4 ms·
I'm not a fan of government-funded media. I think I'd like my media to remain separate from the state just as much as I'd like the church to remain separate fro
by chrisco255 7y ago
I'm not a fan of government-funded media. I think I'd like my media to remain separate from the state just as much as I'd like the church to remain separate from the state.
Local news was always done through a newspaper. Some large cities are able to have and support television stations, but the newspaper is the old fallback.
The digital newspapers I've used mostly suffer from poor design. I pay for WSJ. They've got a great app, it's streamlined and easy to browse. Most local papers don't have this. Their design is not consistent from city to city. I think local papers suffer from a UX problem as much as they do an ad revenue problem.
I think journalism needs a Spotify-like model to sustain itself in today's world. Users should be able to pay a single subscription fee and browse open content (with none of the partisan platform bias we've seen from the tech industry lately) and revenue should be split according to how much of a user's time is spent on each source. Tipping should be embedded as part of the platform.
Ultimately, this is a business model problem, not a government problem. Churches are able to function entirely on donations. Local journalism should be able to make a similar case, if they're willing to put the work in to rebuild their industry.
- choward 7y ago> I think journalism needs a Spotify-like model to sustain itself in today's world. That's an interesting idea. I love getting paywalled by some web site because I clicked a headline, especially when it's some a local news site or some other site I'll probably never visit again. I'm not signing up to read one article that I might not even like. I thought pay per article might be a good idea, but that would just encourage click bait. And if the article is terrible, I still have to pay. However, with a subscription to all of the news none of this would be an issue as long as it was reasonably priced.
- rapnie 7y agoBlendle works like this, aggregates news sites, offers subscription (10 euro/month) and deals out micropayments under the hood (moved away from pay-per-article). They operate in US, Netherlands, Germany. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blendle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blendle
- dr_dshiv 7y agoI disagree. The church is not comparable to the media. We need innovative ways to equitably pay for our economy of attention. Ideally a way that would create a market incentive for producing local news that people read. I think the revenue sharing tax on Google/Facebook is pretty fair and clear.
- Proven 7y ago“Equitably” doesn’t mean what you think it means. Equitably means no one gets gov funding - no one is favored just like in the case of organized religion. > Ideally a way that would create a market incentive for producing local news that people read. Government doesn’t create market incentives, it destroys and distorts them.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoYou have an interesting perspective. But governments can create, or shall I say foster, market incentives -- and not just by getting out of the way. A cap and trade program illustrates that, as does mandatory product labeling. Markets and governments have more akin to flowers and gardens than to oil and water. They need each other to function. Or do you have another truth to share?
- chrisco255 7y agoI disagree. North Korea has newspapers. North Korea has media. Are its citizens well-informed? Of course not. The media is literally owned by the government. And in that case, you get pure propaganda. The reason for separation of church and state is that religion and politics are both powerful forces that influence people. If one entity controls both, it inevitably causes a loss of liberty. The press has the power to shape narratives and influence massive amounts of people based on how they frame a story. That is powerful, and it needs to be treated as a power that should remain separate from the government. There should always be competing narratives in a free country. Democracy doesn't die in darkness. It dies in uniformity.
- dr_dshiv 7y ago
- ignoramous 7y ago> I think journalism needs a Spotify-like model to sustain itself in today's world. Do Brave Attention Tokens fit this model?
- mtberatwork 7y agoDoes your average artist even generate enough revenue to support themselves off of Spotify payouts? Unless you have some high level of popularity, I'd imagine most artists pull in less than minimum wage from Spotify. I can't imagine funding the entire staff of a newsroom with this kind of model is even remotely viable, let alone at the local level.
- base698 7y agoThe average in almost any domain doesn't earn enough. Pareto is a real thing and creative output doesn't scale linearly. Some people are Linus and most are not. True especially in the arts where the median can't get a job writing SQL queries for a Telecom.
- chrisco255 7y agoYes, if they can hit critical mass. I'm rooting for them.
- threatofrain 7y agoShould local journalism also receive special tax benefits like the church? Otherwise in the discussion of viable business models that seems to be an omission.
- abathur 7y agoI am also not a fan of government-funded media. But this sounds a lot like a rediscription of the dystopia we're already rushing towards. The advertising model that floated newspaper journalism was circulation. Whether you read 1 story, 10 stories, or the whole paper. I don't think the genie can be put back, but online ads and going viral on the platforms are already both games measured in eyeball-seconds. Rewriting society around eyeball-seconds is probably not a good idea.
- vegardx 7y agoNews organizations struggle to survive even with government subsidies. Perhaps the problem isn't the business model, but the fact that there is no business. In an open and free country the government benefits from having a well informed population, just like it benefits from having a healthy population. Being well informed shouldn't be based on how willing you are to pay for it. At least not on a national and regional level. It's not true that churches are able to function entirely on donations. They have all kinds of tax breaks and take government subsidies. And tipping? I bet anyone in the service industry in the US can tell you why that's a bad idea.
- scribu 7y ago> In an open and free country the government benefits from having a well informed population How exactly does the government benefit? If by "well informed" you mean "the population knows the information the government wants it to know" then sure, I get that.
- zkid18 7y agoMedia is a low-margin business, that historically was always affiliated with government. I agree with you - it should be a government problem. With various self-publishing media emerged recently it became easier to spread your unbiased opinions. However, I don’t read American press, so not quite familiar with the state of media business in the country. I subscribe to the economist and the ken (the great source covering VC news in SEA and India). I want to reward journalist for high-quality material. They don’t have a fremium reading and the subscription is quite high indeed. As for Spotify-like business model, I bet Medium has something in their roadmap. Also, out of States there multiple interesting products that try to to pay-once-read-all business-model: Yandex Zen in Russia and SmartNews in Japan.
- lordgrenville 7y agoBlendle (https://blendle.com/getpremium https://blendle.com/getpremium) does this. I signed up a few years ago but don't use it much. With paywalls getting stricter (eg NYT, New Yorker) maybe its time has come.
- belorn 7y ago> I think I'd like my media to remain separate from the state just as much as I'd like the church to remain separate from the state. Complete separation of state and church is pretty rare. They often gain some form of tax benefit. Their buildings often holds central position in towns and if there property tax then they are exempted. If there are government initiatives for children, for arts, or other social benefits then the church is often a common actor in the end. Very few religious organizations that I know depend exclusively on members fees, and I live in Sweden where church being separated from the state is a common perception by those who live here. If we apply this to local media then a government supported model would not inherently be controlled by the government. You could have government information awareness initiatives with criteria for the actor to have independent journalism. The local news agency would then bid for the job.
- teddyh 7y agoAs long as there is something which can unambiguously be referred to as “the church”, the state will favor it. It’s not necessarily a question of insufficient separation, it’s more of a de-facto-monopoly situation.
- jeegsy 7y agoThe idea of the separation of Church and State is a long standing and well-established tradition. We dont expect much interference in this case. Not so for if a similar thing is applied to local press vis a vis the govt. Interference is virtually guaranteed given the nature of politics. In any case, tax breaks for local media would be insufficient to solve their revenue problems.
- Dirlewanger 7y agoNot only is a church's model incomparable to a newspaper's, they also have the very nice benefit of not being taxed...