4 ms·
My first thought about Rural Alabama is how much I'd hate that sociopolitical environment (I'm black) Granted I googled Sylacauga and the first line on their w
by BoorishBears 7y ago
My first thought about Rural Alabama is how much I'd hate that sociopolitical environment (I'm black)
Granted I googled Sylacauga and the first line on their website is
>Sylacauga (syl-a-cau-ga) is a progressive community where all the pieces fit.
So they're aware of the image which is a pretty good sign...
But I'm not doing these cities/towns that are "progressive" oases in vast deserts of backwards communities ever again.
At the end of the day, the people in backwards communities are still numerous. They still end up dominating state-level politics.
Instead of embracing change and the wealth that not being a backwards backwater can bring, they actively fight it and if anything become more emboldened in trying to band together against the "common enemy"... that is progressive people (read: non-white, non-straight and/or non-Christian).
In a more ideal world, the answer to these people would be exactly what Sylacauga seems to be, forcing them to co-exist with people who are in the 21st century, but I now feel like the answer is to let these areas wear themselves down. When the pie of wealth grows and these people are locked out for their views, they'll eventually lose the power they had.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoMuch of rural Alabama, especially through the central and southwestern parts of the state are majority black with most local governments and social institutions dominated by the local majority population. The real big problems in those areas are poverty and medical care. Even if you're well off, living in an impoverished community does negatively impact your quality of life. And you really don't want to have a medical emergency out there. The medical facilities can be few and far between with middling quality.
- pm90 7y agoI somewhat relate to your view as a non-white POC. However, I don't think > they'll eventually lose the power they had. would do much to change the situation. Georgia, Virginia and Texas are states that are being fundamentally changed because of the influx of progressives from both rural areas and urban coasts. The fastest way to change seems to be to move to these places and use the democratic process to introduce real changes, and these folks will have no choice but to change their views or retreat to more rural areas of their states (usually its the latter). The other aspect is that a lot of the southern states do actually have sizeable populations of African Americans...I really do hope that we don't just ignore them as successive generations seem to have done....
- theflyinghorse 7y ago> Georgia, Virginia and Texas are states that are being fundamentally changed because of the influx of progressives from both rural areas and urban coasts. Why are progressives moving en mass so much that that are able to replace the local population and fundamentally alter voting patterns? What is happening to drive people out like that? I'm not an American for the record and likely am missing parts of the context here.
- fetus8 7y agoHigh cost of living in urban centers.
- bobthepanda 7y agoInternal migration to the south and west of the US has always been strong due to generally cheaper housing and strong jobs growth (though wages are lower to match.) The advent of mass air conditioning made the climates much more bearable to live in, fueling economic expansion. Otherwise it’d be too hot and humid.
- foogazi 7y agoThey don’t have to replace everyone, just tip the scales enough
- tropo 7y agoThey made their own states too expensive, by choice, and then couldn't live with the result. They are moving to affordable places that vote against taxes, regulations, and government services. Oddly they continue to vote for the policy that caused them to migrate, and so eventually they must migrate again.
- BoorishBears 7y agoIf no one progressive lives in these states, there's no foothold for change, I agree with that. But it's like a see-saw, injecting wealth while the ride is still tipped so strongly towards these backwards communities is counter-productive. It's adding more weight (money) to the other side than it is to the side of progressives and African-Americans already living there. Especially when you consider even in these "progressive" oases, it's not uncommon for gentrification to disproportionately affect African Americans, and even end up destabilizing otherwise functional communities of black people. I want to see us set up the progressives who live in those states for success with federal actions like fighting gerrymandering and national political movements before pouring money into those states. The old guard losing power as wealth left their states has very much been a large part of why places like Virginia have been able to transform. You need the backwards incumbents to be weakened enough not to take your wealth generation and turn it back on the group you're trying to uplift.
- mepiethree 7y agoYou can find an apartment to buy in any neighborhood in Chicago for $200k. Same spaces in SF would be around $1M. Maybe Chicago would be a palatable alternative to rural Alabama?
- BoorishBears 7y agoDon't get me wrong, I don't want to imply there are no alternatives to the major tech cities. I don't even want to imply there are no backwards communities right on the doorsteps of the major cities that everyone just kind of sweeps under the rug.
- mepiethree 7y agoYes! Palo Alto vs. East Palo Alto being a good Bay Area example of your latter point ;)