating here. So please don't go and whitewash this, it is absolutely horrific.
- nec4b 7y ago>Are we even on the same planet here? I don't know which planet do you come from, but on the one I live on, there is pretty big distinction between illegal border crossing vs reeducation camps based on your ethnicity.
- jacquesm 7y agoIn both cases parents were separated from their sometimes very young children. So yes, indeed, there should have been a distinction, given that the one is happening in a country that recurrently describes itself as 'the good guys' and the other one happens in a murderous dictatorship masquerading as a free country. I'll leave it up to you to sort out which is which.
- nec4b 7y agoA doctor can kill a person by an honest mistake or by using a person as lab mouse in a concentration camp. The person dies either way. My morality sensor says that these two deaths are not equal even though they are both dead.
- Spooky23 7y agoMany of these families are people seeking asylum status in the United States. Detaining then like criminals and treating them like animals — there are documented cases of infants without identification being cared for by unrelated minors is grotesque. That treatment is against the law, as is many aspects of how others apprehended crossing the border illegally are. If some regulation of asylum process justifies the dishonorable conduct of our government to you, I’m sorry for you. Our humanity is worth more than some bullshit political dogma.
- tptacek 7y agoYou're arguing with a fake Rayiner that you've conjured in your own head because you're angry about a current event and arguing against it is cathartic. In reality, nobody in this thread disagrees with you about family separation. What Rayiner is saying is that family separation is not the same kind of bad as the mass internment of Uighurs. That's not a controversial take.