4 ms·
The funny thing is that it happens at every single level, no matter how ridiculous or serious the topic is: football teams, battlefield vs call of duty, right v
by lm28469 7y ago
The funny thing is that it happens at every single level, no matter how ridiculous or serious the topic is: football teams, battlefield vs call of duty, right vs left, climate change, pro/anti abortion, religions, &c.
Put two people long enough in the same room and they'll find a reason to kill each other. It reminds me of that podcast about tribalism: https://youarenotsosmart.com/transcripts/transcript-tribal-psychology/ https://youarenotsosmart.com/transcripts/transcript-tribal-p...
- catalogia 7y ago> "Put two people long enough in the same room and they'll find a reason to kill each other." That's a rather negative perspective. Sometimes they'll become inseparable friends to the very end.
- indigochill 7y agoAs I understand, becoming inseparable friends is vastly helped along when there's someone else to hate instead, suggesting there's always got to be a "bad guy". In my course on the EU the instructor asked why the American colonies formed into a cohesive nation while the EU is still largely fragmented. Of course, there are a lot of answers to that, but I pointed out the colonies had to unite to stand against Britain. The EU hasn't had any external entity to unite against, thus the focus remains on the differences between the member states rather than the goals they share.
- catalogia 7y agoSurely at some point in your life you've bonded with somebody over something other than a mutual hatred for another person.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIn politics the opinions actually matter. It makes no lasting difference to the world if Team A wins against Team B in a sports event. But public policy choices are absolutely fundamental to personal opportunity, personal safety, quality of life, and financial stability. There are objectively right and wrong answers in politics. There's also a hierarchy of importance in policy, with some issues making far more of a difference to all of the above than others. Misunderstanding policy cause and effect and picking and promoting the wrong answers will lead to objectively bad outcomes for at least some other people, and very probably for you personally. The toxicity doesn't originate in social media. Social media simply amplifies the toxic effects of industries of dishonesty - from PR, astroturfing, and manipulated academic and media narratives, to calculated and deliberate hostile attempts to focus conversations on low-impact but high-emotion issues, and to split populations along tribal and narrative fault lines.
- bluGill 7y agoNOTHING is objectively right and wrongs in politics. Right and wrong depend on your personal morals. By my personal morals there are objective rights and wrongs, but every moral I have there is somebody will disagree. For things like planed killing of otherwise healthy adults there is a large enough agreement that it is a wrong and we send those who disagree to prison. Note even there how many qualifies I had to put in - every one is required to get around a large fraction that will disagree.
- harimau777 7y agoI think you are confusing whether people agree on right and wrong with whether their is an objective right and wrong. It's entirely possible that there is an objective right and wrong but that some people are mistaken as to what it is.
- bluGill 7y agoPhilosopher's have not been able to agree on anything. Religion and culture can agree on many right and wrongs, but there is nothing universal across other religions or cultures.
- harimau777 7y agoThat doesn't mean that there is nothing universal, just that religions and cultures don't always agree on what it is. Even then, there is generally agreement that murder is wrong, and that murder means killing innocent people. The disagreement is generally over what constitutes "innocent" and "people". Similarly, pretty much everyone agrees that stealing is wrong, the differences are just in the details of what constitutes property and associated rights.
- watwut 7y agoWe do not send those who disagree about killing adults to prison. We send there those who we think actually killed people. That is massive difference practically.
- rapind 7y agoTotally right, however I think it depends on the people. Like can we all agree that developers who use 3 spaces to indent are going to a special place in hell? 2? Sure, nice and compact. 4? Hipster but OK I can handle it. Tabs? Well you're probably the most technically correct even if I don't like it. 3? I'll cut you man. I can get along with most people, but everyone has limits.