4 ms·
What I'm saying is that, if ubiquitous surveillance is inevitable (as I believe), then it behooves us to address the antagonistic relationship (to the degree th
by carapace 7y ago
What I'm saying is that, if ubiquitous surveillance is inevitable (as I believe), then it behooves us to address the antagonistic relationship (to the degree that it exists) between our governments and ourselves.
- - - -
As for specific ways the idea applies to surveillance, I can only speculate. The essence would be that everyone is equally under the microscope including law enforcement officers and administration.
- BurningFrog 7y agoOne angle, which you may or may not have implied: We can't stop Google or the government to cover the city with cameras. But we can put up our own camera network!
- carapace 7y agoYou're still taking the stance of "us against them" in a context where "they" have much greater resources than "us". I think that's already a "failure mode" and we have to integrate society and government somehow (or fall into some techno-dystopia.)
- cbnotfromthere 7y agowe have to integrate society and government somehow Out of curiosity, what do you see as "non-integrated" between society and government in Western democracies?
- harimau777 7y agoIs there a way that you can see that we might achieve that? I ask because it seems to me that would require dramatic changes in government and society that are extraordinarily unlikely. I'm not even sure if such a system could be maintained without changes to basic human nature.
- carapace 7y ago> Is there a way that you can see that we might achieve that? Actually, yes. I think something like the "Core Transformation Process" could do the trick: https://www.coretransformation.org/ https://www.coretransformation.org/ I can vouch from personal experience that it works and is pretty profound. I suspect that it could be adapted to work with pairs and groups. > I ask because it seems to me that would require dramatic changes in government and society that are extraordinarily unlikely. I'm not even sure if such a system could be maintained without changes to basic human nature. Ultimately, I think it all boils down to human nature. Technology is just an accelerator or amplifier. Then again, maybe this is the moment where our evolution transcends our baser human nature, eh? "Interesting times." Ciao.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> in a context where "they" have much greater resources than "us". It doesn't matter if Google can install 100 camera networks and "we" only 1. Both systems record the same data.
- harimau777 7y agoThat's a good point that I hadn't thought of much before. One issue that I could see is that there would still be asymmetry in the ability to use the information from surveillance. Someone with access to lawyers, the media, PR people, lobbyists, etc. who knows your secrets is much more dangerous than the average person who knows their secrets.
- carapace 7y agoHmm. It reminds me of how Peter Thiel and Hulk Hogan sued Gawker into the ground. The whole thing, from Gawker outing Thiel onwards, was sordid, but I feel that it was made much worse by Thiel acting in secret. Maybe, if everything the powerful do is just as watched as the little people, that balances things out a bit. I'm not postulating some utopia: I think what we'll get is what I call the "Tyranny of Mrs. Grundy": > Mrs Grundy is a figurative name for an extremely conventional or priggish person, a personification of the tyranny of conventional propriety. A tendency to be overly fearful of what others might think is sometimes referred to as grundyism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs_Grundy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs_Grundy E.g. the Chinese "social credit" system. If that applies to the powerful communists as well as the masses then it might actually work, if not, it's the genesis of Morlocks and Eloi.
- harimau777 7y agoJust to make sure that I'm understanding you: [1] You are saying that there are two issues here: 1. A power inequality that would be created if the regular people's secrets are known but powerful people's secrets were not. 2. A lack of privacy would allow people's private actions to be judged and punished by society if they fail to conform. You are then arguing that giving everyone access to the data/surveillance would solve the first problem but not the second. If I am correct in my understanding, then I think that's a very reasonable argument. Although I'm concerned that even problem #2 alone could create a dystopia. [1] I know intention can be difficult to read in text so I want to make clear: I truly mean this as confirming that I am following your argument, not as an indirect way to say that I think you are wrong.
- leppr 7y agoIt's hard to imagine how a government set to police the minutiae of everyday life of pretty much a whole continent's worth of humans, can not be antagonistic with the majority of it. Even in such a uniform cultural environment as the US, local differences will "always" be too important to make such relations with a state-wide governing entity consensual. High-level principles and policies, sure, but low level policing and surveillance applied uniformly at such a scale can't be consensual.
- carapace 7y ago> It's hard to imagine how a government set to police the minutiae of everyday life of pretty much a whole continent's worth of humans, can not be antagonistic with the majority of it. Indeed! But I think it's important to try. FWIW, I don't postulate that the ubiquitous surveillance is consensual at all, just inevitable. For a lot of people the amount and degree of casual surveillance is already becoming an issue. I'm saying, if we have to have it, how do we want to manage it?