3 ms·
> It's a bit like medicine: we're not going to stop treating people just because we don't understand the mechanism of action and can't guarantee that it will wo
by kortilla 7y ago
> It's a bit like medicine: we're not going to stop treating people just because we don't understand the mechanism of action and can't guarantee that it will work.
Yet medicine actually focuses on scientific measurement of effects. They don’t just throw their hands up and go, “experiments that affect people’s lives are too hard.”
- throwaway2048 7y agoExcept there is a direct, causal link between treatment and life and death, or at least quality of life. Economic or social studies are a lot more nebulous.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoSeems weird to accept that "quality of life" is a straightforward measure, but insists nothing of the like can be created for social studies.
- jfengel 7y agoRight, and that's what this is about. They're doing the experiments. I didn't say they were too hard; I said they were hard. But it's early days of learning how to do experiments, much like medicine was not that long ago.
- hangonhn 7y agoThere's quite a bit of medicine that "works" but the specifics of why it work isn't well understood, especially in mental health. One of my friends who works in the mental health pharmacology field told me one of the challenges with the field is measuring the efficacy of those drugs. What do you do? Do you ask someone if they are feeling better or happier? Is that trust worthy? Or is it too fuzzy? Was it the drug that did it or something else? In that regard, they face similar challenges as the social sciences.