6 ms·
I still dont understand this, if SIM Swapping were the problem then it isn't SMS 2FA that is insecure, it is the telco themselves, and specially US Telco. In m
by ksec 7y ago
I still dont understand this, if SIM Swapping were the problem then it isn't SMS 2FA that is insecure, it is the telco themselves, and specially US Telco.
In many other part of the world, Switching Sim ( SIM Swapping ) requires to show proof of identification, as well as written form and signature.
And any CS accessing customer information are instantly logged, there is no way paying $1000 dollar to change or SIM Swap without going through the proper procedure, ( Should there be one ) and they will be fired for any misconduct.
SMS might not be the best solution to security, but for average Joe, that is near 4 billion of Smartphone users they are better than nothing.
May be had Apple created their own MVNO this problem could be solved.
- rando444 7y agoSMS 2FA is insecure because companies implement it in a way that it becomes one-factor. Forgot your password - reset your password - get an SMS When there is no second factor involved, it's not 2FA despite people calling it that.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoI agree the problem is that implementation of a backup for 1FA ends up coming back to the phone. But often the target service has no certainty of which mechanisms are going where. They send to your email.. They use TOTP. They use Oauth, etc, etc. What other things accounts go back to either your SIM or someone stealing your phone, SIM and all? Even U2F will fall down this hole soon since everyone wants to implement it on phones! Will the attestation certs for phones say multipurpose device that is probably involved in other factors?
- balboah 7y agoYou can also show fake ID at a competing telco sales point and tell them you want to move the number in Sweden. Happened to me that depending on which provider the call was coming from, sometimes it would reach me and sometimes not.
- phicoh 7y agoAs far as I know, the service telcos provide is the ability to make calls, receive calls, send text messages, receive them, etc. Telcos don't get paid to securely provide SIMs. They make hardly any claims regarding the security of your calls, text messages, etc. So it is rather odd to hold telcos reponsible for the failure of some security mechanism they where never part of.
- dtech 7y agoSince someones phone number is incredibly important for all sorts of reasons, it is definitely the companies fault for making it so easy to hijack.
- phicoh 7y agoThat's rather bizar logic. An obligation to keep something secure comes either from a specific law, or from something specific in a contract. The fact something is important to you, and you failed to negotiate that in your contract, doesn't mean that the company providing the service is somehow required to take that into account.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYou're telling me that offering a service comes with no guarantee of the service? If I'm paying you, but you're no longer providing the service to me, but to some third party, how is that upholding the contract? If you order food in a restaurant and someone takes the food from the waiter before you can have it, what would you want the restaurant to do?
- phicoh 7y agoThe service is that you can receive messages. The service is not that you are the only one who can receive those messages. If someone commits fraud and obtains a SIM with your number then the telco is in general quite willing to correct the error. Maybe they will even given you an extra copy of the messages that were lost. It's like going to a fast food restaurant and later complaining that the meat is of low quality.
- vinay427 7y agoVarious countries besides the US (often other "Anglo" countries) don't require any identification to get a SIM card, while as you mentioned some countries require identification and sometimes even more steps like physical address verification. In my experience as a tourist, these additional steps are sometimes unnecessarily complex and are often somewhat of a hassle. An argument can be made that this hassle is worth it for security concerns (which is what they often tend to be sold as) but personally I find it less reasonable for preventing against SIM swap hacks when there are many alternatives to SMS 2FA.
- 2rsf 7y ago> to get a SIM card getting a new card is not the same as swapping
- michaelt 7y ago> it isn't SMS 2FA that is insecure, it is the telco themselves I have some rope at home. The manufacturers specify it's blue, 8mm, polypropylene and for 'general use' but they don't say anything about its strength. Cost about $5. If I lift something with it and it breaks, is it the rope's fault, or my fault for selecting the wrong rope? SMS is the same way - is sim jacking the telco's fault, or is a company using SMS 2FA as dumb as lifting a piano with my $5 rope?
- tinus_hn 7y agoIs it acceptable for anyone to be able to just walk into a store and hijack your phone number? Guess it’s just your fault your grandma now gets to talk to a crook when she calls you.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y ago> In many other part of the world, Switching Sim ( SIM Swapping ) requires to show proof of identification, as well as written form and signature. Minimum wage employees don’t give a shit. Always exploited.
- trollied 7y ago> May be had Apple created their own MVNO this problem could be solved. I think the only reason they haven't is because they don't want the customer service headache that running & supporting a network generates. Bad signals, stolen phones, billing etc. Urgh.
- hansjorg 7y agoIt's not just SIM swapping that's the problem. The protocol/network used for international SMS (SS7) is supposedly very insecure and can be used to hijack messages.
- Ajedi32 7y agoFor the purposes of 2FA implementations it doesn't matter why SMS is insecure, only that it is insecure. Since it's probably not within your power to force your telco to change their insecure business practices, avoiding relying on them for 2FA is your only alternative.
- anarchodev 7y agoExactly this. Also want to add that phone numbers were never really meant to function as identity providers. For this reason I think it's important not to use the real number on your cell phone for anything -- VOIP numbers are best if the only method of 2FA offered is phone number.
- cartoonworld 7y agoNo, In addition to what you have mentioned, and sibling comments have noted about implimentation, it is SMS that is (has been? --But i can't find info if this has been remedied) insecure as well. This is the "SimJacker" whitepaper describing technical means of hijacking among other games. https://simjacker.com/downloads/technicalpapers/AdaptiveMobile_Security_Simjacker_Technical_Paper_v1.01.pdf https://simjacker.com/downloads/technicalpapers/AdaptiveMobi...
- rasz 7y agohaha ;-). Yes, you need a signature and legal document, both checked by your random, always late and in a hurry EMS courier when receiving the new SIM package. Same when starting new CC.