3 ms·
> He also drops this doozy: "The real solution is to lift the world’s poorest out of poverty..." > Oh, OK, so it's that's simple then. /s Cheap fossil fuels s
by roenxi 7y ago
> He also drops this doozy: "The real solution is to lift the world’s poorest out of poverty..."
> Oh, OK, so it's that's simple then. /s
Cheap fossil fuels since the 1800s are the major driver of all the exponential growth assumptions in economic models. That and improved technology; but the technology all required cheap energy. "Mine more fossil fuels and try to power through" is a strategy that could work. I don't think it will because I doubt we have enough fossil fuels (I'm a peak-oil-ist at heart) but the idea isn't so crazy that it can't be talked about.
It is a pretty fair thing to point out that focusing on cheap and abundant prosperity might be a better strategy than direct mitigation. I enjoy bringing up France, which has a pretty reasonable approximation of a carbon free electricity grid for military reasons; whereas the German Energiewende (bringing in solar and wind) has so far failed to meaningfully reduce carbon emissions and I think they have some sort of gas pipeline to Russia in the works.
- hootbootscoot 7y agoIt would be extreme negligence to proceed with powering further growth with fossil fuels. We know this. The oil companies paid for some of the first confirmational research on the topic nearly 40 years ago. C'mon, spare me your glazed-eye zealotry for cultural memes that will get us all killed. Show me that you are an adult human capable of exercising judgement and leadership. And no, your statement about "solar and wind failing meaningfully to reduce carbon emissions" is not correct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany Renewables account for 38%, as of 2017 (likely higher by now) and this is clearly an upward, vs downward trend. They are on target, per their pledged Paris Agreement goals. (Compared to the US, in which renewables make up between 8 and 10% of the grid, albeit achieved by purely market forces in the face of reverse incentives (the US subsidizes fossil fuels and currently penalizes renewables in many ways, thanks Trump)) You stand corrected.
- jmull 7y agoI certainly like the idea of focusing on abundant prosperity. But... (1) How? It's not like people haven't been trying to rid the world of poverty all along. It's useless to suggest this without better solutions than have/are already being attempted. (2) How does that solve the problems around climate change? The gap in the logic here is immense. This just changes the subject away from climate change to something else.
- roenxi 7y ago(1) Keep doing what we are doing. The current approach is working very well. (2) Wealthy people can cope with climate change; it is the poor people who will suffer. Reducing the number of poor people is an effective way of reducing the overall suffering. > This just changes the subject away from climate change to something else. I was quite explicit about that - the France v Germany example is a great example for saying that pro-environmental strategies have actually not had a great record for making emissions drop.