3 ms·
This essay has a very individualist underlying assumption that one person has to do it all. Maybe that's not true? Could a community of hobbyists who share the
by skybrian 7y ago
This essay has a very individualist underlying assumption that one person has to do it all. Maybe that's not true? Could a community of hobbyists who share the same obsession make progress?
If a lot of the effort comes from going down blind alleys until you hit on something, it seems like the work could be pretty easily distributed?
- analog31 7y agoI believe the answer is yes. I'm thinking about the Homebrew Computer Club, the framers of the Constitution, and the musicians who developed modern jazz. It sounds odd, but the Constitution was written by a bunch of rich guys who happened to share a passion for learning about history and politics. When one of their kids got in trouble, the only advice they could come up with was to read yet another old book in Latin. Jazz was commercially viable for a time, maybe into the 1950s, but then the musicians had to adopt a model of playing boring commercial music, and teaching music to kids for a living, while pushing the boundaries of jazz in living rooms and academic music departments.
- cosmojg 7y agoI'm pretty sure you just described modern academia.
- gniv 7y ago> Could a community of hobbyists who share the same obsession make progress? That's a very good point and worthy of its own essay. I'm thinking of how even though there are more scientists working than ever, breakthroughs are still rare. Maybe combining Paul's idea with the idea of bringing such people together via forums/communities would accelerate progress? (And no, I don't think academic labs count). Ah, maybe something like the Polymath Project: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymath_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymath_Project
- CM30 7y agoOf course they could. The success of many fan communities for topics (especially modding/ROM hacking/game development ones) often comes down to a largish group of dedicated hobbyists working together to push things forward. That's how you get stuff like SMW Central or Sonic Retro. Same deal with stuff like speedrunning communities, eSports scenes, etc. Or outside of that field, open source software development and web development in general. How many of the advancements in say, programming language design are made by hobbyists compared to academics?