3 ms·
Ask HN: Is VC entering a bubble?
With such low interest rates in traditional investments, do you think startups and venture capital investments are becoming a bubble? Why or why not?
- iqster 16y agoYes. Why? Fundamental economics. Money is essentially free. People need to invest somewhere. The stock market is already over-valued. Gold and other commodities seem to be overvalued as well. It doesn't seem like the US will raise interest rates (that's what the market thinks ... see the 10 year rates on Treasuries). In theory, if you take money and make it somewhat productive (ala a hot-dog stand), you have improved things. However, start-ups are not like hot-dog stands. I think that a failed start-up produces less value than an average run hot-dog stand. A few startups are certainly creating value. But their valuation is being bid up by the hordes of people with cash to invest. Case in point. Facebook is not worth 50 billion. If Kevin Rose invests near this valuation, does he expect to get a x2 or x5 on his capital? Seriously?? Don't give me the "if each user was worth 10 bucks a year crap". Until FB figures out how to monetize in a scalable manner, I remain a skeptic. That's just my opinion :)
- dtby 16y agoMore interestingly, is the VC market inherently inefficient because of the accredited investor rules? Is there a reasonable proxy for "startups and venture capital investments" in the open market which would allow one to parlay insight into cold hard cash?
- damoncali 16y agoIt's not a bubble - it's the consequences of the dramatically lowered cost required to start a technology business. Money is just not worth as much to an entrepreneur as it used to be, so the valuations are higher. Not only do entrepreneurs not value cash as much, but the capital required to open up shop as a "VC" has come down as well. The result? Lots of money chasing entrepreneurs who are basically indifferent to investment dollars (at least when compared to past times). A bubble implies a greater fool - I think what we're seeing is a fundamental shift in the economics of high tech startup finance. Not that the above line of reasoning would make me comfortable in the shoes a VC, but they're at least making a rational bet that the model will shake itself out and leave realistic profit for everyone. It's not a pump-and-dump scheme like it was in the late 90's.
- tomrod 16y agoInteresting. Do you think we will see micro-VC's start up, like Prosper or Kickstart for startups?
- damoncali 16y agoI think we already have. They call them Super Angels, and YC is one of them. Prosper style? I don't know. I think that would already have been done if it were viable. In other words, something would have to change fairly dramatically for us to see that.
- tomrod 16y agoWhat typically keeps a person with average wealth from investing in venture capital?
- imkevingao 16y agoPossibly. I mean in theory, correct me if I'm wrong since I haven't read any books on this type of stuff, VC investments always have a bubble like structure attached to it. Every VCs nowadays want to find their Google or Facebook, so more and more LP's are investing into VC funds so all of them can get a piece of the social network / internet hype. If the VC firm's name is not Sequoia or Kleiner Perkins, or any well known firm name, it is probably not going to attract a lot of top tier entrepreneurs, but since they've already raised a fund, they got to invest somewhere. In a way it's good for entrepreneurs, since there's a lot of available cash, but at the same time a lot of entrepreneurs are getting money for the "same ideas". So let's say 100 secret deals are made this month on new social networking sites. After a period of time, only one company will achieve high success, 4-5 are surviving and resilient, and the rests are gone. All this stuff is theory, but I'm sure if someone really digged into this, it can show that there's a lot of flaws with the VC industry. But one thing keeps it going, which is winning. I mean once you start to win like Sequoia and KP, life is good. So I believe if there's competition, there's what people like to refer to as a bubble. Since not everyone can be a winner, there are always a lot of losers. I doubt there is going to be another dot com bubble burst, that just happened to be a crap load of bad investments faltering at once. In essence there's no that much theoretical difference between dot com bubble and the great depression. It will just happen again and again because of Gordon Gekko's favorite phrase " Greed is Good"