3 ms·
This guy still sounds like a scumbag. He's complaining they responded to someone threatening to post people's private info by saying they'd post info on the per
by nailer 16y ago
This guy still sounds like a scumbag. He's complaining they responded to someone threatening to post people's private info by saying they'd post info on the person doing it? Boo-hoo.
If Chris wasn't going to post the info publically (ie, extort POF), then he had nothing to worry about.
As an observer this certainly doesn't make Mr Russo seem any better.
Edit: per below, removed work extortion as posting people's private data might be done for other reasons rather than to make money.
- Tichy 16y agoI don't read anything about an extortion attempt (in this account), what am I missing? I guess it is normal for a security firm to hope to gain some business by exposing security flaws (hey, we found a hole in your site, hire us to fix it). As this incident shows, it is not an easy business to be in...
- nailer 16y agoThat's true, the guy might just post the data to be an asshole, rather than asking for money. Either way, the guy who was cracked is saying if the cracker posts the stolen data, he will post the cracker's contact details to every account. Which is completely reasonable.
- Tichy 16y agoI didn't read anything about him posting the stolen data. I think he specifically wrote that he didn't even steal any data. I don't know whose account is true, but I don't think it is reasonable to threaten somebody who approaches you with information about a security hole, just in case that somebody has evil intentions. In general it seems reasonable in human interactions to not issue death threats upon the first encounter.
- nailer 16y ago> I didn't read anything about him posting the stolen data. Read the post again - the owner of the site is saying he will publish the guys details if he posts the data. If he doesn't post people's personal data, fine. The site owner won't publish his address. If he does, then fair enough.
- Tichy 16y agoHi, nice to meet you. Btw, try anything funny on me, and I'll set the Russian mob on you. How to explain? Yes, strictly logically speaking it is "OK" (no funny actions, no Russion mob). But psychologically I don't think it would be a good approach to human interaction. It establishes an atmosphere of distrust right from the start. You approach somebody and say "you might be a criminal". Or imagine you meet somebody on a party and he says "Hi, my name is soandso. By the way, I carry a gun". How would that make you feel?
- nailer 16y agoI understand what you're saying, but do you have any information that this is how the site owner began the conversation? I imagine we're seeing a small snippet of something larger. I also see the security company guy doesn't dispute that his revelation the site was cracked began with a push for payment to remedy the situation.
- Tichy 16y agoNo idea, really. It sounds as if Russo denies having any data, in which case I struggle coming up with a good reason for POF to issue the warning. But ultimately, I really only know what is written in the two articles. I guess time will tell.
- nailer 16y ago> It sounds as if Russo denies having any data I don't get that impression - I imagine that if he didn't have any data, he'd say so explicitly. If he didn't have data, though, I'd totally agree with your observations. > I guess time will tell. Indeed.
- bad_user 16y agoIf Chris wasn't going to post the info publically (ie, extort POF), then he had nothing to worry about. Considering that anybody can post that info anonymously and that the vulnerability used was there all along, if Chris is in fact innocent then he had plenty to worry about.
- nailer 16y agoMy understanding from reading the post is that the site owner would only publish Chris' private details if Chris published the private data, not someone else.
- gommm 16y agoAnd how would the site owner know if it's Chris or not who published the data?
- nailer 16y agoChris may publish people's private details with his own name attached. It would be stupid but my expectations are low. If, in a short period: * Chris' personal account was used to crack the site * Chris asked for money and was rejected * Chris potentially threatened to leak the data * The data was subsequently leaked anonymously I'd say that there is also a good chance Chris was directly responsible.
- bad_user 16y agoUnfortunately on the web it is hard to establish the chronological order of things. I.e. that data could have already been available to you if you paid the right price since 2 months ago. Correlation is not causation, and we of all people should realize that. I'm not defending Chris, it's just that Mark sounded like a jerk in that blog post and gave a more complicated explanation of the events than Chris; which means there's a good chance Mark got really defensive and blamed the person trying to help.