10 ms·
Before buying Ring, WEMO or Roku, consider privacy issues
- smitty1e 7y ago> "Customers have to consent to allow Ring to share the doorbell footage with law enforcement, but "once they have access, they can save it indefinitely," says Rebecca Ricks, a Mozilla researcher who worked on the report." Sure, but once the bits exit a closed network, how do you have any idea where they go? Even if encrypted, there is no way to prevent the recording of data for some future brute-force attack. Probably the basis for a great thriller novel.
- saagarjha 7y ago> there is no way to prevent the recording of data for some future brute-force attack Ideally, your encryption would be resistant to a brute-force attack…
- smitty1e 7y agoWhat does "resistant" mean?
- beatgammit 7y agoI'm guessing OpenSSL, which has never had a security breach...
- smitty1e 7y agoWhich is great, as far as it goes. Likely more a question of when, and how feasible.
- theossuary 7y agoReminds me of Digital Fortress
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI recently bought a house and it came with a Ring doorbell. I dont care for it. I would of never bought one. I do have additional Wyze cams though for my blind spots and the back of the house. I definitely dont ever want to see activity back there. The Wyze cams app is somewhat similar to the Ring app you can see videos people share with Wyze but thing is they have to email those videos in. Wyze says they End-to-End encrypt videos they upload to their cloud. If you dont trust them you can buy surveilance SD cards and use those instead. For $20 a pop though they are great. I only use them facing outside my house. I only put one facing the inside when out of town. My alternative was going to be Raspberry Pi Zero W's and EyeMotionOS if anybody is interested in alternatives. Only reason I didnt get those is cause I couldnt decide on the camera to get and also I had a suspicious person (realize now they were likely just lost) stop partially on my driveway. So I bought a bunch of Wyze cams. Another neat thing about thr Wyze cams is they shove an AI into a $20 camera to detect people. Their video on the matter can be seen on YouTube. It is impressive.
- samdixon 7y agoThis comment reads like an ai was given context from the article and told to spit out a response.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoWell I have been sick all week so I am not surprised. But no I have been on HN for a while.
- samdixon 7y agoI'm sorry Gian, I was having some fun at your expense. Hope you have a great weekend.
- m0zg 7y agoHow do you route power to those Wyze cams though? And just so you know, they send their video to the cloud as well. I wouldn't be surprised if they send it to China in fact.
- tzs 7y agoWow...that Mozilla page that rates a bunch of products by how creepy they are [1] is very confusing. The first time I looked at it, I got the impression that it was telling me that Ring, for example, is rated "Not creepy!" when in fact it rates it "Very creepy!". There are two ways it can mislead. 1. It appears that the items are sorted by creepiness, but in the table of products there is no indication of how creepy the product is. Instead, they have an indicator above the table that starts out "Not creepy!" and as you scroll down through the table that indicator goes through various levels of creepiness. So let's say you are wondering about Ring--you are ready to buy but first want to see what Mozilla says. You go to the page, see "Not creepy!" and an array of products. As you scroll through the products looking for Ring, the only indication that the creepiness level is changing is that indicator at the top. If you don't notice that it changes, it is easy to assume the whole array is the "Not creepy!" section. Then you hit Ring, think it is "Not creepy!", and head over to Amazon to buy one. I only noticed that this was not how it works because I scrolled to the end of the page, didn't see another array for the more creepy products, and only then realized what is going on. 2. Changing the filter settings does not change the creepiness indicator. If it is showing "Not creepy!" products, and you go change the filter settings to only show more creepy products, it shows those products, but still says "Not creepy!". It only updated the "Not creepy!" to whatever the creepiness level is for the shown products when you next scroll. This page would work a lot better if it simply had separate sections for "Not creepy!", "A little creepy!", and so on. [1] https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/
- MobileVet 7y agoThe further down this future we travel, the less I want to do with technology. I am becoming a Luddite. None of this crappy IOT stuff will enter my home.
- pacala 7y agoI hope you enjoy washing clothes by hand.
- 3pt14159 7y agoMy roommate has a phone. I didn't think much of it until he said "Ok Google" while cooking. What am I supposed to say here? I don't like microphones being always on either, but it's his phone and his home too. I can't escape the millions of cameras around the city or the constant internet trackers. We should have had regulated this stuff decades ago.
- justinclift 7y ago> I don't like microphones being always on either, but it's his phone and his home too. But it's also your home, and he should respect your wishes for privacy when you make them known.
- CDSlice 7y agoWhy should his desire to not have voice assistants in the house trump his roommate's desire to utilize the technology they paid for and want to use? These are both subjective opinions and neither one is better than the other. However I do agree that 3pt14159 should talk to his roommate about it if it bugs him so that they can come to an understanding.
- justinclift 7y ago> Why should his desire to not have voice assistants in the house trump his roommate's desire to utilize the technology ... His roommate didn't have the courtesy to even ask about it up front. :( That being said, his roommate may just have not thought about it. Only way to find out is by starting the discussion and seeing how it goes.
- throwawaysea 7y agoI don’t understand the issue here, and it frankly feels like a manufactured outrage from a minority group of activists. If customers voluntarily release a segment of video to law enforcement, so what? That’s their right. People do so in the interest of preventing crime. I don’t have any cameras myself but I completely sympathize with neighbors who have Ring cameras given the huge uptick in property crime here in the last five years. I’m all for amazon building in facial recognition that works across their network of Ring customers and their cameras. As for the indefinite retention - what do you think happens if you were to give the police evidence that helps nab a criminal in a non-IoT world? They store it and retain it. Why would this be any different?
- 9dl 7y agoTrue What problem if I (anyone) can know where are you now at any point of time, even you newer allow that Or any law enforcement agency can arrest you even if you do nothing and software just wrongly identify your face on crime scene And god forbid if you have not white skin color
- throwawaysea 7y agoWhat does skin color have to with this? That seems like reckless alarmism. Humans are in the loop to validate facial recognition matches. It’s a first pass filter.
- Jamwinner 7y agoEver seen africian or latino men on a grainy camera? It kinda does matter.
- throwawaysea 7y agoRing cameras aren’t grainy. These are new, 1080p cameras, many with night vision capability. And again, if a human is in the loop then you are talking about a problem that is orthogonal to cameras - would a police officer jump to conclusions based on a poor, grainy match on non-IoT cameras or on photographs? Maybe on rare occasion, but the vast majority of the time, they wouldn’t.
- city41 7y agoMost of this tracking can be blocked with something like a pi hole: https://pi-hole.net/ https://pi-hole.net/
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThat won’t things like smart TVs sending pictures of what you watch back to HQ
- city41 7y agoIt depends on the device and whether they use your network's DNS server or their own. In my experience Roku devices are easily blocked with a pi hole, for example.
- jay3ss 7y agoIn my experience with Roku TVs and the Pi Hole, this only works when the Pi Hole is set as the DHCP server. Otherwise, the TVs will only show up on the admin panel sporadically (meaning that blocking the requests that TVs make is not happening). Once I used the Pi Hole as the DHCP server, every request that the TVs make show up.
- tlrobinson 7y agoPi-hole is great, but it's not going to help if the designed purpose of the device is to send data to external servers, or if the device bypasses the network's DNS server, especially with the advent of DoH.
- oceanplexian 7y agoThe right way to do this is set up a VLAN that can't get out to the Internet and is segregated from your own devices except via inbound connections from a Firewall. I've done this with cheap Chinese IP Cams and much other IOT garbage that has either been reverse engineered and/or presents some form of local network access.
- charles_f 7y ago> Wemo says it encrypts all communication between the app, cloud and device and takes privacy and security "seriously." Consider 1) the multiple security breaches that pop up every week, usually following quite dumb holes (unprotected elastic search, unencrypted reset commands, etc.). I have 0 trust in how these companies store my data. 2) the relative longevity (lack thereof) of these companies that still function on investors money, which means that best case scenario your device is now a brick, worst case your data now belongs to a company the likes of Google that doesn't care (or are planly hostile) for your privacy. My wife reaaaally wanted cameras in our house, I took ubiquity and didn't connect it to their "cloud", that's the only thing I somewhat trust
- nontoxyc 7y agoDo you have a smart phone? If so I have bad news for you.....
- Jamwinner 7y agoWhataboutism, giving up on personal freedom or privacy, because it takes effort is not helpful. Your handle betrays you.
- nontoxyc 7y agoOh I haven't given up at all. My cell phone service expires Dec 10 never to be renewed. The massive amount of data your phone collects about you is quite relevant. Thanks for the downvotes which have now throttled my new account, and given me a bit of a bad impression of the community here. Can you explain what you mean by "your handle betrays you?"
- cannonedhamster 7y agoYou're new here. I suggest you read the rules of you haven't (it's to get an idea for how comments are handled and expectations). Comments tend to get downvoted if they do not add to the conversation. I'd give it a bit of time to learn how HN works before making up your mind. I get downvoted all the time, but if you're posting comments of value you can expect your karma to increase over time.
- yumraj 7y agoDuring Halloween I was rather concerned while taking my kids to homes with Ring. Luckily in most cases the kids had masks, but still. Next Halloween those homes will be in my do-not-visit list.
- thebean11 7y agoGenuine question, what scenario are you trying to avoid?
- yumraj 7y agoMy minor kids' photos in some company's database, tagged with neighborhood data which points to where they live, correlated with what characters they like based on costumes, correlated with their age based on their height and so and so forth.. Now if the said company can connect my kids' photos with their identity based on some other database, it will have a lot more info on them to sell ads and for other nefarious purposes. Just one scenario I can think of... There may be others.
- smabie 7y agoDo you actually believe this is happening? No offense, but what you’re describing sounds like a paranoid fantasy. Moreover, I’m sure your kids value candy more than privacy. Also your kids have probably been caught on video hundreds of times at convenience stores, streets, wherever. If you actually wanted to avoid them being on camera at all, you would have to lock them in your house and things would turn out like the movie Dogtooth. It’s not possible to completely protect your privacy unless you make some very hard and costly choices like moving into a cabin in the woods or living a completely isolationist life without internet or contact with the outside world. Unless you want to make these sacrifices for a very dubious benefit, it would probably be better to just worry about something else.
- yumraj 7y ago> Do you actually believe this is happening? What I'm describing is a rather simple system. If I had access to Rings database and Google's database, I can personally create that system and I'm a very ordinary engineer. Regarding the rest of the comment: I'm just trying to avoid what I can and delay it as long as I can to find a healthy balance. Else why worry about privacy at all.
- Thriptic 7y agoI'm confused about the issue with Ring here. The primary complaint seems to be that users can share data with police if they want and that police can then save that data. Ultimately that's product agnostic; someone could easily take footage from any camera and show it to police voluntarily, and users could always be compelled to hand over footage of a crime with a warrant. People have zero control over how neighbors use their personal cameras and I don't see why that should impact personal buying decisions, even if you decide to never share data with police. What's the problem?
- 9dl 7y agoThis is like vaccination Why I have to vaccinate if measles already defeated? Why I have to fear that all my neighbors send* all video to someone? * because you do not know that "some corporation" do not sell your video feed to anyone
- Thriptic 7y agoThat's not my point. If we want to talk about the societal impact of mass security camera adoption, fine, but that has little to do with picking a Ring camera for personal use specifically. The only thing that differentiates this from other security camera products is that it's marginally more convenient for police to get access to data if the user wants to submit it. The advice in the article is silly because it doesn't say "don't get a camera because it's helping to create a police state", it's saying "just don't get this one camera".
- dreamcompiler 7y ago"We take your privacy seriously" has replaced "Don't be evil" as one of the greatest laugh-out-loud lies in tech.
- jstarfish 7y agoIt's most hilarious when the statement is made by some fly-by-night startup with no real assets or obligation to perform. It's seconded only by "Don't worry, I won't put this on the internet."
- nihalot 7y ago>Speaking of Amazon, one of the longest-running and popular tech products, the Kindle e-reader, got called out in the report for not having a lock-screen. Anyone can pick up a Kindle and get right into it. Amazon kindle has a lock screen...