4 ms·
We’ve had photographic deep fakes for decades now. How does this fundamentally change anything more than Photoshop already did?
by philwelch 7y ago
We’ve had photographic deep fakes for decades now. How does this fundamentally change anything more than Photoshop already did?
- CamperBob2 7y ago"We've had computers for decades now. How does this fundamentally change anything more than the IBM 360 did?" -- investor being asked for funding in 1978 by a couple of hippies in Cupertino
- philwelch 7y agoDo you actually have a response or are you just being contemptuous and dismissive to amuse yourself at my expense?
- CamperBob2 7y agoWell, if you put it that way... :-P It's well understood that quantity -- and availability to the masses -- has a quality all its own. I do believe we're facing an arms race, in which purveyors of synthesized bullshit will likely fight the defenders of truth to a draw at best, and more likely win. No disrespect intended but I don't agree that your Photoshop analogy is valid.
- alpaca128 7y agoPhotoshop doesn't have a "put this person's face on this other person's shoulders"-button that anyone can use. Creating convincing deepfake videos is still a lot of work, but a couple years ago altering one's face in live streams took also much more effort than pressing a button in a free mobile app.
- Bartweiss 7y agoWe've also had video since before convincing photo edits were available. So people learned that we shouldn't trust a photo of Martians, or a sound clip of the President confessing to murder, but should hold out for video. When footage of Rob Ford doing crack cocaine shows up, we believe it's real. And when an investigative reporter wants a verifiable record of something, they resort to a high-quality video. Even if video deepfakes aren't any more realistic than image or audio fakes have been, they're important because there's no fallback. With perfect-accuracy photo and audio fakes, we'd have to be more skeptical. But with perfect-accuracy photo, audio, and video fakes, we'd suddenly be back to the pre-photography era when there was essentially no way for an untrusted source to convince you that something had happened. Deepfakes aren't flawless, we're not at that point, but the specifics of video are less important than the impact of having some medium which can't be convincingly faked.
- Jamwinner 7y agoFirstly, Ford was already known for that behavior. The bar of legitimacy was low. The famous early nazi fakes; looping rows of tanks and troops to suggest more, was indeed effective, and nothing new. We have been in this space for nearly a century already.
- Bartweiss 7y ago"Video can be used to mislead" is nothing new, but I'll still argue that we're watching a very specific new door open. From the first days of high-fidelity video to the recent past, there has never been a time when someone could fake this type of content. Faking a clear, unbroken closeup of a recognizable person has never been a serious option before this. Even when Hollywood had likeness rights and massive budgets, it resorted to rewrites and old B-roll footage when actors died mid-shoot. When people wanted to slander politicians, even state actors with Cold War budgets, they edited photos, faked audio recordings, or staged candid, hard-to-see footage. In the modern era of CGI and digital video editing, bad actors still resorted to misleading edits and out-of-context clips. This, though, is 20 seconds of clear, closeup video of an incredibly famous face. And the fake was good enough that even placed in an art exhibition centered on something that never happened, some viewers thought it was real footage. I don't share the popular paranoia that deepfakes of politicians are going to start upending democracy; there have always been plenty of people fervently convinced by manipulative video, altered pictures, or simple "somebody said so" lies. What's new is the increasing difficulty of proving truth in the most trusted contexts. Validating even a very narrow claim like "at some point in the past, for some reason, the President said this exact sentence in front of a video camera" is increasingly difficult.
- philwelch 7y agoIt won’t be that difficult, if it’s a digital video that’s cryptographically signed with the White House’s private key.
- CamperBob2 7y ago