4 ms·
Meh. Not being easily editable is a feature, not a bug. Sometimes you want to send out a finalized document and want to make 99% of the users unable to edit th
by kccqzy 7y ago
Meh. Not being easily editable is a feature, not a bug.
Sometimes you want to send out a finalized document and want to make 99% of the users unable to edit them. That's what PDFs are for. Imagine lawyers needing to send out a finalized contract. Or a graphic designer sending out the finalized design. Or an electronic book that has gone through the work of the author, the editor, and the publisher and needs no more changes. PDFs give an air of permanency and stability when so many other digital formats are malleable.
- chungy 7y agoAgreed, 100%. Literally the only reason I make and send out PDFs is because they're effectively read-only. (It's not really perfectly so, but nobody should claim it's a tamper-proof document...)
- dvdkon 7y agoSo if you didn't care about the recipient editing the document, you'd send what format? Pretty much anyone can view a PDF and see it as intended, not so much with DOC, DOCX, ODT, INDD...
- klint 7y agoThat objection, and others, are addressed in the project FAQ[1]. It's already possible to open and edit a PDF in various applications. [1] https://editablepdf.org/faq/ https://editablepdf.org/faq/ >But isn’t the whole point of PDF that you can’t edit it? No. The fact that standard PDFs are difficult to edit is more of an accident than a feature, as PDF’s roots are in printing, where only final-form documents needed to be transmitted. Many people believe PDF to be “impossible to edit,” but beware: minor edits in PDFs, such as swapping figures on an invoice, are trivial — therefore you need other technologies, such as digital signatures, to verify that your PDFs have not been tampered with. More extensive edits, however, are more difficult, as they require the document’s logical structure to be automatically detected, and this is an error-prone task. [...] >Are you sure we need such a editable PDF format? I believe one of the most important benefits of PDF is its concrete, solid state. The idea of Editable PDF stems from a real-world need to improve the efficiency in the way that we work with documents. Today, the only editable file formats are those native to the applications that generated documents, and none of these formats guarantees the layout to be preserved in the same way as PDF. Furthermore, despite improvements in compatibility, using a native file format still often requires the recipient to be using the same software (and often the same version) of the application, which may not be available. PDF’s largest asset, its rock-solid visual presentation, will remain, and editable PDFs will be backwardly compatible with the current installed base of PDF viewers such as Adobe Reader and Preview.
- kccqzy 7y agoThe FAQ explains things well: making minor changes, although difficult is still possible. I have even personally changed multiple PDFs; I find qpdf to be a great tool for that. But making changes large enough to require reflowing the text is almost impossible. I do not consider my objection addressed. If anything, that FAQ further emphasized the current difficulty of editing PDFs and they are only proposing to make things easier. So no one is really objecting to the fact that currently changing PDFs is hard. Whether or not that is desirable though, is a separate matter, one that the FAQ does a poor job explaining.
- Angostura 7y ago> The fact that standard PDFs are difficult to edit is more of an accident than a feature, as PDF’s roots are in printing, where only final-form documents needed to be transmitted. I disagree with this - I was an IT journalist when PDFs came out and all the blurb at the time was centred around the advantage of being able to create a document and know that it could be displayed by anyone, irrespective of machine, OS etc while retaining visual fidelity. PDF only became a thing in the print production world quite a bit later. For many years, you were making sure your printer got the QuarkXpress Files and all the high-res asset files collected together into a single folder and zipped up.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoPDF was based on PostScript, a system that was created for digital printers. The big selling point of PostScript was that your output would look the same whether you were printing on an Apple LaserWriter or a Linotype.
- Angostura 7y agoIndeed. Postscript is great for printers. The fact that the PDF was created in addition was because a comparable system was needed for human eyeballs.
- hnick 7y agoAbsolutely agreed. My day job is in the print industry so I deal with a lot of PDFs and they are perfect for print production for this reason. Their main complaint seems to be structural metadata (this text is a heading, this text is the same font as that text on another page, so if you can change one the other should change, etc). I don't think at that point it's worth keeping PDF in the name, it'll confuse people. I certainly don't want to receive files built like that since printers tend to have memory issues with bloated files. You can already do minor edits anyway with some knowledge (the spec is pretty easy to read) and some programming or a hex editor. The only issue I have is fonts, they are very complicated.
- vbezhenar 7y agoThis is sounds like security through obscurity.
- alpaca128 7y agoThis isn't about security, it's about making sure that a text document is formatted exactly the same on all devices, whether it's a PC, a phone or a printer. The PDF file is reliable in that aspect while other widely used document formats like .doc and .docx are basically a gamble, even if you open the document on the same machine with the same software. The same with presentations: You just need to open the file in a slightly different software or version or encounter one of the countless bugs and suddenly you have a picture overlapping with text.
- blunte 7y agoBy your argument, PDF fails. I can provide examples of PDFs that look different on different devices.
- kccqzy 7y agoPDF gives you all the tools to make sure that doesn't happen. No one prevents you from shooting yourself in the foot by writing a bad PDF that doesn't adhere to common good practices. For example it is technically possible to make a PDF with text without embedding fonts. Doing that is a bad idea. By your argument, any programming language, no much how safe it purports to be, fails because they allow you to write bugs.
- blunte 7y agoThis was about the claim that PDFs provide consistent/identical document representation on every device. Few programming languages claim to provide bug free programs, so your example is irrelevant.
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> This isn't about security kccqzy's comment was clearly referring to security.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoAnyone else remember all the times a government released a censored document only to have someone discover that they could just remove the black bar layer and see the original text with hardly any difficulty at all?
- rapsey 7y agoGreat feature
- jjohansson 7y agoThis is not because PDFs can’t be redacted, but was instead caused by crappy redaction software.
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> Sometimes you want to send out a finalized document and want to make 99% of the users unable to edit them. That's what PDFs are for. Imagine lawyers needing to send out a finalized contract. That is not what PDFs are for. PDF is, well, a Portable Document Format. It is not convenient to modify a PDF, but PDF is not securely resistant to modification (discounting its cryptographic features [0]). Its resistance to modification is a side-effect of its design, not a primary goal. An attacker will be able to modify your PDF. This gets easier every year, as we'd expect. That doesn't matter, though, as an attacker can always recreate the document, with whichever changes they wish. (Again, neither of these attacks will work if you use cryptographic signing.) If you want secure assurance of authenticity, you use cryptographic signing. No excuses. If you're a lawyer, I'd hope you aren't placing any stock at all in the inconvenience of modifying a PDF. [0] https://acrobat.adobe.com/uk/en/sign/capabilities/digital-signatures-faq.html https://acrobat.adobe.com/uk/en/sign/capabilities/digital-si...