4 ms·
> We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars. I'm curious if people will miss the deafening sound of the raw engines to the point
by dmix 7y ago
> We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars.
I'm curious if people will miss the deafening sound of the raw engines to the point it hurts the business, at least for live shows. I'm not a racing fan (beyond occasionally going to local Indy races) but I've seen a lot of comments online complaining about the whirring sound of hybrids.
There will probably still be combustion cars just for the fun of it. But agreed re: the larger firms not getting as much R&D value from doing it.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoHybrids are fine, there’s not a huge amount of complaint about them in F1. The fully electric engines do sound quite horrible though.
- redwall_hp 7y agoThe Turbohybrid is truly an amazing feet of engineering, and it's incredible how much aerodynamics work into getting these cars to do their thing. They're hitting 230mph, when they fly around corners it's like watching a fighter jet. In contrast, Formula E cars are topping out at 170mph, corner like they're full of cinderblocks, and are still running shorter races to compensate for their lack of battery life. They don't have the same level of racing talent either. (e.g. Verstappen and Hamilton.)
- billfruit 7y agoOTOH, the formula E races, there is lot of close-in action, and more overtaking, etc than in formula -1, might be due to the narrower tracks.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoNever paid particularly close attention to formula E, but the current generation of turbo-hybrids have horrible problems with dirty air (due to the current chassis regs, not the engines). That’s the main reason there’s little close up racing in F1. Following cars take a big hit to their downforce and they overheat quickly in dirty air (just look at Bottas retiring last weekend). This is something the FIA think they’ll fix by bringing back ground effect in 2021. Then you have the seperate problem that there’s only 3 competitive constructors in F1 at the moment (and even then 1 of them is quite far above the other 2 - apart from those races where Ferrari was cheating with their fuel injection).
- billfruit 7y agoFormula-E, infact may be having too much of close-in action, some of the race highlights looks like bumper cars, with more than 10 cars at a single corner.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoI think that’s down to formula e being very-nearly a spec series. Formula e fans get very defensive it not being a spec series, but the regulations (and lack of big time money) make the cars much, much more similar than they are in F1.
- gsnedders 7y agoThe powertrain is pretty free nowadays in Formula E, but the rest of the car is almost entirely spec, which inevitably means there's a lot of similarity. It also means they can spec something where the aero doesn't produce so much dirty air. I think keeping the development limited to the powertrain is the right move for Formula E; there's plenty of other series where money is thrown at the rest of the car, so let developments happen where the series stands out.
- billfruit 7y agoI think the electrical motor whine has its own charm, to which viewers will get attuned to in some time. Anyway most people watch races through televised video, which doesn't convey the sounds of the racetrack with any much fidelity, the sound of F1 broadcasts are rather dull too.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThe full electric motors don’t sound great on either the track or the tv sadly.
- Animats 7y agoPeople will get used to it.[1] In a generation, going to see an internal combustion engine vehicle may be like going to see a steam locomotive. Here's the biggest steam locomotive, restored by Union Pacific, the Big Boy.[2] Behind it is a run-of-the-mill Diesel-electric from about 2005, an EMD SD70ACe. It's there for backup, in case the steam engine fails. It has considerably more tractive effort than the Big Boy. The steam locomotive needs substantial daily maintenance. The Diesel needs to go into the shop once every six months. [1] https://qz.com/232833/this-is-the-sound-of-electric-cars-racing/ https://qz.com/232833/this-is-the-sound-of-electric-cars-rac... [2] https://youtu.be/n_OGGct1r5s https://youtu.be/n_OGGct1r5s
- Baeocystin 7y agoI'm not even a train enthusiast, but that is a gorgeous machine, the diesel being far superior notwithstanding.
- Baeocystin 7y agoExperiencing the intense doppler zoom as the racers fly past is a big part of the experience, no doubt. But I am equally certain the people with a stake in racing will find some way to make the mechanicals sound both good and useful. Auditory feedback is too important to discard. And speaking just as a fan, I'd be thrilled to watch a race that sounded like a Tie Fighter dogfight.
- basementcat 7y agoI have to say after driving a non-gasoline car for a few months, the sound of a loud internal combustion engine sounds trite and tacky, even when I watch a movie.
- Merrill 7y agoJust finished watching "Bullit". It would be amusing to edit the soundtrack to replace the Charger and Mustang V-8 notes with the whir of a couple electric motors. It would be sort of strange to see the tire smoke and hear the squeal of rubber along with an electric motor.