7 ms·
That makes sense. It refocuses the engineering talent. We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars. Just volume. Batteries are gett
by Animats 7y ago
That makes sense. It refocuses the engineering talent.
We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars. Just volume. Batteries are getting cheaper as production volume increases, and faster than expected. Down 80% in the last decade.
What the world needs is a $20,000 electric car comparable to the Toyota Corolla, the best selling car. VW might be able to do it.
- whalesalad 7y ago> We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars. You sure?! Battery technology is in dire need of breakthroughs.
- maxerickson 7y agoWhat do you think is most dire? (three suggested answer would be charge rate, capacity and price) I sort of think that if you look at progress over the last 15 years, factors of 2 aren't dire.
- elihu 7y ago"Less cobalt" is another one in there that the battery industry has been working on, and has made a lot of progress. (It's related to price, but also related to not wanting to be constrained by the availability of a conflict mineral.)
- bitL 7y agoNot just cobalt, there aren't enough rare earth minerals to have battery production at required scale. Extraction of those is extremely expensive process as well, then the question is what to do with used batteries. We are trading one known externality (air pollution) for a bunch of unknown externalities, passing the buck.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoThere are unknowns. Batteries can be recharged hundreds of times and some are already reused for home solar power packs. A bigger unknown is mass battery recycling. Right now prices of batteries are going down so fast there isn't much financial demand for recycling.
- cartoonworld 7y agoI would say "Cold Weather Performance" My understanding is that Lithium based batteries (and lots if not all others) have unfavorable properties at human-cold temps. When at -5 or -10C say they work pretty poorly, slowing charge, discharge and capacity.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoIt's vastly less of a problem if you hear and cool the packs. Until this year only Tesla had that tech, but more ev cars are starting to have that.
- leguminous 7y ago> Until this year only Tesla had that tech The Chevy Bolt (released for the 2017 model year) has a battery cooler and heater. If I recall correctly, the Volt (even older) had a similar system.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoI didn't know that, thanks for the correction.
- maxerickson 7y agoCan you explain what you mean by "that tech"?
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoI refer to heating and cooling the battery pack. When charging, the battery gets hot and it can reduce the lifespan, that's probably why leafs seem to suffer faster range loss. Similarly lack of this hurts range when it's cold.
- maxerickson 7y agoYeah, I understood that, I was wondering what you thought Tesla had that other companies couldn't get.
- foxes 7y agoThere are physics limitations on batteries. I am not sure there will be a breakthrough. Obviously its worth investing in materials research, but for an average person commuting within a city, the technology seems there. The breakthrough needs to be the price.
- newnewpdro 7y agoFor the average person, the batteries need to be recharged at least at a similar rate and range to filling a gas tank. My understanding is this still requires a battery breakthrough, or at least significant improvement. The average person is a tenant without home charging as an option, they require a gas station substitute or better - ideally an obsoleting solution eliminating this waste of time altogether. Imagine if a battery breakthrough enabled 2000 mile ranges with a 5 minute recharge, and effectively unlimited charge cycles so the battery outlasts the vehicle lifetime with zero degradation of range. If such a thing were in EVs today, ICEs would all but vanish practically overnight. I think it's obvious we're still not quite there, but it is getting close.
- lukevp 7y agoGasoline is already super energy dense and a car full of gasoline only gets like 3-400 mile range. Getting comparable range and < 20 min charging time is a lot more reasonable and likely.
- natch 7y agoDon’t absolutely need home charging although it helps. Charging at work or access to fast chargers around town also works.
- ianai 7y agoI really wish batteries were a standardized, removable part. People could join a coop type thing where they drive up, swap in a fully charged battery, leave the old on a charger, and go. The problem is these battery packs tens of thousands of dollars (I think, given costs per kWh) and aren’t standardized. Seems like something the auto companies should be open to standardizing. They’ve done the same with oil - because they had to accommodate the fuel literally burning away. Edit-I get that they’re heavy, but that can be standardized away, too.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThere are plenty of nice to haves in terms of breakthroughs. However if all that improves is the cost, that completely kills ICE cars in the next 10-20 years because the current batteries are more than good enough in terms of range, durability, safety, charging speed, temperature management, etc. Even the price is not that bad actually. Can things be improved? Sure, massively probably. And that's actually continuing to happen for the foreseeable future. But even if that weren't the case, the current market pretty much proves that for a lot of drivers we've hit the "good enough" point. IMHO the main issue is driving cost down further since EVs are still on the expensive side and somewhat scarce. The fact that with total cost of ownership it actually does make sense for a lot of people doesn't matter; we need cheaper batteries. Funnily enough, there are hardly any unsold units in this market. Even at the currently high price, most manufacturers struggle to meet demand and are selling everything they manage to produce. So it will take a while for cheaper vehicles to get interesting enough to produce in volume (margins per kwh are higher on the more expensive ones). Just scaling up production is going to address prices in the next few years. IMHO VW and Tesla are going to be working hard to undercut each other with the entry level price in the next few years. They are both heavily investing in being able to scale production and I expect that they will be getting results from that. Both are aiming for mass production. A few other manufacturers are trying to do the same but I think in terms of volume those two will be competing for the #1 and #2 position for the next few years.
- closeparen 7y agoRange and charging are solved for people who can plug in at home. Using shared/public chargers is a huge time commitment, both in queuing for the charger and going back to move your car off it when it's done.
- dmix 7y ago> We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars. I'm curious if people will miss the deafening sound of the raw engines to the point it hurts the business, at least for live shows. I'm not a racing fan (beyond occasionally going to local Indy races) but I've seen a lot of comments online complaining about the whirring sound of hybrids. There will probably still be combustion cars just for the fun of it. But agreed re: the larger firms not getting as much R&D value from doing it.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoHybrids are fine, there’s not a huge amount of complaint about them in F1. The fully electric engines do sound quite horrible though.
- redwall_hp 7y agoThe Turbohybrid is truly an amazing feet of engineering, and it's incredible how much aerodynamics work into getting these cars to do their thing. They're hitting 230mph, when they fly around corners it's like watching a fighter jet. In contrast, Formula E cars are topping out at 170mph, corner like they're full of cinderblocks, and are still running shorter races to compensate for their lack of battery life. They don't have the same level of racing talent either. (e.g. Verstappen and Hamilton.)
- billfruit 7y agoOTOH, the formula E races, there is lot of close-in action, and more overtaking, etc than in formula -1, might be due to the narrower tracks.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoNever paid particularly close attention to formula E, but the current generation of turbo-hybrids have horrible problems with dirty air (due to the current chassis regs, not the engines). That’s the main reason there’s little close up racing in F1. Following cars take a big hit to their downforce and they overheat quickly in dirty air (just look at Bottas retiring last weekend). This is something the FIA think they’ll fix by bringing back ground effect in 2021. Then you have the seperate problem that there’s only 3 competitive constructors in F1 at the moment (and even then 1 of them is quite far above the other 2 - apart from those races where Ferrari was cheating with their fuel injection).
- perl4ever 7y ago"We don't really need any more technical breakthroughs for electric cars." Did you misread the headline? They are ending all non electric racing. Presumably because they think we don't need any more technical breakthroughs for ICE cars, but we do for electric cars.
- LessDmesg 7y agoWe need another breakthrough though - a massive increase in power production. Current power grids are totally incapable of providing sufficient energy should all cars become electric.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoAnd the benefits go beyond cars. I would like to replace all my tools with electric motors but the energy density isn't there yet. I just got back inside from cutting down a 5.5" diameter tree branch that fell on my electric fence with a battery powered reciprocating saw. I need to go back out when the battery recharges (had to cut multiple large limbs) to get one more branch. I have gas chainsaws, but I prefer the electric saw because it's much quieter, much lighter and easier to maneuver. I'm waiting for the day when I can buy a battery that lasts as long as a tank of gas. I am quite happy that the cost is dropping though.
- theluketaylor 7y agoI have a battery electric chainsaw that would have eaten that branch for lunch. I don't get the chance to use it very often, but it's a joy when I do. It won't take down mature trees, but I'd have to get permission from the city and a certified expert for that anyway. It will limb just about anything. The best decision I ever made powertool-wise was sticking with a single line of tools for both construction and yard tools, so I have at least 10 or so batteries that fit in every tool I own. I have drills, saws, nailers, lights, leaf blower (that thing drinks battery), hedge trimmer, weed whacker, and the chainsaw all ready to take the exact same battery. One thing I've never had to do is wait for a battery to charge.