4 ms·
"The animal parts used for pet food may include damaged carcass parts, bones, and cheek meat, and organs such as intestines, kidneys, liver, lungs, udders, sple
by triceratops 7y ago
"The animal parts used for pet food may include damaged carcass parts, bones, and cheek meat, and organs such as intestines, kidneys, liver, lungs, udders, spleen, and stomach tissue"[1].
These are all byproducts of the meat industry for humans. Humans don't eat any of these animal parts. Pets are doing us a favor by eating all these things that would otherwise simply be thrown away, with a great deal of pollution involved. Eating our leftovers is, in fact, the traditional role that dogs have played in human societies.
Reduction in meat consumption has to come from humans, because we actually have a choice. We can (and do) also control pet populations with spaying and neutering programs.
1. http://www.madehow.com/Volume-2/Pet-Food.html#ixzz662tVEXrH http://www.madehow.com/Volume-2/Pet-Food.html#ixzz662tVEXrH
- eMSF 7y ago>Humans don't eat any of these animal parts People don't eat liver where you're from?
- triceratops 7y agoIt's certainly a less desirable part. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chopped_liver#Chopped_liver_as_an_expression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chopped_liver#Chopped_liver_as... I'm aware that stomachs are used in haggis, or intestines in sausage. That doesn't represent the majority of human meat consumption though.
- undersuit 7y agoBlack Pudding or Blood Sausage is a complete unknown in the US. Liver is reviled. Gizzards are occasionally sold in restaurants as an appetizer, fried. We don't need the offal from our animals because we can just buy a plastic jug of broth from the store.
- 11235813213455 7y agoI know that argument, but the more there are markets dependent on meat production (like pets food), the more meat production will be hard to reduce It's like saying "I just give my throwaway to my dogs", this means you'll more or less consciously get more food because you know you need enough throwaway Or it's also somewhat like saying, "I bought this mango at the supermarket, which came in plane, from another continent. But what am I doing wrong? if I don't buy it, it'll be discarded/wasted". Similar reasoning, the idea is to cut down the downstream demand so we're able to cut down the upstream one > that would otherwise simply be thrown away, with a great deal of pollution involved. That's not necessarily true, there may some efficient ways to compost/bury/recycle organic material, I don't know how precisely for this case. But compared to the amount of energy for making and transporting dog food to each final consumer? The latter is certainly more polluting > Reduction in meat consumption has to come from humans, because we actually have a choice Yes, right, well the vast majority people have the choice to not have pets, for those who need a companion, they can try with a plant, it's less talkative but not less sensible
- 11235813213455 7y ago> [...] making and transporting dog food [...] add to this their packaging fabrication (often in plastics), what it takes later to recycle them, their storage, all the logistics (IT, ..)
- triceratops 7y agoCool, so what are you going to do with all the hundreds of millions of pet animals that already exist? > Similar reasoning, the idea is to cut down the downstream demand so we're able to cut down the upstream one That's an inaccurate, backwards analogy. The accurate analogy would be "my pet eats only mango cores, so I'm going to buy the mango even though its from another continent". Which is patently untrue. Pet food demand doesn't drive human meat demand - human meat demand makes pet food cheap and plentiful. Cutting human meat demand would drive up the price of pet food (because there are fewer castoff materials available) and lead to people re-evaluating how many pets they can/should have. Alternatively, it may also lead to investments in healthy animal-free pet foods, similar to fake meat for humans. Since you're so concerned about the environmental impact of pets, consider also that for many people, their pets are surrogate children. Presumably if they couldn't have pets they might have actual children, which is far more destructive to the environment.
- 11235813213455 7y ago> Pets are doing us a favor by eating all these things that would otherwise simply be thrown away, with a great deal of pollution involved Seriously, just the fact of making their food, the food containers/packages (aluminium, plastics or whatever, not talking about the further recycling environmental costs), end-to-end delivery/transport, all of this has a massive impact, e.g. pets industry in US is $75b/year [1], those pet products and services are generating "a great deal of pollution" Saying pets are environmental-friendly is dangerously wrong, above all in our current state Pets are like a virtual human extra-population (1 billion in order of magnitude), given they are not wild animals participating in the ecosystem (when they are feral, they disrupt it [2]), nor farm animals. Their footprint is probably somewhere between 3% and 10% of the average person, that's still significant You're definitely right about human having to reduce their meat consumption, their consumerism in general, pets included. That's the key to environment problems [1]: https://www.americanpetproducts.org/press_industrytrends.asp https://www.americanpetproducts.org/press_industrytrends.asp [2]: pets/'feral' pets impact on ecosystem https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/the-dog-is-one-of-the-worlds-most-destructive-mammals-brazil-proves-it/2019/08/19/c37a1250-a8da-11e9-8733-48c87235f396_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/the-dog-is...
- triceratops 7y ago> Saying pets are environmental-friendly is dangerously wrong, I didn't say that. They're just not as bad as you make them out to be. > Pets are like a virtual human extra-population (1 billion in order of magnitude)...Their footprint is probably somewhere between 3% and 10% of the average person, So like 30-100 million additional humans? You also didn't specify what country the "average person" is from, whose footprint you're comparing a pet to. Either way, it's not that big - barely 1.5% of the human population in terms of impact. I can only think of two reasons why anyone would suggest "eliminate all the pets" as a serious solution for environmental problems: 1. They already hate pets. Which is a valid (if unpopular) personal opinion, but not a basis to formulate any sort of policy on. 2. They want to alienate people who might otherwise be on board with environmentalism. Because that's what will happen if you suggest to people they have to put Fido to sleep right now to save the planet.