3 ms·
> This is “moral grandstanding” — publicly opining on morality and politics to impress others, and so to seek social status. This is much better known under th
by Izkata 7y ago
> This is “moral grandstanding” — publicly opining on morality and politics to impress others, and so to seek social status.
This is much better known under the name "virtue signaling"...
- dilaudibble 7y agoThe authors address this in the paper. They claim that MG is different to VS as VS is a colloquial term used to criticise people on social media, whereas MG “has been extensively explored and defined in philosophical literature”.
- mcguire 7y ago"Our basic contention is that one grandstands when one makes a contribution to public moral discourse that aims to convince others that one is “morally respectable.” By this we mean that grandstanding is a use of moral talk that attempts to get others to make certain desired judgments about oneself, namely, that one is worthy of respect or admiration because one has some particular moral quality—for example, an impressive commitment to justice, a highly tuned moral sensibility, or unparalleled powers of empathy. To grandstand is to turn one's contribution to public discourse into a vanity project." https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/papa.12075?campaign=woletoc https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/papa.12075?... I personally strongly disagree that anything from 2016 can be "extensively explored and defined in philosophical literature".
- brailsafe 7y agoOnly on the internet I think, if you happen to spend a lot of time in particular areas iver the last 5 years.
- daenz 7y agoUnfortunately that has become a loaded term because it was only used by "one side" against "the other side." Often that term is rejected and ignored outright because of this. But yes, I agree.
- jariel 7y agoVirtue Signalling is used by everyone, just in different ways. The intersectional left however, is generally the group with words and actions powerful enough for it to be highly visible, at least at the national level. In local terms, say at the level of school/church/neighbourhood I think, paradoxically, it's people of very conventional/classical morality that might have more power via shaming etc.. Whereas at on CNN for example generally one's 'private sex life' is out of bounds (unless there's something illegal) ... I think that in social circles, there's a lot of gossip and talk about that kind of stuff. To me the results of this study are obvious, but it would be interesting to point out how it may have nothing to do with the validity of the moralisation. 'Virtue signallers' may often be right, but it's the ugly sanctimony and lack of context that I object to.
- tantalor 7y agoOh, look how smart you seem to be! Knowing the "much better known" names for stuff. Hey everybody, this guy gets it. Teach us more, oh wise master.
- dang 7y agoWhoa, please don't flame other users like that! regardless of how wrong or annoying another comment may be. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tantalor 7y agoIt's a joke on "virtue signaling"!
- dang 7y agoAh ok. Thanks for clarifying. Intent doesn't come across with these things! But I did notice that your comment history hasn't been flamebaity, which is why I gave you the mild version of the standard mod reply.
- teh_klev 7y agoMaybe stick /s on the end. Poe's Law and all that, and these days folks just scan read things then twitch rather than reconsider a post in its best possible light.
- bmm6o 7y agoMy understanding of "virtue signalling" is that it contains the notion that the proclaimed position isn't sincerely held and that it is professed solely as a performance for others. "Grandstanding" is being loud and performative about your beliefs, but carries no connotation that the beliefs are not sincere.