4 ms·
The proposed way to achieve editability sounds like it is inherently at odds with the page description model of PDF, which is in turn exactly what gives it its
by lxgr 7y ago
The proposed way to achieve editability sounds like it is inherently at odds with the page description model of PDF, which is in turn exactly what gives it its stable output on different platforms.
A PDF renderer basically needs to be able to rasterize fonts and paint glyphs on a page/screen – that's it. Layout, spacing and even kerning are left to the producing application.
The project mentions the lack of robustness inherent to web-based document formats, but I'm afraid that any alternative would either be severely limited in the range of achievable output documents or would end up reinventing the wheel.
As an analogy: SVG has been around for a while, and yet we still use PNGs and I don't see them going away anytime soon.
Maybe what we really need is just more widespread support of ePub, and maybe some extensions for more "document-like" (instead of book-like) functionality in editors for it, and potentially support for an embedded rendered PDF for layout stability?