4 ms·
Hello Professor Hewitt, Hmm...I don't quite understand your criticism, particularly as you yourself point out that "every important scientist (including Einste
by mpweiher 7y ago
Hello Professor Hewitt,
Hmm...I don't quite understand your criticism, particularly as you yourself point out that "every important scientist (including Einstein) made numerous errors", and go on to describe some of those errors.
The fact that Alan is a towering figure who has contributed more to this field than I (and most people) can ever hope shouldn't mean that we cannot point out where we believe such an error was made, should it? That's not how science, even computer science, is supposed to work.
As a matter of fact, it seems even more important in the case of such an influential figure.
Of course the article points out that it was (a) a "brilliant" (quote from the article) construction and (b) the fact that it was wrong wasn't really Alan's fault, because he didn't have any large computer networks to look at, so (c) using the same brilliant construction with up-to-date inputs gets you a better answer.
The claims you make about the impossibility of things that are clearly being done seem a bit strange.