3 ms·
Even if you believe that Hitler has taken power (which I am sure some people believe), what is your analog of "civil liberties of X 'temporarily' curtailed"? W
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Even if you believe that Hitler has taken power (which I am sure some people believe), what is your analog of "civil liberties of X 'temporarily' curtailed"? What specific event do you point to that you think is equivalent to that?
- zapita 7y agoAgain, I believe Nazi Germany is a useful analogy. I do not think it’s a perfect analogy, nor do I think that “actual Hitler” has taken power. I do believe that civil liberties have been curtailed. For example: - Not long ago, citizens from certain Muslim countries were unilaterally barred from entering the country. The implementation of this ban was so rushed as to be reckless. - ICE has systemically violated the rights of citizens and legal asylum seekers. This includes harassment, illegal searches, illegal separations of families, numerous incidents of brutality, etc. - Notoriously, we have built concentration camps along the Mexican border. Asylum seekers are detained there in conditions which undeniably violate their civil rights. Children have died because they were denied basic care. Hundreds of children have gone missing entirely while under US custody. - In many US states, access to safe abortion has been severely limited by unconstitutional legislative action. - Violence against American muslims, jews, black Americans, lgbtq, native Americans and other minorities is at an all time high. Many of the most violent attacks were perpetrated by people who openly confessed to have been inspired by hate speech coming from the President and his allies. The effect of this is that targeted citizens are less safe, and less likely to exercise their rights to free speech because of fear and government-sanctioned intimidation. Here the parallel to the Brown Shirts in Germany is quite strong. - Trump just pardoned convicted war criminals. This sends a strong message to US military personnel that gratuitous violence and cruelty against civilians will be tolerated. This obviously violates the civil liberties of the people whose liberties our troops were supposed to protect in the first place.. - The EPA has been gutted along with major regulation of corporate pollution. If you consider access to clean air and water a basic civil liberty, then those have been severely curtailed as well. - Voter suppression, both legal and illegal, is on the rise. Gerrymandering, the abuse of Senatorial powers, abusive purging of voter rolls, the disenfranchisement of former felons, voter intimidation, and outright fraud, all add up to restricting US citizen’s right to fair representation. - The Judiciary is under attack on two fronts: the current GA is dismantling any semblance of independence from the President’s partisan interests. And the Senate majority is packing federal courts with unqualified loyalists. The result is that we may no longer have an independent judiciary in a few years. Hopefully I don’t have to explain the consequences of that for our civil liberties.
- pjc50 7y ago> what is your analog of "civil liberties of X 'temporarily' curtailed"? https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/sep/24/detained-us-largest-immigrant-detention-trump https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/sep/24/detained-us-... ? (As the article points out, this did not begin with Trump; the illiberalisation of America dates at least to 2001 and the permanent war footing thereafter.)