2 ms·
> For example, electric cars require large amounts of copper, cobalt, and nickel. We don't produce enough to electrify all cars, so that means we need new mines
by WorldMaker 7y ago
> For example, electric cars require large amounts of copper, cobalt, and nickel. We don't produce enough to electrify all cars, so that means we need new mines.
Cobalt comes "free" as a waste product from copper/nickel mining. So long as copper/nickel get mined, there will be cobalt. There doesn't currently seem to be any threat right now of a shortage in the cobalt market (even in some hypothetical of "electrify all cars immediately" worst case). On top of that, we already have proven Lithium Ion battery formulations that don't need Cobalt (it's about a quarter of batteries on the market), and the ones in current production that use Cobalt typically list their usage of Cobalt in ppm [parts per million].
> Also, recyclability of these batteries still needs a lot of work.
Current car-sized batteries have been showing real world usage statistics at hundreds of thousands to just shy of tens of millions of cycles in their "first use" in cars, not enough have made it to secondary markets yet to have reliable statistics, but current beliefs are that secondary usages in devices such as "power walls" and grid supplementations should see tens of thousands of cycles at reduced capacities. In the tertiary stages where recycling becomes useful/necessary, we know that Lithium, the vast majority of battery compositions, is entirely recyclable (and a known entity, we've doing that much for a while). We aren't currently good at recycling Cobalt, but we haven't needed to do any such thing in bulk to date because A) again, most car batteries are still in their first lives, which are showing to be 15-20 years in some cases, B) Cobalt is often measured in ppm so a tiny percentage of battery composition, C) Cobalt is a "waste product" from other mining and economically the incentives just do not align to recycle it when it just keeps coming out of mines whether or not we need it.
Not that pessimism isn't useful, but another possibly helpful reminder we may be better off than we think we are.