22 ms·
> For example, it's more promising if you're creating something, rather than just consuming something someone else creates. That heuristic leads to bikesheddin
by jancsika 7y ago
> For example, it's more promising if you're creating something, rather than just consuming something someone else creates.
That heuristic leads to bikeshedding. Try talking to an old white person for whom rap "doesn't sound like music to me." Inevitably they'll bring out the big guns-- that rap "just" takes the music that someone else wrote and talks over it.
Besides, there's no cost to dropping that heuristic. Nobody who scrolls through cat pics is in danger of thinking they are Vincent van Gogh. And if some "cat pic scroller" makes a real breakthrough in the artform I'd really prefer to talk about it without a bunch of grumpy, anti-intellectual gate-keepers whining, "how is that art?"
- Jarwain 7y agoTaking something and talking over it is still creating. It still takes an active effort that results in something New, independent of how "easy" or "hard" someone might perceive it to be. Remixing is still creation & creative. Consuming something someone else creates is more along the lines of Just listening, or Just reading, or Just observing some sort of art