5 ms·
The only bug here is the default password. After authentication, the fact you can make it charge or dump power into the grid is by design. If I wanted the gr
by londons_explore 7y ago
The only bug here is the default password.
After authentication, the fact you can make it charge or dump power into the grid is by design. If I wanted the grid to suffer, I can do this by plugging in and unplugging a multi-kilowatt heater every few milliseconds too. Residential properties have a fuse (usually 60-100Amps), and anything you can do without blowing that fuse won't damage the grid.
- Proven 7y agoNo it's not, it's also the CT Sensor. What a garbage product.
- londons_explore 7y agoIn the same way a printer is a garbage product for printing a document landscape when you put the paper in the wrong way round? Product works in safe but unexpected ways when not configured according to reality. News at 10.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoThe fast switching ability isn't a bug by itself, but it makes the insecure authentication much worse. Shitty IOT auth does not mix with power electronics. Whether Tesla is worse than other providers in this space is another question, and may well have a depressing answer.
- jacobush 7y agoThe fast switching is still a failure of defence in depth. It could be internally rate limited to some value (which I don't know), and also with some random backoff value so Powerwalls could not be synchronised.
- malux85 7y agoYou don’t see any difference between an individual switching a multi-kilowatt heater every few milliseconds vs a malicious actor automating this attack on 100,000 properties over an entire state?
- londons_explore 7y agoBut if only the true owner of each powerwall had the ability to control it (when the default password issue is fixed), an attacker can't get correlated control like that.
- FeepingCreature 7y agoBut if you add a hardware randomizer for switching times, you guard against all software security issues, not just this one.
- skykooler 7y agoCharging or dumping a single powerwall will not damage the grid. However, if someone causes many of them to do so in sync, the current grid control systems are definitely not going to cope well with that sort of behavior.
- londons_explore 7y agoWithout the default password, an attacker would need to actually own all those powerwalls to pull that one off... At that kind of money, there's better ways to be evil.
- DangerousPie 7y agoTo do that the attacker would need to connect to hundreds (thousands?) of Powerwalls at the same time and figure out the password for each of them. Which means being close enough to each of them to access the Wifi and also figuring out their serial number somehow. How would they do that?
- cstross 7y agoNot feasible for a single idiot to accomplish, but you're forgetting we live in an age of State-Level Actors who distribute very sophisticated malware to attack enemy nation's infrastructure by borking SCADA controllers in e.g. uranium enrichment plants or petrochemical refineries. One may hypothesize about the feasibility of a router-targeting worm (similar to the Moon router worm, targeting Linksys kit) that has a payload that searches for nearby PowerWalls and uses its owners's resources to play guess the password. Getting in wouldn't be fast, but over a period of months such a worm could well gain control over thousands to tens of thousands of powerwalls. At which point, a DDoS attack on national-level grid infrastructure is within reach.
- wil421 7y agoIt would be more feasible to just hack industrial controls or the power company rather than create some worm for a specific router and hope that you can find the 50k powerwalls.
- ncmncm 7y agoYou can't turn hundreds of them on and off in synchrony from your basement.
- bspammer 7y agoTesla has full control over every PowerWall, which means a rogue employee at Tesla would be able control all of them simultaenously. Given what we know about security at Tesla, I have little faith that their internal systems are advanced enough to prevent this.
- jacquesm 7y ago> and anything you can do without blowing that fuse won't damage the grid That's what you'd think. But I have actually done damage to the grid and had that fuse still in one piece. I accidentally connected the -HV line of a neon light installation to ground. After I could see again I realized the power had gone out. I called my boss (landline still worked) who lived more than a kilometer away from the workshop and there too the power had gone out. It turned out my little accident had put a good chunk of the eastern part of Amsterdam out of commission and the fuse was just fine. Fuses react to current, not to power and when you dump a high enough voltage back into the grid your fuse might not blow before you cause something further upstream to trigger to protect the rest of what's connected.
- madaxe_again 7y agoThis is exactly what RCDs are for - with a huge earth leak like that (and therefore L/N imbalance) it would have tripped within milliseconds, before cooking the grid. I am surprised by how infrequently they seem to be used outside of the U.K. - I’ve just rewired my house in Portugal as it was completely unearthed, and just had fuses, no RCDs.
- sib 7y agoFor those in the US, this is what's known as a GFCI (ground fault circuit interrupter).
- jacquesm 7y agoI'm not sure how common these are in an industrial setting nowadays, but back then all big electrical tooling would leak at least a little bit and if you hooked them up through ground fault interrupters those would trip all the time. A typical lathe, mill, plasmacutter or welder (which that particular workshop was full of) would be in the 10KW range with peaks far in excess of that during start-up. I don't remember if we had the office area (where I was working) on protected circuitry or not, that would have been an interesting bit of data. The building still exists, I'm almost tempted to go and have a look. That HV supply was a pretty beefy one by the way, the crocodile clamp that made 'first contact' was gone entirely.