4 ms·
> There's something called general intelligence, humans can do it, and Deep Blue cannot There's no such thing. General is a strong word. Humans can't for exam
by visarga 7y ago
> There's something called general intelligence, humans can do it, and Deep Blue cannot
There's no such thing. General is a strong word. Humans can't for example handle more than 7 objects in working memory. We have an inbuilt limitation to how much complexity we can grasp. Programmers know what I mean.
General intelligence requires a general (infinitely complex and challenging) environment. Without it it will always be a specialised intelligence. Human intelligence is specialised in human survival, as individuals and part of society.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoWell, humans can understand any utterance certainly in their native language and there are an infinite number of those, given that natural language, as far as we can tell, is infinite (you can genereate utterances for ever without ever generating the same utterance twice). That is as general as anything gets. Also, we may not be able to keep some number N of objects in memory simultaneously, but we can definitely reason about an infinite number of objects, like I did above. And if you want to handle more than N objects, you just do it N objects at a time. You can always write things down etc. You can always extend your memory, I mean.
- visarga 7y agoSome systems are impossible to parcel out in sets of N objects we could grasp at once, for example, the DNA code. Think about trying to explain the stock market to an ant. Then scale up, and imagine a similar situation for humans.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI'll need an example of a process we can't explain by cutting it up in chunks though. DNA and the stock market- well, maybe we don't "understand" them as such, but that's not to say we can't, ever. I think it would be very difficult to find a process that _cannot_ be understood by humans, let alon explain why. It'd be a bit of a paradox really. "Let me explain to you this thing that is impossible to understand".
- feral 7y agoAs you appeal to Programmers: do you believe quicksort is a general sorting algorithm? Would it still be a general sorting algorithm if someone had just developed it and used it solely to sort numbers between 1 and 100? It would be. Why do you think you need to a general environment to develop a general algorithm? No one is arguing human rationality is unbounded. But our intelligence generalizes, in a practical sense, to a great many more tasks than any computer algorithm I'm aware of. Mainstream psychologists believe in general intelligence. They even attempt to measure components of it, with good prediction of performance on unseen tasks. I think there's a big burden if you want to argue it doesn't exist.
- visarga 7y ago> Why do you think you need to a general environment to develop a general algorithm? Because intelligence is not intrinsic to the agent but the result of the agent trying to maximise rewards in an environment. In the end the driving force is survival - the agent needs only to survive, any method would do. So as soon as it overcomes a challenge it stops evolving and turns to exploiting. And the list of challenges that threaten survival does not scale to infinity. Anytime you think about intelligence you need to also think about the environment and the task otherwise it is meaningless.
- omnicognate 7y agoYou state this as if it's fact but it's a point of view, not necessarily wrong but not proven either. More to the point, it's circular: "intelligence is not intrinsic to the agent but the result of the agent trying to maximise rewards in an environment" is a statement that the human mind operates on the same principles as ML algorithms. If you assume this, then not surprisingly it follows that ML algorithms can in principle do anything the human mind can do. Not everybody agrees and the question has not been empirically settled.
- itronitron 7y ago>> Humans can't for example handle more than 7 objects in working memory citation needed
- jbn 7y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Magical_Number_Seven,_Plus_or_Minus_Two https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Magical_Number_Seven,_Plus... However stating "can't handle more than 7 objects in working memory" as fact seems a little too assertive to me :) Humans can do it, but are usually not very good at it as the number of items goes up.