7 ms·
Going to court without a lawyer is new normal for U.S. litigants
- anonu 7y agoPro se plaintiffs should pass some sort of light bar exam (some sort of licensing). And they should be made to pay higher fees to access the court systems. If they lose more than 3 times in a row they should be banned from the court systems entirely. This is only to weed out the aholes who run frivolous suits hoping for an easy pay day when defendants settle to avoid protracted and useless litigation. Also we should get rid of the "American rule" which prevents defendants who prevail to seek damages from frivolous plaintiffs.
- Aloha 7y agoAccess to the legal system is a right not a privilege. Also, this article talks mostly about people representing themselves while defendants.
- turk73 7y agoOur whole system is falling apart. All the protections for regular people are pretty much gone while the elite enjoy freedom from prosecution for major crimes.
- skizm 7y agoSounds like an opportunity. Live chats with lawyers for significantly lower prices than in-person consultation might cost. You can represent yourself, but get guidance from a real lawyer. Sounds like something that already exists since it seems obvious in retrospect, but not sure.
- tryptophan 7y agoThe problem is that non lawyers are not allowed to own law firms. And what lawyer wants to work over low cost chat sitting in a room all day? That's part of why this sort of service doesn't and will not exist.
- wholepointofcc 7y agoMaybe a lawyer who would like to work fewer hours, live anywhere in the world, make his own schedule, etc
- dman 7y agoAny reason why there is a restriction disallowing non lawyers from owning law firms?
- wmeredith 7y agoStrong state bar lobbies
- rayiner 7y agoState bars don't want outside investors or non-lawyer executives directing the conduct of lawyers. (Also, why would you want to allow non-lawyer ownership of law firms? The reason you have corporate structures is to be able to raise capital. Law firms require very little capital.)
- eldavido 7y agoLaw as currently practiced, does not require much capital. You're correct about that. But legal services in general are an expensive, labor-intensive craft industry. Just like any craft industry, there's probably scope for low-touch industrialization alongside high-end bespoke craftmanship. Clothing is a good example of what I'm talking about--rich people have tailors, everyone else buys off the rack. What you have now in law and may other professions only works for the high-touch case. Atrium (google them) is trying to get around this by having a traditional high-touch law firm use a lot of software provided by a standard silicon valley-financed venture capital startup. They're basically laundering legal fees to the startup side via the law firm. I'm not sure of the exact legalities but we need more stuff like this. Access matters. A system that, for completely well-intentioned reasons, attempts to guarantee that everyone only gets the best, means the low end will never have access at affordable rates. It's simple economics. Until practitioners work for free (they won't), or there's some way to do things more cheaply, the bottom won't get served.
- AlexB138 7y agoIt exists. One example is called Rocket Lawyer.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoLooks like an expansion opportunity for Atrium.
- tialaramex 7y agoThis is roughly the fix in place in other systems that inherit from the English system. The McKenzie Friend rules says if you proceed pro se you can nevertheless have somebody who may or may not be trained as a lawyer present to help you by taking notes, prompting, and giving advice not so different from the way a lawyer might use assistants. You have to do all the actual talking, most weight is on your shoulders - you can't use this to basically keep all the advantages of pro se (courts give people proceeding on this basis more leeway because they may not know and understand the rules a lawyer must master) while having a lawyer do everything, but you can at least have somebody to help you and it can be someone legally trained. In the UK this principle is named for a Mr McKenzie who lost a divorce case because the lawyer sent to try to assist him after he lost funding for a "real" lawyer wasn't qualified to appear in front of that court (an Australian lawyer, in an English court), and the court reasoned that lawyer was thus prohibited from attending except to sit in the public gallery. On appeal a higher court concluded that nothing clearly prohibited this lawyer being present as "a friend" of McKenzie and so that's the McKenzie Friend rule. Since they aren't a "real" lawyer it can be a paralegal working for cheap, somebody who has done a year's law school and dropped out, or even just your actual friend who is better at reading and thinking than you are. It all helps.
- Gibbon1 7y agoIt sort of makes sense. A lawyer is authorized to represent someone in court, and what they do is binding. But anyone can give you advice in the court house parking lot.
- eurticket 7y ago[Sort of off topic] From what I've seen in my limited experience with the US court system is split a couple ways: Having no money in a court room results in you: - getting a public defender that is incredibly overworked and underpaid; which results in your case having the dice rolled on if they are able to spend the time to successfully represent you. Having no experience in a court room results in you: - pleading which could have possibly worse results than if you tried the case and played it out naturally. It's not always appropriate for the case, but sometimes a lot of people plead to simply return to work. There is also a lot of cops that linger around doing just this, making you plead by handing you forms saying you need to sign this. Any inexperience in traffic courts for example makes you think you need to sign this, resulting in the scenario above, possible points for a no violation type offense. Having money but no experience in a court room results in you: - retaining a lawyer on your own dime; the money adds up, and if they don't find a way to represent you in your situation quickly, you're going to pay for every adjournment the lawyer may need. If you're searching lawyers, be sure to ask if they have big workloads, because the ones that have a smaller, more manageable number of ongoing cases are going to be your best bet obviously. The thing about too many ongoing cases is the current courts situation dealing with overworked public defenders and lawyers. Not having the time it takes to focus on each case or creating mistakes due to burnout & fatigue. After having even one negative experience with a public defender or lawyer like this, I could easily see people wanting to represent themselves or like in the articles case, they aren't even guaranteed to get one in a civil suit.
- cosmie 7y agoMy last two employers have both offered Hyatt Legal group plans[1] as a voluntary benefit. I signed up because it seemed like a potentially useful benefit and ~$9/paycheck was a tiny enough cost to impulse check that box without much thought. It's turned out to be one of my favorite, most used company benefits. Both companies have carved out different services the plan covers, but in general it has covered every instance I've ever needed to leverage a lawyer for personal needs. And removes the impetus of having to find/vet/pay a lawyer for smaller work like reviewing and drafting legal documents that I otherwise would have done myself and hoped I covered everything well enough. It gives you the benefit of the second scenario, without the unpredictable costs of retaining a lawyer directly. If your work offers it, I highly recommend getting it. [1] https://www.legalplans.com/ https://www.legalplans.com/
- cobbzilla 7y agoHypothesis: the Bar Association is a cartel; limits supply, keeps prices high. The supply of lawyers is artificially constrained, while the volume of civil litigation only grows larger every year. One used to be able to self-study, pass an exam, and practice law. Now it virtually always requires 3 years of law school, at a cost of thousands.
- zeptoon 7y agoSimilar idea w/ doctors (although obviously different specifics) or with any licensed profession really. Yes, you need some form of licensing to keep all the fakes out. On the other hand, should it really require so much time and so much money? On some level it's just raising costs for everyone and limiting supply.
- rayiner 7y agoThere is no "Bar Association." There are 50 different state bars with different rules. The largest legal jurisdiction, New York, requires only one year of law school. California, the third largest, does not require a law degree at all. Interestingly enough, California and New York are the two states with the highest rates for legal services. (Though obviously it's not a cause-and-effect relationship.) There is an American Bar Association, but it does not regulate licensing. It regulates accreditation of law schools, but it was sued by the DOJ in the 1970s for antitrust violations. Unlike the AMA, it has aggressively accredited new law schools. Since 1970, the cumulative number of JDs granted over the previous 35-year period increased by 3.5x, while the number of employed attorneys increased by 2x: https://www.mybudget360.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/35-year-law-degrees-rate.png https://www.mybudget360.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/35-ye....
- vonmoltke 7y agoThe same thing has happened in the areas of engineering where licensure is required. An accredited degree is now an explicit requirement in most states to take the PE exam, and the FE exam is mandatory to start the clock on your experience period.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoLimited? There's a law office on every corner. 2/3 of all billboards are rented by law offices (ok, that's made up, but still...) However, FTA: > Last year, the Trump administration effectively closed the Justice Department’s Office for Access to Justice, designed in 2010 to make lawyers available to everyone. Let's put the blame where it should go.
- neonate 7y agohttps://outline.com/AWGsb8 https://outline.com/AWGsb8
- cheez 7y agoI can relate. Last year's tax return put income at around $600K. So I'm not poor. I have found it very difficult to find a lawyer who is actually interested in getting to a solution rather than dragging it out forever. Here is the cost of filing an agreement negotiated between me and a counter party: $5K. $5K for you to call someone and send over some paperwork. Sure, i can do the work myself but I could do it wrong, and judges don't like that. In fact, a judge initially rejected it until we had a lawyer. Can I even get someone on retainer? No. Because the retainer is used up in the first phone call. Useless waste of money. In my mind, lawyers have gone from people who used to be the bedrock against tyranny and are now rent seekers. Unbundled services are a step forward, but then you lose the benefit of context.
- rhino369 7y agoSo you make 600k and you think lawyers charge too much huh.
- mikestew 7y agoThe way I read it, the legal system charges too much. It isn't the lawyer's problem that the legal system (according to parent's anecdote) requires $5K worth of legal services. DIY isn't even an option. Besides, who cares how much parent makes? If people making those kind of fat stacks complain, how the hell is a barista supposed to get a lawyer?
- cheez 7y agoBingo. I can afford it. Others can't.
- phailhaus 7y agoAre they wrong? $5k is ridiculous regardless if it was as simple as they made it sound.
- rhino369 7y agoI'm sure I could make his job seem easy too.
- mnm1 7y agoI tried to get worker's compensation in Washington state but couldn't find a lawyer anywhere in my area willing to take my case. One actually agreed to meet in person but told me his payoff is based only on the payoff I get. I am not legally allowed to pay him outside of what he would win for me. My payoff would have been lots of physical therapy, doctor visits, and the like. What's 20% of physical therapy? I never heard from him again and ended up just giving up on the case. This was despite or because of I had already had a case in NJ which I couldn't continue due to lack of any doctors willing to take it. It's a great system for the state when you have zero chance of winning. I wonder what Washington state does with all the money it collects and refuses to pay to the people that need it. Other than paying doctors to review cases for ten minutes, violate their Hippocratic oath, and say they don't think the injury is work related when it obviously is.
- Aloha 7y agoAs someone who represented themselves in a similar sort of case, and successfully repulsed the effort to collect, I have sympathy - the civil courts system gives a slight bias to people who have lawyers - like in my case a default judgment was granted before I could even get my filing in (before the deadline), and then was withdrawn when I submitted my filing. Writing a brief is hard if you've never done it before, and there is no easy guide to figure out what you need to do to make the system work for you. I represented myself at first because I couldnt afford a lawyer - then the case just sat in an existing but no filings state - then later because the plaintiff scheduled a court date without notifying me, and I only had a one day notice to drag myself into court.
- jedberg 7y agoThe way legal cases are funded needs to change. You shouldn't have to put up money up front to try a case, but of course then we would need to figure out a way to discourage frivolous lawsuits. But I'm sure it could be done with some sort of escrow system or something. Imagine a system where both parties put in however much they are willing to spend, and then 5% of the pool is given to each side for their upfront fee, and then the rest of the pool goes to the winner of the case, or maybe the judge gets to divvy the fees or something. Then if a big corp and a frugal individual go up against each other, the big corp can put $100,000 in and the other person can put in $5, and neither party gets an advantage because both lawyer teams get $5,000 up front. Or something like that.
- siegel 7y agoThere is significantly more price variation in legal services than many (particularly in this cohort) seem to recognize. I admit my own bias here, but I don't quite understand why many in the startup world feel the need to go to 1000+ lawyer international law firms for early-phase legal services. Do any of you hire Ernst and Young or Deloitte to do your startup accounting? A lot of folks pay a lot of money for legal services because they seem to think they need to hire the same lawyers as Facebook and Google. You hire those same service providers, don't be surprised how much you pay.