3 ms·
I liked KenoFisher's top level answer but I want to change the perspective because I think momentum is a red herring. The starting point should be energy. Clas
by roenxi 7y ago
I liked KenoFisher's top level answer but I want to change the perspective because I think momentum is a red herring.
The starting point should be energy. Classical physics (and modern physics as far as I recall) determined that literally everything is linked by a single concept of energy. In my view energy is more real than anything else we experience and all our senses are for perceiving energy in different states. Matter is pooled energy, movement is energy, heat is energy (linked to movement), time is defined to some degree in terms of mass so it is linked in there too somehow. And we know energy is conserved because we have observed that everywhere.
Once we know energy is conserved the law of momentum makes a lot of sense - there have to be symmetrical laws that don't allow arbitrary creation of energy because that doesn't happen. And then F = ma turns up and it isn't so surprising for the same reason.
F = ma is in that sense not a fundamental law; it is a corollary of the conservation of energy. Mathematically there might have been other options, but that is the one that applies in this universe. There was always going to be a mass component in the formula because by observation energy is fundamentally linked to mass.
- klodolph 7y agoThis only makes sense in a relativistic context, but forces don't exist in relativistic contexts. So you can either have F = ma, or you can have GR, but you don't get to have both at the same time.
- selimthegrim 7y agoWait, you can’t write the Lorentz force down?
- cygx 7y agoYou can: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%27s_equations_in_curved_spacetime#Lorentz_force_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%27s_equations_in_curve...
- pdonis 7y ago> forces don't exist in relativistic contexts Yes, they do; the difference in General Relativity is that gravity is not a force, but non-gravitational forces are still there.
- millstone 7y agoIn relativity, energy and momentum are understood as equals, distinguished by direction. Energy is "momentum through time" while momentum is "energy through space." There's not really a good word for it (but see "momenergy.") We can imagine systems where energy is not conserved. Physicists work with these systems all the time. Electrical engineers consider the power coming from the outlet, not the entire (solar-sized) system which conserved energy. In our EE's system, E is not conserved but F=ma still holds. So F=ma is true even if energy is not conserved.
- roenxi 7y ago> In our EE's system, E is not conserved but F=ma still holds. So F=ma is true even if energy is not conserved. Well; no. Energy is conserved. Just because the electrical engineer is ignoring that fact doesn't stop it being important. Same with the physicists. F = ma is a very convenient equation. But energy conservation is a simpler, more fundamental concept and forces are a mathematical artefact of that which happen to be easy to work with.